Being Too Restrictive With Kids' Diets Could Backfire
I've written many blogs where I talk about trying to provide my kids with a diet that is as healthy as possible. Sometimes I get strange looks from family and friends when they see what my almost-3-year-old eats for lunch. I think my choices have made veggies and other healthy foods a normal part of her day. She doesn't question why she's having broccoli with her sandwich because she likes it. But I will be honest, for a while after I stopped nursing and she started eating like a "real" person, I got VERY stressed out about her diet. I never wanted her to have anything that was too high in salt, too high in sugar, too processed, etc. I felt like she could never eat what everyone else was having. She didn't notice when she was younger, but as she got a little older and all of the other kids were having juice and chips, she didn't understand why she wasn't having some too. That's when I decided that unless I wanted to alienate her and give her a complex about food, I needed to relax a little.
Don't get me wrong- I'm still pretty strict about what she eats at home or what we'll order off of the kids menu at a restaurant. But new research from the Center for Childhood Obesity Research at Pennsylvania State University shows that being too restrictive about the foods children eat can actually cause more weight gain. The highest weight gain was among girls who considered their parents most restrictive about eating certain foods. The study followed 200 girls from age 5 through age 15.
Although it's easy to control things when they are younger, eventually your kids start going to play dates, school and other places where you're not around to monitor every bite they take. And kids who have very restrictive diets at home are more likely to go crazy with junk food when mom's not looking. So I've loosened up a little, and decided to teach my kids the importance of healthy foods, both by what I serve them and what I eat myself. But I also want them to understand that treats are okay now and then, and if your friend is having some M&M's and you'd like to enjoy them with her, it's not the end of the world.
What do you think?
Don't get me wrong- I'm still pretty strict about what she eats at home or what we'll order off of the kids menu at a restaurant. But new research from the Center for Childhood Obesity Research at Pennsylvania State University shows that being too restrictive about the foods children eat can actually cause more weight gain. The highest weight gain was among girls who considered their parents most restrictive about eating certain foods. The study followed 200 girls from age 5 through age 15.
Although it's easy to control things when they are younger, eventually your kids start going to play dates, school and other places where you're not around to monitor every bite they take. And kids who have very restrictive diets at home are more likely to go crazy with junk food when mom's not looking. So I've loosened up a little, and decided to teach my kids the importance of healthy foods, both by what I serve them and what I eat myself. But I also want them to understand that treats are okay now and then, and if your friend is having some M&M's and you'd like to enjoy them with her, it's not the end of the world.
What do you think?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > How to Disinfect Your Home -- Naturally























Comments
My main reason for taking this approach with my daughter is because I have struggled with my weight my whole life and I didn't want her to be burdened by the same issues. I wanted her to learn early what healthy choices are and why it is best for your body to make these the main parts of your diet and only have the "not so good" stuff occassionally.
I also agree that balance is key. Restricting the treats that all kids are drawn to (ice cream, cookies, etc.) can only lead to them feeling the need to sneak it or overindulge when they have the opportunity. - 6/30/2010 8:59:56 AM
I was a healthy eater, for the most part. I loved fruit & veggies (except when the veggies were boiled until unrecognizable). I ate more salad at dinner than anything else. My mom thought that that was unhealthy and pushed me to eat more meats and starches. I do love pasta. I did know when to stop, but Mom's house was part of the "Children are starving in (insert yout third-world country here). You should be grateful and finish everything on your plate" club. Odd juxtaposition, no? She wanted me thin, but wanted me to clean my plate.
I still struggle with weight to this day and have matabolic issues from the crazy diets Mom put me on until I was 17 years old. Now, I do all my own cooking and eat only what I want in moderation. I don't deny myself any foods and don't over-indulge, except for my veggie pig-outs. - 5/18/2010 12:14:13 PM
Mom cooked from healthy whole foods the whole I time I grew up. Processed foods were considered a treat; not much was around except for some cookies and ice cream. When getting together with friends, I helped myself to junk foods as much as I wanted and really enjoyed them, and never gained weight until I hit 40 yrs. Later, as an adult, I can be a glutton, which has led to being overweight. Only my brother, when he was younger, had a weight problem of the whole family. Years later, the rest of my 4 siblings are suffering from hypertension, as did Mom and Dad. 2 of my siblings are overweight (not obese), the other 2 just slightly overweight.
I grew up next to my uncles family of 5 girls. My aunt was a health nut, and kept no processed treats in the house. Almost daily, my cousins would come over and beg a cookie, as Mom usually always had them in the house. Of the 6 adult cousins, all of them are at healthy weights and look terrific.
In both cases, all of us kids were pretty active growing up. We didn't watch much tv and our sedentery activities centered almost exclusively on sitting and reading books. In both families, we were allowed to only eat 3 square healthy meals and a bedtime snack. You made sure you didn't miss meal time.
- 3/23/2010 5:47:20 AM
I wish people would realize that balance in all things is the ongoing challenge of life!
As my kids get older, I try not to say "no" to everything "bad". Rather I attempt to educate them or at least suggest that they can have "that" if they also take "this", and then I tell them why. I try to keep it in the science of carbs, fats, proteins, etc.
I also do not make the point(s) in front of their friends. - 3/22/2010 8:31:38 PM
the kid wants to eat non-stop and gets emotional when he is told no.. (he will eat cereal, or eggs and toast, then wants bread, then more cerel, then lunch after eating breakfast right away. then a snack, then more bread, then dinner..(keep asking even though he is is full, seriously his stomach expands, gets tight, . he will eat until he throws up.. done it several times.) He doesn't understand when he is full... any help ... message me plz "
It may be hard but don't let him eat like that even if he cries & has tantrums etc. You are not starving him so it's best to break that now before it really becomes an ingrained habit in him. You are not abusing him or mistreating him by not letting him eat constantly, just like how you teach him healthy verses junk teach him that eating constantly is not good for him also. It does sound like that can develope into emotional eating that will become a problem if left unchecked. You just have to buckle down and say no. - 3/3/2010 5:25:45 AM
just because my friends son is drinking red pop and kool aid at age 3 doesn't mean I am going to let this happen... red dye causes hypersensitivity in boys, and parents wonder why their kid isn't listening to them... b/c of all the sugary foods..(not to mention what it does to their teeth!)
as of now, my son will pick good foods over unhealthy ones, even if kids around him aren't... he will say, "that isn't good for me" (i lead by example )
sure alot of parent ask why i wont give him what everyone else wants to give their kids, simply b/c he should be taught a healthy diet in a healthy way (not it will make you fat to eat that.).;
sure a couple mm's wont hurt... but there are some things that i think we should put our foot down on (pop, and more than 1 or 2 junks a day) b/c a healthy, behaved, and smart kid, is better than having one like everyone else...
(ever notice what some of those treats do to your kid?)
He is only 3 now, but i pray that these things i am teaching him become habit, and wont have to worry about him becoming a "closet" eater.
One thing i have difficulty all the time with is portion control...
the kid wants to eat non-stop and gets emotional when he is told no.. (he will eat cereal, or eggs and toast, then wants bread, then more cerel, then lunch after eating breakfast right away. then a snack, then more bread, then dinner..(keep asking even though he is is full, seriously his stomach expands, gets tight, . he will eat until he throws up.. done it several times.) He doesn't understand when he is full... any help ... message me plz - 2/12/2010 12:18:46 PM
Same went for my ex sister in law...she did it to her eldest daughter all the time...I kept advising her that one cookie is better than none in this situation...she didn't believe me. I told her she'll slim down after she moves out of here...she again didn't believe me...when it happened...she was finally glad to sit down and talk about what a closet eater is
It's okay to encourage a person to have less bad foods, but don't try to remove them completely. - 2/10/2010 7:15:57 AM
Teaching our children by our own examples is most important, by #1 including lots of veggies and fruits and avoiding processed foods and #2 also by teaching them about eating in moderation. Two lessons that will take them a long way in living a healthy lifestyle in the future. - 12/13/2009 2:03:50 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›