Is Combining Your Workout Better For Your Diet?
I get questions like this all the time: “Is it better to do my strength training and cardio workouts on different days, or can I do both on the same day?” Typically, my response is that it really doesn’t matter in the long run. I recommend doing whatever works best for your schedule. But a recent study in the Journal of Sports Science and Medicine shows that when it comes to your diet, it might be better to combine your workouts.
For 16 weeks, study participants did cardio, lifted weights or combined the two while recording everything they ate. Those who did both their cardio and strength in the same workout ate an average of 517 fewer calories per day by the end of the study. Researchers theorize that combining your workout may cause a shift in hormones that control appetite, and therefore you don’t feel as hungry.
Do you notice a difference when you combine your workouts versus doing cardio and strength training on separate days? Is it any easier to stick to your diet? Do you notice a difference in your weight loss progress?
For 16 weeks, study participants did cardio, lifted weights or combined the two while recording everything they ate. Those who did both their cardio and strength in the same workout ate an average of 517 fewer calories per day by the end of the study. Researchers theorize that combining your workout may cause a shift in hormones that control appetite, and therefore you don’t feel as hungry.
Do you notice a difference when you combine your workouts versus doing cardio and strength training on separate days? Is it any easier to stick to your diet? Do you notice a difference in your weight loss progress?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > Helpful Tips for Running Your First Race






















Comments
But when I work out in the morning, then my appetite is more normal. - 10/6/2010 5:36:39 AM
http://www.curvesinformation.com/ci
rcuit-demo.php - 12/3/2008 9:39:41 AM
I lift weights 4 days/week in the morning, but I also go for a walk/jog for 30-45 minutes over my lunch break every day, plus I always do 5-10 minutes of cardio (usually the rowing machine) to warm my muscles up for weight training, so I've never really done "just" weights. Even in high school, we ran sprints for 20 minutes before going into the gym to lift. - 9/25/2008 10:13:32 AM
Now I still combine, but differently. I do 10 minutes of cardio, then 3 sets of weights, then a set of ab work, then everything all over again. It keeps me from getting bored and I think it keeps my heart rate consistent over the hour; more so than doing one first then the other. It's also great because sometimes I feel like I can do my cardio a little harder in 10 minute increments instead of over the full 30 minutes.
When I'm consistent about exercising, it seems to work well for me...I lose weight very consistently. I think that's because I'm building muscle which helps burn calories even when I'm not working out! - 9/24/2008 3:55:00 PM
Perhaps I am clutching at straws, ready to blame anything but myself for the gain???
- 9/24/2008 1:35:02 AM
It works for me. Some days the strength intensity is subservient to the cardio--for example if I do spinning, then a pilates class polishes it off. Or if I do the super intense circuit training with heavy weights, then the cardio won't be quite as intense so I'll have done something like some finning laps in the competition pool beforehand.
But I love doing them both the same day.
Paula - 9/23/2008 11:40:24 PM
Well, yes and no. You can do cardio and ST on the same day, but you DO NOT want to do strength training in consecutvie days in a row because this will not allow your muscle to be built up. It will have just the opposite effect, your body will consume the muscle and make it smaller and that is not how you want to go.
So you can do cardio every day of the week if you want, but only do ST every other day to give your muscles a chance rest and repair the cells and tissues which you have torn down by the ST.
I know that when I do serious exercise, such as yoga, my muscles are exhausted, and so I will do cardio the next day and then I feel better to do other ST after my "day of rest". - 9/22/2008 8:25:18 PM
- 9/21/2008 11:10:54 AM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›