The SparkPeople Blog

7 Things Your Daughter-in-Law Wants to Tell You

By: , – By Denise Schipani, of Woman's Day
9/12/2011 6:00 AM   :  28 comments   :  13,360 Views

See More: family, woman's day,
Stereotypically, a wife's relationship with her mother-in-law can be tense—even competitive in some cases. There’s a good reason for that, says stress-management expert Debbie Mandel author of Addicted to Stress: You have two women who love the same man, albeit in different ways. Add to that the fact that a daughter-in-law may find it difficult to express herself when an issue arises with her mother-in-law, whether out of fear, respect or frustration, and you've got the makings of one stressful family dinner. However, according to Mandel, a healthy relationship can form between the two women. It just takes time––and a lot of mutual respect. So we asked some real-life daughters-in-law to tell us what they feel they can’t tell their mothers-in-law, and had experts weigh in on how best to resolve these conflicts so you can both start having a happier family life today.

1. Trust that I know how to raise my children.

The topic of children––how they’re raised and disciplined––can quickly become a battleground because it's an emotional topic for everyone. When a mother-in-law makes comments, her daughter-in-law may feel like she’s being judged, says Mandel. “Meanwhile, your mother-in-law may feel as though you’re doing things differently than she did to undermine her.” LeAnn* has diminished this type of intrusion by simply responding to her mother-in-law’s suggestions with, “They are fine” or “We raise them differently.” She’s on the right track, says Mandel. “Daughters-in-law should try to respond neutrally—‘That’s an interesting point’—rather than negatively, which only fuels the fire.” Meanwhile, she says, “A mother-in-law is smart not to offer unsolicited advice. If your daughter-in-law asks how you used to do things, tell her and leave it at that.”

  2. Don’t come over to our house unannounced.

For years, Anne* and her husband lived just blocks from her in-laws, who were fond of ringing their doorbell on Saturday mornings—without calling first. “It felt so intrusive!” Anne says. “This is the time for the husband to get involved,” says Elizabeth Lombardo, PhD, psychologist and author of A Happy You. What sounds shrill coming from you can sound like good advice from their son, as long as it’s said politely. “Suggest he try something like, ‘Mom, we love seeing you, but Saturday mornings are so crazy with the kids. Next time, call first so we can be sure the gathering is more relaxed.’” Remember, she just wants to see you (and your kids, if you have them), so if you assure her that you also want to spend time with her, perhaps the unannounced knocking will come to a halt.

  3. Leave religion out of it.

Claire’s* in-laws, who are Catholic, openly fret to her and her husband about how they have yet to baptize their son (something they have no intention of doing), which causes uncomfortable feelings all around. Here, both sides have to come to the realization that the question of religion might never be settled. “It may be a core value for the in-laws, so if you reject their religion—especially for your children—they may feel personally attacked,” says Mandel. The best you can do is to be firm in your own choices, but also be clear and reassuring that you’re raising your children to be good people.

4 more things your daughter-in-law wants to tell you
!


Stories you might like:


Do you think saying these things would help or hurt the relationship between mothers- and daughters-in-law? Would you add anything else to this list? 


Provided Photo


Click here to to redeem your SparkPoints
  You will earn 3 SparkPoints
 

NEXT ENTRY >   This Week's Healthy Headlines

Comments

  • 28
    This article kind of makes me laugh. I have a really wonderful relationship with my MIL and in fact, all of my in-laws. They are my family as much as my blood relatives are. So yes, that means sometimes we lock heads (families always do) but overall, my MIL is super supportive of me and I of her.

    We don't have any children yet so I don't know if things will change once we do but honestly, I just don't see that happening. My MIL is a wonderful woman who does occasionally offer advice and suggestions but she only does so because she has more experience. She never expects that anyone should follow her rules and her rules only.

    The only thing I see being an issue is that my MIL is very Catholic and my husband and I are not particularly religious. I'm sure we'll have no choice but to baptize our future children. I know how much it matters to her so it's not a battle I want to get into. - 6/25/2012   10:49:44 AM
  • 27
    I think my mom and grandmother had a great relationship; my dad told me that at the time when my parents were newlyweds, his mom pulled him to the side and said to him (in her cute little Swiss accent) "If you two ever get divorced, she stays and you go!" I am not a daughter-in-law yet, but am confident when the time comes, I will be able to have a good relationship with my mother-in-law, thanks to the example set by my mom and grandmother. - 9/20/2011   6:02:32 PM
  • OKIEGIRL75
    26
    My MIL is great. Even though it took me time to accept her quirks and yes we all have them, she totally rocks. She is truly a blessing. Is everything perfect no. But that's okay. She is a great listener and I value her advice. - 9/13/2011   9:31:51 PM
  • 25
    Here is a list of things your MIL would like to tell you.

    Just as you don't want me criticizing your cooking and housekeeping, I don't appreciate it when you criticize mine either.

    While I love the grandkids and want to spend time with them, please don't always bring them over when they are sick.

    The husband you crticize in front of me, happens to be my son, and I love him as much as you love your sons.

    I don't appreciate being compared to your mother any more than you like being compared to other people.

    Remember, someday you will be the mother in law, and no matter who much you plan on being the perfect mother in law, you daughter in law will always see you as her husband's mother. - 9/13/2011   6:29:47 PM
  • BAMAJAM
    24
    There is another side to this topic, and I thank DAMETEMPLAR for presenting it! The "in-law" relationship should be one of mutual respect. Employ the golden rule for your conduct. There are boundaries to every relationship, and kindness is too often in short supply. (If you have a jealous DIL--who is unkind to you, take heart that one day she might wear that MIL title and get a dose of her medicine!) lol
    PS.. I hope that Dametemplar's message gets published in a national magazine; fair is fair. - 9/13/2011   2:21:50 PM
  • 23
    Watching many different relationships over my years, one of the "old" sayings really seems to be true.

    A son is yours until he takes a wife.
    A daughter is yours all of her life.

    My mother-in-law was amazing to me. When at her house, she kept prompting my wife to make sure I had tea, was comfortable, etc. I felt like a young prince.

    At my mothers house, it was completely the opposite. My mother kept prompting me to to make sure my wife had tea, that I did 60+% of watching our two sons, etc.

    We've only met two other couples in our life who have had that sort of relationship. - 9/13/2011   12:43:54 PM
  • 22
    I totally agree on the not dropping by or telling anyone how to run their own home. The daughter-in-law/son-in-law should be free from interference on their own turf.
    But there should be a caveat: when in my house, it is my rules. So, just because your children jump on the furniture at home: not in my house. Just because they can watch TV while eating, at my house we all sit at the table and talk to each other over dinner. Just because you find their interruptions amusing, I like to finish talking to one person before I give my attention to another.
    At your house I will eat while laughing over cartoons, applaud the sofa acrobat and try to remember where the conversation was going once the 5-year-old's wisdom has been heard. Fair's fair . . .
    Besides, exposing children to the notion that in different places we apply different rules, respect others and don't always do everything the way we do when Mom and Dad are the rule makers isn't a bad thing. They'll end up far more welcome in restaurants and on airplane jaunts if they learn that one. - 9/13/2011   11:26:30 AM
  • 21
    These rules apply to my relationship with MY parents, too! - 9/13/2011   10:16:09 AM
  • 20
    I am meeting BOTH of my boys girlfriends tomorrow night! It's the 1st time either of them have been serious about anyone for over 5 years! I suddenly understand how Jane Fonda feels in "Monster-in-law" Infact, I've joked about giving the girls that movie for Christmas & having them sign a contract that I get custody of the major holidays, teehee. It is diffecult, especially since it has been me & my boys alone for 24 years, the 3 musketeers! It's like having someone invade our happiness or join our group. But, both of my boys understand my fears & have assured me that neither of the girls want to take them away from me. I trust my boys judgement. But, still, meeting both girls @ one time! pray for me! - 9/13/2011   9:49:23 AM
  • KATHYMCW1
    19
    I had enough of my mother growing up giving her opinion of anybody/everybody and what they should/should not do. It didn't matter if family/in-laws or not. My rule that I have passed on to my children and I hope they pass it on is: Just because you have an opinion, not everybody is entitled to it. God gave us 2 ears and one mouth - keep the 2 open and the one shut. That's why I have a pretty good relationship with all my in-laws and my children's girl/boy friends and their spouses. - 9/13/2011   7:42:17 AM
  • 18
    To this practical advice, I'd add "detailed directions to an unusually warm climate"... - 9/13/2011   7:40:39 AM
  • 17
    Oh, I just LOVE, LOVE, LOVE your "rules". This is why since I have FOUR SONS, I will never, never, ever bother with my DILs at all. I'm sure they will know it all, so I won't waste my time. My oldest son is married & his wife is a nice person, that I'd have picked out for him, but I don't interfer with ANY thing in their lives. He calls & talks to me and I listen. I tell him the one rule in a marriage is "NEVER EVER CRITICIZE". There is no such thing as "constructive criticism." My third son has a wonderful girlfriend, but I have no intention of bother whatever they do once they are married. - 9/13/2011   12:32:12 AM
  • 16
    My DH and I 'had to get married' when we were teenagers in the late 60's. My MIL didn't speak to us for 11 YEARS! We moved 3000 miles away (he joined the AF to avoid the draft) so that made it easy for her to ignore us. When we moved back home, she finally came around and spent the rest of her life trying to make up for it- not that she ever apologized or anything. My DH never forgave her. My DIL and I get along great and I try to be a good MIL. - 9/12/2011   10:32:35 PM
  • 15
    I was so fortunate to have a loving wonderful mother-in-law. I had absolutely no problems with her or my father-in-law----I am one thankful lady to have such wonderful in-laws and miss both of them, wish my grand daughters could have had a chance to have met them. - 9/12/2011   8:21:28 PM
  • 14
    I am so lucky to have a wonderful Mom-in-law. She decided a long, long time ago that she would treat her DILs like friends, not an intrusion. We get along so well and I always look forward to spending time with her! - 9/12/2011   6:54:50 PM
  • 13
    SADLY my MIL died a little over a year after I married my DH. I never got to know her because she lived in Arkansas and we lived in South Carolina. I really regret it. - 9/12/2011   5:15:25 PM
  • 12
    My Mother in law is 6 years older than my husband and myself (second marriage for my fil who is now 83) They have been married 5 years less than my husband and myself so most of the times things go smoothly between us.
    There are no comments on the child raising, etc from her but for several years while we were stationed 3 hours from them, my FIL would drop by unannounced and be upset because the house was a wreck. Usually he stopped by when I was being "class mom" and baking cupcakes for 4 classrooms of kids.
    I am actually able to give her more insight into issues with my FIL which helps her a lot. Hubby is also an only child - 9/12/2011   4:13:55 PM
  • 11
    I have a great relationship with my MIL and she has been wonderful ever since we first met 41 years ago!

    My DIL is different--she is from a completely different culture and she barely knows English. In fact, she does not want to learn English because it's an "imperialist language". My son does not know her language. How can they communicate? - 9/12/2011   1:42:56 PM
  • 10
    I have an interesting situation. My MIL lives in another county and does not speak English. In fact, she did not come up for our wedding, so I have actually never met her. We do Skype with her, but neither one of us speaks the other's language, so we rely on my husband to translate.
    I do plan on visiting and meeting her within the next six months.... should be interesting. She does know that I truely love her son, and because of that, my husband tells me that his family already loves me! - 9/12/2011   12:13:09 PM
  • SEPTLEFTY
    9
    Ditto - 9/12/2011   11:41:47 AM
  • SEPTLEFTY
    8
    Lol this is so interesting but fortunately my husband settles any issues my MIL has with me. We have gotten along well with no issues. - 9/12/2011   11:29:11 AM
  • 7
    Thank you for the list this will help on the future I would love to have a great relationship withy future DIL not like what I had with my MIL. - 9/12/2011   10:02:52 AM
  • 6
    I wish it were so easy to talk to some MIL's... unfortunately I have not been able to get to this point with mine and we are quickly losing the "respect". Although I'm always respectful, it's hard to feel respect for someone who constantly ignores your feelings and requests. - 9/12/2011   9:58:33 AM
  • 5
    I have been truly blessed. I have had no problems with any of my in-laws. My MIL has always respected my thoughts and opinions as I have hers. She doesn't give advice unless you ask for it. When my mother passed away, she became the mother that I leaned on. I loved the stories she told about my husband growing up and passed them on to my children.

    I hope I can influence my DIL in the same way my MIL influenced me. I praise my daughter (DIL) for putting up with my moody son. She is perfect for him. - 9/12/2011   8:33:09 AM
  • OSSIEBIRD
    4
    My relationship with my MIL did not exist in the beginning. She nor my FIL liked me. In fact, his whole family took no interest in me. It was all about the others. I remember one Christmas, as gifts were passed out, I was deliberately left out, as well as my young daughter. I am still married to their son, after 27 years. They never thought it would last. What a ride it has been! - 9/12/2011   8:24:44 AM
  • 3
    Thank you! I have a great relationship with my DIL and I want to keep it that way. This gives me a good list to be mindful of when we get together. - 9/12/2011   8:20:32 AM
  • 2
    My MIL lives pretty far away, and I don't really see her very often. However, when we do see her I get along great with her. We actually have a lot in common and have always been able to talk to each other. My husband is not real close with his family and his mom appreciates that because of me he actually communicates and sees her more often then he did before he was involved with me. - 9/12/2011   7:13:25 AM
  • 1
    I consider myself very thankful that I have a great relationship with my MIL. I grew up with both of my parents having a great relationship with their MILs, to the point that both of my grandmothers lived with my parents in their final days (not at the same time).

    Its all about respect - respect for your MIL for raising your husband, and respect for the DIL who is an important person in said husband's life. This is true for any relationship. You have to see if from the other persons side. - 9/12/2011   6:17:17 AM

Please Log In To Leave A Comment:    Log in now ›


Join SparkPeople.com

Sign up for a FREE SparkPeople account