When Your Sweet Tooth Strikes, What Do You Reach For?

By , SparkPeople Blogger
Most days, right around 3 or 4 o'clock, they spring up out of nowhere. Others are surprised by them at night, usually in the few hours before bed. They come without warning and you can't really explain why they're there. Sugar cravings—they drive you nuts! Why must they appear, temping you at every turn, persuading you to give up on this whole "healthy lifestyle" thing?

I definitely have a strong preference for sweet foods. When they were handing out that gene that makes people think some desserts are "too sweet" or "too rich," I must have been sleeping (or off somewhere eating dessert), because no food is ever too sweet for me! Sometimes I give in, but other times, I find ways to squelch it without turning to sugary junk foods.

So what do I reach for when sugar cravings strike?

When I crave sweets, I usually want:
  • Twizzlers (only strawberry, no exceptions)

  • Ice cream (premium, really high-calorie stuff)

However, I try to indulge in real desserts and candy only in moderation—usually once every few weeks at the most, but sometimes it happens more or less frequently.

Instead, I usually eat one of these lesser evils a few times a week to tide myself over:

  • Dried fruit. I'm really into dried cherries, pineapple rings and mango slices, which are so sweet you'd think they're candy! OK, granted, some of these are made with added sugar, but at least the basis of your snack is still fruit. Whether plain or coupled with some almonds or lightly salted nuts, it usually hits the spot.

  • A protein bar. These don't make their way into my diet on a regular basis, but they're great for killing your sweet tooth and getting at least some nutrition (and not too many calories) without the sugar rush, thanks to the fat, fiber and protein that most contain (in addition to sugar and carbohydrates). My all-time favorite protein bar (in terms of taste and sweetness) is PowerBar's Triple Threat. This is delicious like a candy bar with a few vitamins, a decent amount of protein and some fiber thrown in.

  • Sweetened yogurt. I think most yogurts contain far too much sugar, which is why I'm putting this under the category of "lesser evils." However, it's far from an unhealthy food. Sweetened yogurt also provides protein and calcium, of course. I like to pair mine with some fresh strawberries or blueberries to stretch the yogurt but still get the sweet taste. I also like to make the world's simplest smoothie: 1 cup of vanilla yogurt with 1 cup of frozen fruit.

  • Dark chocolate chips. Yes, dark chocolate contains antioxidants, but I wouldn't consider it a health food. It still has lots of sugar and little else in the way of nutrition. However, at least those antioxidants are in there, right? Here's what I do from time to time. I buy a bag of expensive, organic dark chocolate chips made by Sunspire. These cost about $5 to $6 per bag, which I know is pricey. But that price ensures the quality I want—and the fact that I'll ration them instead of inhaling them. I'll portion out a small amount to eat for an after-dinner snack. Sometimes I eat them plain and other times I'll eat them with dried fruit (usually raisins or cherries) and almonds.

Ideally, what I eat most of the time when my sweet tooth strikes is… fruit. Unglamorous, right? I know you're thinking that you hear this advice all the time and that fruit just isn't going to cut it when you're really craving sweets. I beg to differ! If the SparkPeople kitchen is loaded with goodies (someone's gotta taste all those low-cal ice creams after all), I will eat the fruit I brought from home FIRST and then wait it out. If I'm still hungry and really want sweets afterward, then I'll have a portion-controlled treat, knowing that at least I got some fiber, vitamins and another serving of produce in my body before I indulged. And 90% of the time, the fruit alone hits the spot and I think to myself, "This is so sweet and delicious! I can't believe I thought I wanted ice cream!" Apples, oranges, bananas, and berries are my top picks for daily snacking. When they're in-season and fresh, their sweetness rivals any dessert out there—plus they're the healthiest thing you can snack on when it comes to sweets.

My sugar cravings come and go. I love sugar just as much as the next guy, but I find that the more sweetened foods I eat, the more sugary foods I crave—and that's not a good situation to be in if you want to eat healthy. So I make a conscious effort to eat sweet foods in moderation. If I notice that I'm having too many sweets over a few days, I'll resist those sugar cravings to no end and choose one of the "lesser evils" above or a natural sweet like fresh fruit, which puts my sweet tooth at bay without increasing my sugar cravings.

Now you tell us: When your sweet tooth strikes, what do YOU reach for?

Click here to to redeem your SparkPoints
  You will earn 5 SparkPoints


NANASUEH 3/8/2018
good points Report
RYCGIRL 2/22/2018
amazing! thanks Report
I like a small amount of more expensive milk chocolate at a 100 calorie serving. I buy it on sale after many holidays and freeze it in the warmer weather. I have also found what is called a gourmet rich tasting ice cream that is not diet,taste very good,comes on sale often at 100 calories per 1/2 C in Canada, I prefer it. Report
me i go for fruit or dark chocolate nuggets or hershey/dove bites Report
Utz mini choc. pretzels for 2P, 1/2 cup frozen yogurt in a small waffle cone 3P, or weight watcher candy (has points on the label) 1P for the one I eat - talk about YUM Report
My sweet tooth is often happy with berries or pineapple or sugar snap peas (now THOSE are candy), but I also eat a lot of yogurt (sweetened or with fruit or with granola or all of the above) and homemade cookies. I don't apologize for them, I just eat them in moderation. Report
I have 3 go to sweet tooth fixes. Either a teaspoon of almond butter with a touch of honey, or 72% cacao chocolate piece (when it has to be chocolate). And my chewy yummy is a couple of prunes. I know- crazy, but they are super sweet and chewy and fix the sweet tooth Report
I eat a date or an apple sometimes both if I have enough calories.
My sweettooth kicks in at random times during the day. I used to reach for chocolate, but now I mostly eat three or four prunes. I also have learned that sometimes a glass of water will do the trick as I am simply a little dehydrated. Report
i keep 100 calories in the house and use them . like the idea of cool whip with coco powder. think i might try that .thanks Report
One tub of fat free Cool Whip with some cocoa powder mixed in it, tastes like mousse, doesn't add up on the scale the next morning though. Took some doing to finally come up with this to keep a binge away. Report
2 or 3 prunes, a piece of dark chocolate (think Hershey's miniature, or two dark chocolate kisses, and a cup of milk. Filling, mostly healthy and satisfies that sweet tooth. This is about a 200 calorie snack. If I can afford it and need the fat for the day, add 1/2 oz. of walnuts for about a 300 calorie snack. Awesome!!!! Report
Greek yogurt and honey, Fage has it already packaged for me and its a delight. I get the 0% fat yogurt so its not so sinful! Report
Mmmm. low fat vanilla yogurt over bananas(or any fruit) with a little sugarfree hot fudge topping! So yummy, my husband adds granola. It is really like a sundae if you put it in the freezer for a bit. My kids eat it and never are concerned that it is not ice cream. Report
Well- Im a fan of cheese. I like 1-2 oz. of raw grassfed cheddar. although its contradictory to a sugar craving- it changes the craving and satitifies me. If I need something sweet sweet and cheese or a hard boiled egg doesnt cut it- I use 2 Tbs heavy cream over berries and sweeten with somersweet or truvia and a splash of vanilla or coconut milk. Report
This is a really good blog. Thanks for the alternative selections you mentioned to the high fat./sugar treats. I usually reach for the premium ice cream myself. I recently purchased a vita mix machine and now I make some rocking smoothies, (just like the kind you buy out in town). Yummo! Report
I definitely go to the grapes and non-fat yogurt first. And like many of you, I LOVE dark chocolate . . although I try not to buy it often because I will eat too much of it.
DH loves his ice cream at night...I just can't eat a "standard" portion of 1/2 cup so I don't eat it AT ALL! I have a carton of non-fat yogurt and add a serving of Kashi Honey Oat cereal to it...I get the "sweet and crunchy" that I'm after for few calories! Report
Chocolate ice cream every evening. For some reason, I get a chocolate or sugar craving after every meal. During the day at work, I reach for the gum. If there are cookies or muffins around I will eat them in the morning. I do not purchase candy and cookies very often because I would devour them in one or two settings. Report
I eat 3 squares of Lindt 85% cocoa very dark chocolate almost every day, it's one of my snacks for the day that I plan for. Also have one Skinny Cow Fudge bar, 100 calories, and that is for my 7 pm snack time. Then I have a serving of fruit, like no sugar added applesauce, or mandarin oranges from a can, rinsed first and drained. This keeps me sane and able to eat "cleanly" for weeks at a time. And I save up for a real splurge if there is some big holiday or birthday or anniversary. Never sit there and NOT eat the cake or dessert while everyone around you is enjoying a treat, you will make up for it and then some in the next few days or weeks, I kid you not!!!! Report
Dark chocolate. Report
I like the greek yoguet with honey Report
The best way I've found to have healthy snacks: Try eating gluten, dairy and soy-free, and have braces! It pretty much eliminates most snacks I used to grab on "autopilot". I love some of the Think Thin bars and Larabars. Besides those and fruit, another good option is a rice cake with fresh hummus or almond butter. I keep a small packet of maple almond nutter to add protein to a bar. Yum! Report
I go for the 72% Cacao dark chocolate. I can have a third of a bar and the sugar content is fairly low, plus I get antioxidants. Also love Skinny Cow ice cream sandwiches. Report
I love my twizzlers too!! Strawberry and once and a while chocolate. Although I attended a raw foods class Monday night and the instructor made this INCREDIBLE chocolate heart. It was solid and so delicious. Report
I eat Hershey extra dark chocolate and a mug of coffee. 4 pieces are 180 calories with 21 grams of carbohydrates. I have 12 oz. of reg. coffee, 1/4 cup nonfat skim milk and two packets of Sun Crystals in my coffee, I have this logged together and can download it at one time. Usually, I don't eat all 4 pieces. The craving is curbed by letting the squares melt in my mouth as I bite off pieces and sip my coffee. I try to keep my calorie counts under 1500 a day and will log in a food before I eat it to see what counts it has. If it is too much, I will look for something different and remove it from my nutrition. My first week here, I lost 3 lbs., this is my second week. You have to figure out what you will do before you are faced with the problem and the foods you think you cannot eat, are the ones that you might binge on. It is better to have a small portion and allow yourself to have it, than it is to eat something you really don't want and then binge on the food you really wanted. Report
I have a huuuge sweet tooth. I really should try to run to fruit first as the article suggests, but mostly I crave chocolate and I've found the best thing to satisfy this for me is a weight watchers brownie. Only 120 calories, some fiber to fill you up, and super chewy, chocolatey, and delicious. Once in a while I'll eat it with tablespoon of Naturally More peanut butter (really healthy stuff!) If I'm feeling like I need that to help tied me over. Sugar free, low cal hot chocolate or a spicy or honey chamomile tea are nice too. Report
I'm trying EFT tapping, so stop cravings. Report
To be honest I reach for the True North almond clusters. They kind of have this sweet/savory thing going on, and they usually satisfy any cravings that I have. I like to mix them with fresh fruit or greek yogurt. Report
bakers semi sweet baking chocolate. just one half of a square takes care of me. and its good for the heart. Report
I keep a jar with a mix of 65% dark chocolate chips,dried cranberries, almonds, and a few raisins. Add some cinnamon and shake it up. A little goes a long way. Report
I actually prefer savoury when i get cravings - bad fried stuff and pastries. BUT when i do want something sweet, i want cheeeesecake and cream ! I might have a treat of a small slice to feed the craving, but stick to limts! (at the moment!) Report
I usually want something sweet either in the afternoon or early evening. I usually grab sugar free hot cocoa. It is sweet and chocolaty and usually curbs my sweet tooth for only about 25 calories!!! Gotta love that! Report
I definitely reach for chocolate, but try to have a 100 calorie pack so it's portioned Report
I use a Balance Bar, peanut-caramel chocolate covered..it tastes like a Snickers Bar but has 210 calores, 15 grams of protein, and 7 grams of fat. I cut it into little pieces on a pretty plate and have a cup of tea.
Also, there are many measured portions of all sorts of ice cream treats from Weight Watchers or Skinny Cow, but I myself have been known to have 2..so i think twice before bringing them into the house.
For those who love dark chocolate and find themselves unprepared with a commercial product, try this: mix a dollop of honey with an equal amount of unsweetened baking cocoa powder like Hersheys, and stir and stir in a little cup until it forms a firm fudgelike candy! It takes about a minute, longer than just blending the 2 items.
I also will slice an apple up and drizzle it with honey.
In grocery store chocolate, we have recently discovered a new premium offering from Dove, with cranberries, and the bar is presented as three gold foil wrapped modest portions. If you have three people at hand, this is very delicious and sucessful! Report
Fresh fruit is my first choice. If the cravings continue AND it's okay with my nutrition tracker, I'll grab between 10 to 20 pieces of a dark chocolate covered dried fruit and/or nuts.

While on SparkPeople I have learned portion-control, self-control, and to plan ahead. Never would have touched chocolate the first couple of months in the program. I would have gone uncontrollably crazy! Report
Mmmmm Cocoa coated ALMONDS!! get the sweet and salty fix :) and filling! Report
I like to have South Beach living fiber fit Smore granola bar. They are yummy and satisfy my monster craving for something sweet. Report
Chocolate! Report
I slice up a fresh banana, put the slices in a tupperware container in the freezer and when I get the craving for something sweet, I reach for a slice or two of the frozen bananas! Try it, they are great! Report
I musn't tell a lie (LOL) - my all time forbidden sweet indulgence is a Rockslide Brownie (scrumpdillyicious!), about once every 2 month I treat myself to one, if I crave it. My more healthy sweet indulgence, about once every 6 weeks is a sliced fresh ripe banana with 1/2 cup of Ciao Bella Coconut Sorbetto (Deelish!) Report
Today I will reach for the Greek yogurt I bought yesterday with berries and honey. Report
I think I was born with a permanent sweet tooth.....so when I journal each day, I build in a 100 calorie "dessert" that I eat around 8 p.m. It is usually yogurt, lite ice cream, kettle corn, etc. Always sweet! Perhaps this isn't good for me, but at my age, I'm into some comfort. Report
i have to say that these were so helpful! i'll admit i love the chocolate altoids & also nutella. i'll just make myself a 1/2 nutella sandwich on some whole wheat or honey wheat bread & it really hits the spot & is pretty healthy, too. if i'm really needing something, a little bit of a nutrilite french vanilla meal replacement shake or one of their chocolate crisp meal replacement bars. they're soooo rich that i have to eat them slowly & with a glass of milk, and they're almost a chocolate overload, in a healthy way! mmm.... thanks for the other ideas, all! Report
You guys are just waaaay to good !! I applaud you!!! When my sweet tooth hits I'm into the snickers and red licorice, actually anything that is sweet and fattening. Can't convince my sweet tooth that the imitations will satisfy it. Report
When my sweet tooth or any tooth strikes (for that matter) I stop myself before I reach for anything. Often, I am feeling bored or lonely and get hungry to feed the need for affection. I tend to that need first by being present to myself and by deep breathing. Those actions usually fill me up. I usually have fruit or drink water. I admit I have a thing for chocolate. On occasion, I indulge in a small portion of Lind chocolates and keep track of the calories in the nutrition tracker. Report
Yoplait light works for me. Its fat free and they have flavors like white chocolate raspberry, cheesecake - and they taste great!! Report
I like dark chocolate peanut butter, Nutella butter, or as a last resort, regular peanut butter. It is high in protien and fat so it satisfies my sweet tooth and my hunger. I find that if I eat a spoonful and wait 15 minutes, I usually don't feel I need anything else. I eat it on fruit when I can. Also, I like that it I can package a spoonful for the road if I need it. Report
sugarless gum. Report
I am sooo glad I read this post. I have a terrible sweet tooth. And I'm afraid I've passed it on to my husband as well! Sugar is so contagious. But now I have LOTS of ideas for semi-healthy sweets so we don't cave in to the call of ice cream so often. Plus, that gets expensive!

I was wondering though, would anyone have a good recipe for NO BAKE COOKIES that perhaps includes DARK CHOCOLATE, ALMOND BUTTER, and STEVIA? Seems like that would be a semi-healthy treat... Report
Close email sign up
Our best articles, delivered Join the millions of people already subscribed Get a weekly summary of our diet and fitness advice We will never sell, rent or redistribute your email address.

Magic Link Sent!

A magic link was sent to Click on that link to login. The link is only good for 24 hours.