Fitness Articles

Waist-to-Hip Ratio Estimates Health Risk

Are You an Apple or a Pear?

114SHARES
Ever notice how some people can have big bellies but lean legs, or how women tend to store most of their fat in their thighs, hips, and butt? These are examples of fat distribution, which refers to where your body typically stores the fat, no matter what your weight is. This is important because where you store fat can be a predictor of health risk.

The waist-to-hip (WTH) ratio is a common measure of fat distribution. Your WTH ratio can help you track your weight loss progress, while also serving as a warning about your estimated health risk for problems related to being overweight, such as diabetes, stroke and heart disease. In fact, a study reported in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition reported that for some age groups, the waist-to-hip ratio is a better indicator of increased mortality risk than body mass index (BMI), which compares your height to your weight.

Calculating Your Waist-to-Hip Ratio
Use a measuring tape to measure your waist (at the smallest circumference of your natural waist, usually just above the belly button) and the circumference of your hips (at the widest part of your buttocks). To determine your ratio, enter your measurements into SparkPeople's calculator, OR simply divide your waist measurement by your hip measurement. Compare your result to the appropriate chart below, which is different for males and females.

Females Estimated health risk Estimated body shape
0.80 or below Low Pear
0.81 to 0.85 Moderate Avocado
0.85+ High Apple
Males Estimated health risk Estimated body shape
0.95 or below Low Pear
0.96 to 1.0 Moderate Avocado
1.0+ High Apple

Although all body fat is made of the same “stuff,” where it's stored can make a big difference in both how risky it is to your health, and in how easy it is to lose.

Pear Shape (Low Health Risk)
If you’re a pear shape, you tend to carry most of your weight in your hips, thighs and buttocks. Storing fat in your lower half is actually a healthier site for fat accumulation. Research shows that storing fat here may actually protect you against cardiovascular disease. In one study of 1,356 women, ages 60-85, Danish researchers found that those with excessive fat in the arms, legs, hips and buttocks had less atherosclerosis (hardening of the arteries) than those who stored most fat in their abdominal area and other central parts of the body.

Apple Shape (High Health Risk)
If you tend to carry weight in your abdominal area and upper torso, you’re an apple shape. People who are apple-shaped and tend to carry more weight around their waists (commonly referred to as a “pot belly”) are at a greater risk of lifestyle-related diseases such as heart disease and diabetes than pear-shaped people. However, a 2011 study of 220,000 people published in The Lancet did not find an increased risk.

Avocado Shape (Moderate Health Risk)
You may hear about apples and pears all the time, but what about people who don't fit into either category? The less common "avocado" shape is somewhere between an apple and a pear, with health risks higher than a pear-shaped person, but somewhat lower than a true apple-shaped person.

Improving Your Distribution
Once you know which body shape you have, and your potential level of risk, what can you do about it?

First, you have to accept that there is no way to change where your body stores fat—your genetics determine that. If you are an apple now, you will always be an apple, even if you lose a few extra pounds. Weight loss may not change your body shape, but it will reduce your size.

Secondly, it helps to know that there is no way to lose weight in specific areas of the body. For example, crunches might target the abdominal muscles, but they don't burn fat from the belly; running might use your lower half, but it doesn’t mean that you're burning fat from the legs alone. The best way to get rid of fat—no matter where it is on your body—is through regular cardio exercise and a healthy diet. Cardio (aerobic) exercise burns fat from all over the body. But if you tend to store fat in a certain area (apple or pear) it may take longer to lose fat from that specific area. Stay consistent and you will lower your risk for future health problems by achieving a healthy weight.

Lastly, don't fear strength training. It's a common misconception (especially among women) that strength training is going to make you “bulk up”. You may fear, for example, that since your thighs are a trouble spot, you shouldn’t lift weights because it will make your thighs look bigger. This is a myth. Women, in fact, are more likely to tone up from strength training rather than bulk up. Research shows that women can add up to 30% lean muscle and end up looking thinner, feeling stronger and being firmer.

A well-rounded program of cardio and strength training, along with a healthy diet, will help with overall fat loss. No matter what your shape, maintaining a healthy weight will greatly reduce your risk of obesity-related illness.

Click here to to redeem your SparkPoints
  You will earn 5 SparkPoints
Page 1 of 1  
Got a story idea? Give us a shout!
114SHARES

Member Comments

  • Good reminders to be vigilant on a healthy lifestyle.
  • I struggle with this type of arbitrary measurement...bec
    ause I have given birth SEVEN TIMES! I can guarantee you that no matter what I weigh, I will have a tummy and my I kissed my waist goodbye a long time ago! LOL It is frustrating to be labeled as moderate to high risk on a chart just because of my waist to hip ratio so I usually put more stock in my BMI...which is well within the normal healthy range at 23.1....but I will ask the doctor what she thinks....
  • THROUGH THICK & THIN I HAVE ALWAYS BEEN A PEAR
  • My WTH ratio went from an apple to a pear as I lost weight. So, guess that makes me an apple since that's where the excess weight went when I gained.
  • You change shape when you lose weight, but I think the point the author is making is that if you gain weight in the middle first, even if you lose it and change your shape, if you gain again, it will be in the middle that you see it first and that will be the last to go always. I am an apple and though I had a very nice hourglass figure most of my life, every time i started to gain weight it came first in my middle and left there last. I gain last in my face and lose there first. Every time. I will always be an apple.
  • I am pear shape with my lost weight, before I lost weight I was a apple. I managed to lose in the right place with correct exercise. so, yes you can change your shape.
  • Very interesting article. I have always had more of an hour glass (large, think Wizard of Oz) share, but according to cslculator, I am a pear.
  • I agree with AUNA_CYCLE. For instance, I plugged in my current measurements into the calculator and it says I'm an apple. Then I put in my measurements from when I was 45 pounds lighter, and I was a pear. So yes, you CAN change your shape!
  • People are getting the idea, from reading this article, that it's impossible to change your body shape. That's not true! If you lose weight, your body shape will change significantly. You will go from being an apple to an avocado to a pear, and then to a banana, is what the thin one is. It changes. You don't HAVE to store body fat. I think that should be one of the points that this article makes. I know that I used to be a banana shape until I gained some weight. Then I became a pear shape. Now I am an avocado shape. But I have been losing inches, and am very close to being a pear shape again. And once I'm done with my weight loss I will be a banana shape again. Normal is possible, people! Don't believe the hype!
  • so I learned I'm an avocado... when i lose weight and my ratio's change will i become a pear? hmm
  • Hmmmm...So I am an avocado; I've never heard of it but it's better than an apple!
  • DGUERRERO14
    Pear. Always a pear
  • Hmmmm..... Avocado?? First I've heard that one.
  • GREENWOODTAM
    I am an apple it says but I look like a box lol with bulge out front and bulge out back lol guess I a squished box. Made me laugh at least. Lots of work ahead. Dr oz recommending me to eat cold potatoes to use up all carbs. I called an "android" type meaning fat pot belly. But at 5' 1" and 159 lbs its time to work hard!! Wish me luck.
  • I can't measure myself at the moment, but I've noticed ever since I started birth control I've steadily transitioned from a pear to more like an avocado. I still have a fairly defined waistline, but my belly below the waist is gathering more fat and refuses to let any of it go. It's even more frustrating when I can feel my now strengthening ab muscles just under the layer of flab and I know I may never see them until or unless I get off of bc!

About The Author

Nicole Nichols Nicole Nichols
A certified personal trainer and fitness instructor with a bachelor's degree in health education, Nicole loves living a healthy and fit lifestyle and helping others do the same. Nicole was formerly SparkPeople's fitness expert and editor-in-chief, known on the site as "Coach Nicole." Make sure to explore more of her articles and blog posts.