Survey Shows Americans Are in Denial about Their Weight
Overweight and obesity are often in the news, with dismal headlines about the fattest states, the heaviest cities, and the rise in our collective girth. Once a problem for our nation's adults, not even our children or babies are immune to uncontrolled weight gain these days. It's hard to miss the headlines, but even harder not to notice that the people around you seem to be getting larger. Despite clear evidence to the contrary, a new online survey of 2,418 adults conducted by Harris Interactive and HealthDay shows that Americans don't view themselves as overweight, even when they actually are. Even worse, when respondents were asked which weight-loss intervention was most effective, diet and exercise didn't even make it into the top three.
In the survey, respondents provided their height and weight, which pollsters used to calculate their body mass index (BMI). Calculate your BMI here. They were then asked which weight classification they thought they fell into: normal weight, overweight, obese, or morbidly obese. Here's what the pollsters found:
With overweight is the new norm, it's easy to see yourself as "normal" (or not too far from it), even when you're overweight or obese.
So Why Do Americans Think They're Overweight?
Most poll respondents blamed lack of exercise for their weight problems, while far fewer recognized poor eating habits as a culprit. According to the poll,
Why do we put so much credence in exercise and shy away from taking a good, hard look at what we're putting into our mouths? I have two theories.
First, this is the example we are given. We're constantly told that we don't exercise enough, but we are more seldom told that we eat too much. Weight-loss infomercials rarely talk about food—usually they hawk fitness gizmos that miraculously helped people melt away their fat in just minutes a day. (Read the fine print, though. Exercise alone and that device alone is never the sole cause of someone's svelte body.) Weight-loss reality TV shows depict people killing themselves in the gym for hours a day, not weighing their food or talking about how hungry they are from eating less. Fitness magazines primarily talk about workouts, with headlines about losing your gut or de-dimpling your derriere. It's no wonder we think a lack of exercise is what's to blame for our increased girth.
But what about food? People are always told that there is no such thing as good and bad foods, but can that honestly be true? Realistically, there are bad foods—we all know what they are—and they become especially bad when you eat too much of them too often. But it's more than that. Food is deeply personal to us. It reflects who you are, from your culture to your personality. I think people do really know that they eat poorly, eat too much, or eat the wrong things, but probably don't want to face it. For something that says so much about you, to admit that the food you choose to eat isn't so good might mean that you're not a good person either. It may signal that you're weak, that you lack willpower, that you don't care, or that you don't care what others think of you. Because food matters that much to us, and we want freedom to eat whatever we want. We don't want to be told what to eat or how to eat. We especially don't want to be told what NOT to eat. For some reason, there's not much stigma associated with a sedentary lifestyle, but people become very defensive and protective if you try to change, control, or analyze their food choices. It's easier to just say we don't exercise enough than to dissect something so personal to us.
How Americans Rank Weight-Loss Methods
According to the respondents, neither diet nor exercise ranked highly as the "most effective" methods of weight loss. Instead, people ranked other interventions in this order: 1- surgery (such as gastric bypass or stomach stapling), 2- prescription drugs, and 3- over-the-counter drugs and diet pills. Faith in these remedies seemed similar, regardless of the respondents' weight.
We love our quick fixes! Despite the insight that some people expressed about their diets and lack of physical activity, they turned away from those very culprits when asked about losing weight. But the cause is also the solution! Still, it may be easier to avoid changing your own habits by these means, even if they're riskier, potentially less effective, expensive, and downright unsafe at times.
Perhaps we don't want to change because we think it's too hard or aren't sure how to start. I can see how people feel overwhelmed by it all. I've been there myself, struggling to lose weight and failing, trying to exercise more without changing how much I was eating, wanting nothing more than to lose weight but not being ready to truly look at myself and the reasons why I was overweight in the first place. I'm sure many of you felt the same way before embarking on your own weight-loss journey.
That's why I love working for SparkPeople. Because it's real, it works and it's simple. And more than anything else, it's educational. SparkPeople's tools, programs and resources open people's eyes to what they're doing right and what they need to work on, and then we (not just our experts, but our amazingly supportive and smart members) help you get from where you are now to where you want to be, one small step at a time. You don't have to give up anything you don't want to (although you will eat less), and you don't have to run a marathon (although you will find clever ways to become more active each day). When I see news stories like this one, I feel devastated for the poor state of America's health and the future of our children. I feel sad that people don't seem to know what to do or understand how to get out of their weight predicament. But then I remember that SparkPeople is a beacon of hope that has the potential to rewrite the story of America. It's time to get real about our weight, what causes it, and what we can do about it. It's time to join forces with SparkPeople!
How do you explain these poll results? Have you ever experienced denial about your weight or your lifestyle?
In the survey, respondents provided their height and weight, which pollsters used to calculate their body mass index (BMI). Calculate your BMI here. They were then asked which weight classification they thought they fell into: normal weight, overweight, obese, or morbidly obese. Here's what the pollsters found:
- 30% of the "overweight" individuals believed they were actually normal size.
- 70% of the "obese" individuals felt they were simply overweight.
- 60% of the "morbidly obese" individuals labeled themselves as obese, while another 39% considered themselves merely overweight.
With overweight is the new norm, it's easy to see yourself as "normal" (or not too far from it), even when you're overweight or obese.
So Why Do Americans Think They're Overweight?
Most poll respondents blamed lack of exercise for their weight problems, while far fewer recognized poor eating habits as a culprit. According to the poll,
- Among overweight respondents, 52% felt they didn't exercise enough, but only 36% blamed their diets.
- 75% of both the obese and morbidly obese felt they didn't exercise enough, but only 48% of obese respondents and 27% of morbidly obese individuals reported that they ate more than they should.
- Overall, almost 60% of people said they were aware that they should be getting more exercise.
- Only a little more than half of the obese and morbidly obese respondents felt they "ate too much of the wrong types of food."
Why do we put so much credence in exercise and shy away from taking a good, hard look at what we're putting into our mouths? I have two theories.
First, this is the example we are given. We're constantly told that we don't exercise enough, but we are more seldom told that we eat too much. Weight-loss infomercials rarely talk about food—usually they hawk fitness gizmos that miraculously helped people melt away their fat in just minutes a day. (Read the fine print, though. Exercise alone and that device alone is never the sole cause of someone's svelte body.) Weight-loss reality TV shows depict people killing themselves in the gym for hours a day, not weighing their food or talking about how hungry they are from eating less. Fitness magazines primarily talk about workouts, with headlines about losing your gut or de-dimpling your derriere. It's no wonder we think a lack of exercise is what's to blame for our increased girth.
But what about food? People are always told that there is no such thing as good and bad foods, but can that honestly be true? Realistically, there are bad foods—we all know what they are—and they become especially bad when you eat too much of them too often. But it's more than that. Food is deeply personal to us. It reflects who you are, from your culture to your personality. I think people do really know that they eat poorly, eat too much, or eat the wrong things, but probably don't want to face it. For something that says so much about you, to admit that the food you choose to eat isn't so good might mean that you're not a good person either. It may signal that you're weak, that you lack willpower, that you don't care, or that you don't care what others think of you. Because food matters that much to us, and we want freedom to eat whatever we want. We don't want to be told what to eat or how to eat. We especially don't want to be told what NOT to eat. For some reason, there's not much stigma associated with a sedentary lifestyle, but people become very defensive and protective if you try to change, control, or analyze their food choices. It's easier to just say we don't exercise enough than to dissect something so personal to us.
How Americans Rank Weight-Loss Methods
According to the respondents, neither diet nor exercise ranked highly as the "most effective" methods of weight loss. Instead, people ranked other interventions in this order: 1- surgery (such as gastric bypass or stomach stapling), 2- prescription drugs, and 3- over-the-counter drugs and diet pills. Faith in these remedies seemed similar, regardless of the respondents' weight.
We love our quick fixes! Despite the insight that some people expressed about their diets and lack of physical activity, they turned away from those very culprits when asked about losing weight. But the cause is also the solution! Still, it may be easier to avoid changing your own habits by these means, even if they're riskier, potentially less effective, expensive, and downright unsafe at times.
Perhaps we don't want to change because we think it's too hard or aren't sure how to start. I can see how people feel overwhelmed by it all. I've been there myself, struggling to lose weight and failing, trying to exercise more without changing how much I was eating, wanting nothing more than to lose weight but not being ready to truly look at myself and the reasons why I was overweight in the first place. I'm sure many of you felt the same way before embarking on your own weight-loss journey.
That's why I love working for SparkPeople. Because it's real, it works and it's simple. And more than anything else, it's educational. SparkPeople's tools, programs and resources open people's eyes to what they're doing right and what they need to work on, and then we (not just our experts, but our amazingly supportive and smart members) help you get from where you are now to where you want to be, one small step at a time. You don't have to give up anything you don't want to (although you will eat less), and you don't have to run a marathon (although you will find clever ways to become more active each day). When I see news stories like this one, I feel devastated for the poor state of America's health and the future of our children. I feel sad that people don't seem to know what to do or understand how to get out of their weight predicament. But then I remember that SparkPeople is a beacon of hope that has the potential to rewrite the story of America. It's time to get real about our weight, what causes it, and what we can do about it. It's time to join forces with SparkPeople!
How do you explain these poll results? Have you ever experienced denial about your weight or your lifestyle?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > 12 Healthy Game Day Recipes






















Comments
I don't know that I am totally ready to change - it feels like a major commitment! :) - 9/12/2010 6:25:57 AM
I just don't like the way the survey asked people that question and the concluded that people aren't being realistic about their weight. BMI is not an end all answer to the health of an individual. - 9/11/2010 12:18:26 PM
Like I said, this is something that I noticed and I am not suggesting that I agree with others who are avoiding the truth--this is simply an idea to explain part of what this unnerving survey. - 9/10/2010 7:30:30 AM
I believe being overweight or obese today isn't a big deal. You look around and figure a) there are tons of people heavier than me and b) I can still buy decent clothes, in decent sizes and I fit in with most of the population. Today at 150 pounds I wear a size 10. Thirty years ago at 134 lbs I wore a size 14!
Although everyone looks at the obese as weak, gluttonous, lazy, etc... yet everything encourages us to remain obese... fast food, junk food, vanity sizing, etc.
I believe, most of us (overweight & obese) are masters of denial. We know exactly how fat we are and why.... we eat too and move too little. But it's just easier and a heck of a lot more fun to keep going on that route. Developing a healthy lifestyle and maintaining it isn't fun... it's hard work. And whereas we are into denial about out weight, we're not so willing to deny ourselves food, etc. that keep us fat.
I am hard on myself, because if I'm not there is a very good chance I'll be 200++ lbs again.... and whereas it is perfectly acceptable to everyone else, it is not for me. I want to be an old, healthy, active happy woman, not an old, obese, woman who can't move without a walker or a wheel chair. What do you want to be? - 9/9/2010 10:03:20 PM
For the person who mentioned Weight Watchers wanting her to lose to 106 pounds on a 5'1" frame. I don't know when or where she went to WW but WW has a range for healthy weight (you choose your own goal within that range) and for 5'1" it is 111-132 pounds (a 21 pound range) and you can get a note from your doctor is he/she thinks you will be healthy at a higher weight than the range or if you have medical issues that might preclude you from losing to that range level. BMI is only an indicator, but some people take it as the end all, be all. Every pound lost helps your body just by not having to carry it around. - 9/9/2010 12:34:29 PM
PLUS I am a nurse, and we have a REGULAR cliental coming in for Weight Loss surgery....some close to 600 lbs.
- 9/9/2010 12:21:00 PM
/obesity2010 /
There are past reports you can look at as well. The charts are there in those as well, but you have to dig into the PDF.
I did not realize that people were so ignorant about what to do about overweight and obesity. I've been considering becoming a health coach, and this gives me an idea just how much it is needed. - 9/9/2010 11:45:30 AM
Sorry, I just had to get that off my chest. It's something that has been bugging me for years. - 9/9/2010 11:22:49 AM
You want something? Go to the store and get it on credit. No saving up like our predecessors did. You can get it now and pay for it later, how cool is that?
You want a date? No, you don't have to court a partner...just go online or call up a "service" and he/she is either at your fingertips on the computer or talking in your ear as soon as you type in your credit card number. No rejection, no waiting, no need to even really "see" them. Instant gratification.
You want a treat? Heck, you don't have to wait to make anything anymore...the store has all kinds of gooey sweet treats just waiting for you. Load up and away you go...no waiting.
So...why do we have to wait for weight loss? Because we're being taught it's not necessary. We have all been taught to "accept yourself as you are; everyone is perfect as they are; no one has the right to insult you or tell you what to do; it's against the law to hurt someone's feelings because it's bullying"; yadda yadda yadda. Not only can we do what we want when we want it seems, but no one has the right to tell us not to do that.
What about being honest with those we love? I don't mean "Good grief, George, you're huge! Lose some weight, would you?" How about teaching us how to say that lovingly, and supportively, without hurting poor "George's" feelings to the point where he goes and eats even more because his ego is battered. How about "George, I think the world of you. Is there something bothering you? You know, I'm your friend and care what happens to you. You can talk with me any time." Maybe "George, I could use your help. Would you consider going to the gym with me or maybe a diet with me? I could use your help and your moral support."
We live in a society of instancy and convenience. We were not constructed for life to be instant or convenient. We were built to work for our daily bread, and our society is teaching us not to work for what we need out of life.
Just my two cents' worth. - 9/9/2010 10:29:58 AM
That being said, I am 5'5 1/4" inches tall, and I weigh 180 pounds - thereby making my BMI 30.2, and putting me in the Obese category (just over the line). Prior to gastric bypass (November 2007), I weighed 400 pounds. I no longer weigh 400 pounds, or 300 pounds, or even 200 pounds. I am happy at 180, and although I would like to weigh 160, this is where my body seems to have plateaued; I've maintained this weight for seven months now. I just ran my first 5k in August; I run 3x a week. In fact, I work out 6-7 days a week. I eat healthily, but I also have my favorite "bad" foods that I eat in smaller portions than I used to. I know that my diet could be better, but like I said, I feel pretty good at 180, and it's good that I'm not 400 pounds anymore!
I have posted recent pictures of myself on my blog. I am pretty sure most people wouldn't call me Obese, even if the BMI number does. - 9/9/2010 9:48:03 AM
Then one day I saw a picture of me with my doggie....and started crying. Um, I was not just overweight. My BMI was nearly 39 and I was just shy of the morbidly obese numbers. For YEARS I had thought I was "just overweight" but I wasn't.
And still, after 17 months on spark...I am STILL obese (not yet overweight) with a BMI of near 32 (yes, I have gained 14 pounds this summer. Ughhhh).
Yet, I would still tell people I am "just overweight". I dont' know if we just get comfortable in our own skin. If we are in denial. If we just don't see it. I dont' know. But I do know, I am unquestionably the people that are referred to in this blog. And I do not know how to change it. - 9/9/2010 9:31:39 AM
I also had a RYN Nov 28, 2006. It is a tool not a solution. Before I had the surgery I had already changed my mindset, eating and exercising habits. I followed my Dr's orders to the T. I was very fortunate in the fact that I only got sick a couple of times when I was first introducing foods. I found what I could or could not tolerate.
I only use a salad plate and a salad fork when I eat. When I do go out to eat I only eat about 1/3 of my meal and bring the rest home. I never order a dessert.
If the colthing industry would not lie by changing sizes, media and resturants would stop pushing extra large sizes it would help some.
It is still up to each individual to take responsiblity for what, when and how they consume. We are the laziest and largest country in the world. We spend to much time in front of TV, gaming systems, computers, etc. Look at what we have done in our schools. Our children get little or no exercise and rescess at all. this is suppose to save tax payers money. We end up spend more for health issues in the long run.
Stop blaming others for your situation. It is time for the United States to take responibility for ourselves. - 9/9/2010 9:18:58 AM
I have always been obsessed with my weight, especially when I was younger. Although never formally diagnosed, I know now that I suffered from eating disorders and it is still a constant battle. In my youth I feared the scales because I didn't want to be fat and in doing so I can vividly remember being devastated when I hit 100 lbs in my grade twelve year. In hindsight, this was ridiculous as I am 5' 5"! I refused to have scales for a number of years so that I wouldn't obsess about my weight. However after 25 years, 3 kids (with varying degrees of special needs), trying to re-enter the workforce and a failed relationship, I am obsessing again. This time I am striving to obsess about a healthy life style and not just the numbers. I am wanting to feel better, not just look better as I navigate this new chapter of my life.
I know can slim down, but my previous habits of controlling what I eat by denying is NOT the answer. Logically and intelligently I know that being 155 lbs at 5' 5" is not obese, but I feel that way and need to change my life style in order to loose (and keep it off!) the 25 - 30 lbs I wish to shed.
Thanks SparkPeople for the guidance & support as I navigate through these changes in my life!
- 9/9/2010 9:18:49 AM
I've personally found that it takes both diet and exercise to win the fitness and weight loss challenge. I used to diet a lot, but always gained it back. Now that I walk and hike, I feel better and have the hope of becoming and staying fit and healthy. - 9/9/2010 7:34:24 AM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›