The Pros and Cons of Barefoot Running

Although barefoot running has been practiced in some parts of the world for hundreds of years, the concept has only recently gained popularity as an alternative to traditional running shoes in the Western world.  The book "Born to Run," published in 2009, explored the patterns of distance runners who are able to avoid common injuries by running without shoes. This sparked a whole new interest in barefoot running and minimalist running shoes, which are lightweight and flexible and have very little padding or support. Proponents of barefoot exercise claim that the excessive support and cushioning of traditional running shoes leads to muscle weakness and injury, while opponents contend that running in minimalist footwear (or no shoes at all) doesn't provide enough protection or support. 
 
Is barefoot running just a fad, or is the trend toward minimalism worth trying? It’s important to do the research before deciding whether or not barefoot running is right for you. The two sides of this debate each have research to support their claims. First, let’s look at some of the research supporting minimalist running.

A 2010 study in the journal Nature found that the majority of runners wearing shoes strike their heels, which causes a large and sudden collision force that happens (on average) 960 times for every mile ran.  The authors concluded that this makes runners prone to repetitive stress injuries. People who run barefoot tend to land with a step toward the middle or front of the foot, causing less impact force to the foot. (Learn more about the difference between heel and forefoot striking in this article on proper running form.)
 
A 2012 study in the journal Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise found that minimalist runners are "more economical" than traditionally runners regardless of foot strike—even after controlling for shoe mass and stride frequency. The researchers believe that minimalist shoes provide a more "elastic" energy storage and release than other running shoes.
 
Other recent studies question the validity of the benefits of barefoot running. The journal Sports Health published a review in 2012 that concluded that there is not yet enough research to determine whether or not foot strike has a positive or negative effect on injury. A year later, the Journal of Applied Physiology concluded that the forefoot strike pattern is not more economical than the rearfoot strike pattern. 

Potential Benefits of Barefoot Running
While running barefoot or in minimalist shoes might not solve all of your aches and pains, it may help strengthen the muscles, ligaments and tendons of the foot. It can also help lengthen the Achilles and calf muscles, which can shorten over time if you wear shoes that provide a "lift" to the heel.

Barefoot running teaches a person to land on their forefoot, which is a better shock absorber than landing on the heel. 

Barefoot or minimalist running can help improve balance and body awareness. Running without shoes stimulates the smaller muscles in your legs, ankles, feet and hips, which can improve coordination and balance.

Potential Risks of Barefoot Running
There's no doubt that shoes offer significant foot protection. It’s much easier to be injured by glass, rocks or other debris on the road or trail when you are shoeless. Shoes also do provide some stability at the ankle joint that can protect you from injury if landing incorrectly or a little off balance—a common occurrence when running on uneven terrain, such as trails.  

Blisters are one short-term complication that many people experience when first switching to barefoot running. This is temporary until calluses develop, but can still cause discomfort.

Barefoot or minimalist running isn’t something a person can switch to overnight. Trying to convert too quickly increases the risk of injury, since this type of running is more work for the muscles of the feet.

Building Up to Barefoot Running
If you are new to barefoot or minimalist running, don’t expect that you can immediately run the same kind of distances you are used to doing in traditional running shoes. That is a recipe for discomfort at best and injury at worst. 

It can take one to two months for your muscles to adapt to barefoot running. Fitness expert Ben Greenfield suggests the following program to reduce your chances of injury:
  • Weeks 1-4: Walk barefoot for 20-30 minutes each day, while also standing and walking with your shoes off as much as possible when working or at home.
     
  • Weeks 5-6: Start running barefoot on soft surfaces for very short distances (no more than 1 mile) two or three times per week. Go slow and easy.
     
  • Weeks 7-8: Gradually increase distance by no more than 10 percent per week.
     
  • Weeks 8+: If you are pain free and comfortable running on soft surfaces, begin to test out some harder surfaces. Be attentive to how your feet feel and if anything hurts (not just your feet).
Looking strictly at the research, the jury is still out on whether barefoot running is better than running in traditional shoes. Future research could determine the answer, but it's important to remember that every individual reacts differently to any stimuli, so what has worked well for others might not necessarily be ideal for you (and vice versa). Barefoot running is something you might consider trying (with the careful progression discussed above), especially if you’ve had injury problems in the past. But if you’ve been running injury-free and are happy with your progress, don’t feel the need to jump headfirst into the latest fitness trend---at least not yet. 
 

Sources

Gruber AH, Umberger BR, Braun B, Hamill J. "Economy and rate of carbohydrate oxidation during running with rearfoot and forefoot strike patterns." Journal of Applied Physiology. 2013 Jul;115(2):194-201.

Huffington Post, "How to Start Barefoot Running," www.huffingtonpost.com, accessed on August 27, 2013.

Lieberman, Daniel E., Venkadesan, Madhusudhan, Werbel, William A., Daoud, Adam I., D'Andrea, Susan, Davis, Irene S., Mang'Eni, Robert Ojiambo, Pitsiladis, Yannis. "Foot strike patterns and collision forces in habitually barefoot versus shod runners." Nature 463, 531-535 (28 January 2010).

Lorenz, Daniel S. Pontillo, Marisa. "Is There Evidence to Support a Forefoot Strike Pattern in Barefoot Runners? A Review." Sports Health. November/December 2012 vol. 4 no. 6 480-484.

Perl DP, Daoud Al, Lieberman DE. "Effects of Footwear and Strike Type on Running Economy." Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. 2012 Jul;44(7):1335-43. 

Click here to to redeem your SparkPoints
  You will earn 5 SparkPoints

Member Comments

I could never run a city block without my ankles, knees and hips aching for days until about 10 years ago when I was 48. I am barefoot 24/7 and have always gone without shoes as much as possible. Then one day, I rode my bike out to a trail, locked up my bike and shoes and ran almost a mile in barefeet. I ran my first three 5ks in KMart $7 swimming shoes just to avoid slivers and pointy things. I now wear minimalist shoes pretty much all the time. Xero shoes makes minimalist negative heel dress shoes for work even! They are the only shoes that I forget I'm wearing. I just got back from a 65 minute trail run in the woods! Minimalist shoes changed my life! Report
barefoot running? Never! Report
Not for me Report
I have suffered from plantar fasciitis. I could hardly walk. I go und shoes with good arch support and relief from pain. I will stick with shoes with good arch support. However, I love running barefoot at the beach. The sand conforms to the shape of the foot for natural support. Report
Thanks for sharing!!! Report
thanks Report
Don't think so Report
I would worry about stuff on the ground on which I would step. Swimming shoes seem to be a simple compromise. Report
I could never run for more than 30 seconds in regular shoes. Everything hurt especially my ankles and my hips. I go barefoot as much as I can because truly, I think I have a shoe allergy. 8 years ago I found out barefoot running was a thing. I rode my bike out to a soft trail, took off my shoes and ran for the first time ever! I worried about glass and metal bits but then here on Sparkpeople I found people who were running in swimming shoes just to protect the soles of their feet. I ran my first 5k in $7 swimming shoes and had to field a lot of questions about my fancy minimalist running shoes! I now have a pair of $100 minimalist shoes and truly don't see much difference.
Report
Great innfo Report
Not for me. My feet are too tender. Report
Thanks for the information Report
Seems to me there are more cons than pros Report


 

About The Author

Jen Mueller
Jen Mueller
Jen received her master's degree in health promotion and education from the University of Cincinnati. A mom and avid runner, she is an ACE-certified personal trainer, health coach and medical exercise specialist, with additional certifications in behavior change, functional training and senior fitness. She is also a RRCA-certified running coach. See all of Jen's articles.