Group photo
ALICOTTER's Photo ALICOTTER Posts: 6,353
9/5/11 11:23 A

Send Private Message

Should weight loss be a goal? Or is healthy living where it's at?
James Fell Mon Sep 05 2011
Internationally-renowned obesity researcher Dr. Arya Sharma a man I admire thinks that weight loss should NOT be a goal. Im inclined to agree with him.

Dr. Sharma explains how behaviour change is focused around goal setting, and that weight loss is not a behaviour. Ive written before about the need to focus on process goals (behaviours) to achieve outcome goals (weight loss / improved health / increased performance), but I still agree with the basic argument about not having weight loss be a goal at least not a serious one.

The reason why is that I have always stated that you need to focus on the behaviours that lead to the results. Not just focus on them, but embrace them fully.

There is also the fact that I really dont like scales. We have one, and I practically never use it. The kids are the only ones who do, and its because theyre excited about growing and gaining weight.

One of the reasons I dont like scales is because they lie. If you are, uh, a little backed up, or retaining water, or have gained muscle, then the scale can fluctuate a lot, and even though your body fat percentage is going down, seeing the numbers on the scale either not move or go up can be de-motivating.

More importantly, however, is that I think in order to be successful at behaviour change long-term you need to transcend the whole concept of weight loss. Healthy living is really where its at. You need to relish in how good it feels to kick butt at exercise, as well as desire to fuel your high-performance body with an appropriate amount of healthy food.

These are behaviours that make you feel good, they make you healthy, and they do lead to weight loss, but that last one is just a side benefit.

There are so many other benefits to embracing healthy living that I think its beneficial to reduce the stress of being overweight by just deciding to say, To hell with the scale. Focus on loving the fact that youve become a nutrition-conscious workout warrior and the excess body fat will take care of itself.

Bathroom scale be damned.

Get your free metabolism report at

"Sometimes you have to stand alone to prove that you can still stand." - Anonymous

"I don't like to be labeled as lonely just because I am alone." - Delta Burke

"I'm single because I was born that way." - Mae West

Co-leader Single No Kids (SNK)

Co-leader New Beinnings

Leader Goodlife Go-ers

Co-Leader People in Ottawa

Leader Forty + Ontario

 current weight: 255.0 
Page: 1 of (1)  

Report Innappropriate Post

Other GoodLife Go-ers! Diet and fitness Posts

Last Post:

Thread URL:

Review our Community Guidelines