60,000-79,999 SparkPoints 75,478

"Plus size?" Seriously?

Thursday, April 25, 2013

If this woman is plus size, that's a terrible commentary on our perceptions of size. No wonder we have teenage girls starving themselves to death. She recovered from anorexia and unless I'm delusional, she looks healthy and totally beautiful.
Share This Post With Others
Member Comments About This Blog Post
    I think she looks very healthy and fit. This is just another reminder of how out of whack the fashion industry has become.
    1819 days ago
    emoticon That is just nuts. She is beautiful...
    1821 days ago
    I would consider it a plus if I was that size and looked that good!
    1822 days ago
  • 46SHADOW
    1823 days ago
  • LINDA!
    I should be so lucky to look like that. She looks like a healthy woman.
    1823 days ago
    Idiotic society we live in! There is no way that's a plus size!!
    1823 days ago
    That's crazy. 154 pounds is within the normal range of BMI for a person 5' 6".

    What a distorted industry that an average-size figure is considered "plus-size."
    1823 days ago
  • KARENE10
    She looks beautiful! Plus size my A** emoticon
    1823 days ago
    In the industry, plus size is size 8 or bigger. She's probably a size 8. She looks smaller since she's tall. Only tall women are chosen to model. I'm 5'2" and a size 2 and I look normal size not small since I'm so short.
    1823 days ago
    Plus sized my fanny! (Er, mine is plus sized). Craziness abounds
    1823 days ago
    She is a beautiful curvaceous woman most of us would be thrilled to look like. Its sick to label people by size like they do. And it leaves people punishing themselves to get out of the "bad" label size as she did. Or beat up on themselves when they have nothing to be beating themselves up for. A person so small they can turn sideways and be mistaken for a broomstick is Not attractive. I don't care what the size guidelines say.
    Thanks for sharing this emoticon
    IKacey co-leader of the Chair Exercise Team
    1823 days ago
    It's shocking to what people think is plus size. Thanks for sharing this.
    1823 days ago
    I don't know if she is PLUS SIZE or not, I just know she sure looks healthier than she looked when she was anorexic.

    1823 days ago
    1823 days ago
    She looked freakishly awful before at 108 pounds - like she was within a week or two of hospitalization.

    She probably wears a size 8 at most, which is NOT plus sized. I hate getting a plus sized catalog (like Woman Within) and having size 8 women in it, with skinny legs. At least this woman has relatively normal legs, but they are still not size 18 legs.
    How in the world are we to know what a woman who actually FITS in these clothes is going to look in them?
    1823 days ago
    Thank you for sharing this - how crazy is it to think THAT is a PLUS SIZE.
    1823 days ago
    She looks beautiful now, and I like the fact that she is sharing her story, and is a role model for being at a healthy weight. However, plus sized? It seems as though, if a model is not the typical stick-figure thin kind, they are automatically labelled plus-sized. I agree with one of the commenters below-how about a middle ground between super thin and plus sized? Let's start celebrating women of all sizes!
    1823 days ago
    as others have said...the model is probably about a 10 at 154 for 5'9".
    It is absurd what we expect...
    but they are selling clothes and the manufacturers want people to think
    their product is going to make us look that good.

    1823 days ago
    She looks good to me.
    1824 days ago
  • _BABE_
    The plus size models are usually starting at a size 10 or 12 and I wonder too how they are supposed to represent a size category that starts at size 14?
    1824 days ago
    She looks like she is at a healthy weight
    1824 days ago
    It's really sad that there is no middle ground here, anorexic or plus size?! How about "Healthy?"

    I agree, she doesn't look plus sized. That being said I didn't look plus sized when I was 200 lbs and wearing plus sized clothing. I carry my weight well (hourglass shape). I think society has some very strict rules about sizing and they jump to call it 'plus size' way too soon.
    1824 days ago
    wow! she looks so much healthier now!
    1824 days ago
    SHe sure looks better now.
    1824 days ago
  • GRAMMY_22
    I'm glad that she put on some weight after being anorexic. Plus sized she's not!
    1824 days ago
    Interesting. I'm the same height, approx the same weight but don't look as good. It all has to do with weight distribution, I guess. Its unfortunate that they must use such a negative tag for this beautiful woman.
    1824 days ago
    Looks healthy now. When you have a bust and hips that are more than pencil thin, you are considered 'Plus Size' today.
    1824 days ago
    She looks so much healthier AND happier.
    1824 days ago
    Its ridiculous to call her plus sized. She looks great and I would be THRILLED to be her size!
    1824 days ago
    I wholeheartedly agree with you. You know, the young ladies (teens) who show up in our church on Sundays are PAINFULLY thin. I mean they look like they should get medical help they are so thin, but they act as though they are hugely proud of this.

    I don't find it the least attractive, and I don't particularly think this can be healthy either.
    1824 days ago
    Plus size models are generally size 8-10, with 12 being the upper limit. Fashion houses DO tailor the clothes down (or actually, design them abnormally small to fit the models and then tailor them up for sale) in all size ranges. It's insane-- but the fact is that even women who are plus size are less likely to buy clothes they see on an overweight model. Using models who can fit the clothes you're actually making would reduce profits, and how many clothing companies are willing to do that?

    And 1GROVES2, how do you get "government" out of this?!?? The weight guidelines you're referring to are PRIVATE insurance company charts. Everything you're talking about is the "free enterprise" system at work-- anything for profit. The only role any government has had in this is that some OTHER countries and cities have banned advertising using severely underweight models. There are NO government regulations in the US having anything to do with body size, except some states that are considering laws to ban employment discrimination against the obese. When the government does need to make reference to healthy weight, they use standards established by medical professional organizations; the government doesn't set those standards.

    And this woman is right in the middle of the "healthy" BMI range, so even IF the government had anything to do with the BMI range, it still wouldn't have anything to do with this woman being called "plus." That's all, 100% private industry. And it's not even American private industry; this whole story is from England, not the US. Not everything is the government's fault!

    1824 days ago

    Comment edited on: 4/25/2013 2:43:59 PM
    " I " should be so "PLUS SIZE"! I'm shorter & weigh more, so what does that make me?
    JAGUNDA?????????????? emoticon
    1824 days ago
    Did a BMI calculation on those figures and that is a healthy weight. Not a plus size model to me.
    1824 days ago
  • --VICKI--
    I had trouble loading it, but from what I could see, she looked to be about a size 12, and to me that's far from being a plus size. If a 12 is a plus size, this world is seriously screwed. emoticon
    I read further down she's she 157 and 5'9" tall. That would make her about a size 12/14 ( I used to be that weight and I'm 5'9" tall, and I wore a size 14).
    1824 days ago

    Comment edited on: 4/25/2013 11:55:52 AM
    WHAT!! emoticon She looks like a size 10 at most! But at least she is healthy now- both physically and mentally emoticon
    1824 days ago
    **SIGH** That's all I can say.

    HUGS and thanks for the link.
    1824 days ago
    She still looks too skinny to me.

    They must taylor down plus-sized clothes to fit these models. I'm much bigger than that woman and anything plus-sized would absolutely fall off my body.

    Granted, plus size starts a bit smaller in British sizes, but not THAT much.
    1824 days ago
    She looks good. I wouldn't think of her as 'plus size'.
    1824 days ago
    Plus size models are seldom if ever actually plus sized.
    1824 days ago
    Honey, Marilyn Monroe is consider "plus size" if I remember correctly.
    1824 days ago
    Look at how thin models are for regular sizes. Plus size models wear a size 8-10 usually. If you've ever seen a Romans catalog you know what I mean! It's a sick sad world. Thank goodness my husband like a real woman and tells me I'm beautiful and sexy, even though I feel like a blobby slob most days!
    1824 days ago
    i see a healthy woman!
    1824 days ago
  • 1GROVES2
    Yes, I agree....she looks just the right size and I read the article to see if there was something I was missing from the photos....nope! she 157 and 5'9"....
    I don`t know about the rest of the world, but the US changed their guidelines so nearly everyone who has meat on their bones is now obese. In the `70s, when I was in high school, I weighed 115-118# at 5'4" and was just about right looks wise, but the guidelines said I should weigh 137#....they went from ridiculously high to impossible low!
    Thanks for sharing this. I totally agree with you! The government is even peeking at our scales!....and
    I do not get the commercials all over about 1-5 children in US goes to bed hungry (ads for donating to food pantries) how US is the fattest nation!
    OK I will get off your soapbox,
    1824 days ago
    1824 days ago
    Our culture is so out of whack! She looks like a healthy, beautiful woman to me, too.
    1824 days ago
  • Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

    Log in to post a comment

    Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.

More Blogs by LADYIRISH317