Author: Sorting Last Post on Top Message:
KLMAY999 Posts: 57
1/27/12 7:48 A

thx Sergeant, appreciate the info. Also, love the signature quotes. ;-)

1/26/12 2:01 P

Couple of minor corrections, first HIIT is not for the marginally fit, it is a high demand workout. Regardless of how fit you are HIIT will in fact increase your level of fitness. The various charts and electronic monitors use algorithms based on averages so are at best marginally accurate. Your rate of perceived exertion (RPE) is your best determinate as to how hard you are working. A heart rate monitor provides only a guesstimate of your calorie consumption, that can only be accurately measured in a laboratory setting. HIIT causes what is called excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC) which a heart monitor can not measure. A recent study indicates that you will use up to 40% more calories running than you will walking so it is I believe safe to assume there is a differential between calories used at steady state as opposed to interval training.

None of this answers your question but I believe getting any form of accurate value is tenuous at best.

Edited by: SERGEANTMAJOR at: 1/27/2012 (11:40)
KLMAY999 Posts: 57
1/26/12 10:03 A

Yes, thx for all the reesponses - very much appreciated.

I think I am going to get that FT7 and give it a try. I do a lot of cardio and would be nice to see exactly what I am doing.

As far as my HIIT - I warm up for 5 mins, then take my HR to about 150-153, then go back down to about 135 before pumping it back up again.

My max HR is only 168 - I'm 52yrs old, 319lbs (down from 335 Jan 1st) and the trainer at the gym gave me my max HR.

Just curious what would happen if I got close to that max number.

SHADEDK SparkPoints: (4,568)
Fitness Minutes: (1,851)
Posts: 40
1/26/12 8:48 A

Thank you for the links!

MPLANE37 SparkPoints: (79,204)
Fitness Minutes: (79,213)
Posts: 2,170
1/26/12 8:34 A

You can read about HIIT and HIST here:

Edited by: MPLANE37 at: 1/26/2012 (08:34)
SHADEDK SparkPoints: (4,568)
Fitness Minutes: (1,851)
Posts: 40
1/26/12 7:34 A

What exactly is HIIT? I was curious on what people were doing to track calories burned and such, but realize I have no idea what exercise program you're all talking about.

DIMPLES807 Posts: 215
1/26/12 6:51 A

Thanks mplane37. that is really useful information.

MPLANE37 SparkPoints: (79,204)
Fitness Minutes: (79,213)
Posts: 2,170
1/26/12 5:12 A

It is true that HIIT makes you burn more calories after the workout because your body needs to adopt to respond to the new, higher demands caused by the HIIT. The problem is it is hard to calculate accurately how many calories are burned after the exercise, even with a heart rate monitor, even though your heart rate remains higher than the resting HR after an HIIT session. This is because the heart rate monitors are often calibrated for the range between 90 and 150bpm AND actively cardio exercising. For the very same reason, HR monitors cannot tell you the calories burned during strength training, even when your HR falls between these two extremes.

It must also be pointed out that, the HIIT is for people who are not yet fully fit. For a very fit person, HIIT will not do much except shorten the workout for the same calories burned, and will not burn any calories after the exercise, because the body of the fit person is already good enough to respond to intense exercise.

So the returns are diminishing as we get fit with this kind of exercise. Still, I strongly suggest it because it burns more fat while getting fit and it is far less boring and thus more engaging, which makes it likely that we stick with the exercise.

One last point: If the average HR of a HIIT session remains the same as that of steady exercise, the HR monitor will report the same calories burned in both exercises. The point in HIIT is to put demands on the body to force it to improve, not merely increase the HR moderately for a while and reduce it way down next. For example, I remember that after getting used to working out at an average 140bpm for an hour, when my average went to 150bpm for 40 minutes, it placed such a high demand on my cardiovascular system that my heart rate did not go down to resting HR for the next 10 hours or so, and I ended up sleeping only a few hours that night. If I don't place that kind of demand, none of these happens.

Edited by: MPLANE37 at: 1/26/2012 (05:47)
KLMAY999 Posts: 57
1/26/12 4:48 A

What I've been reading tho is HIIT makes your body more calories post workout than a slow jog/walk would. Which is why I started doing HIIT. If what I've been reading isn't true :) I'd rather be fast walking to be honest. lol

UNIDENT Posts: 33,498
1/25/12 11:36 P

FWIW in the meantime, when I used my HRM to compare HIIT with sprint/walk intervals vs a steady state slow jog at my normal pace, it reported the same burn for the same time. Whether 20 minutes of HIIT or 20 minutes at a steady state, I would burn about the same.

SP_COACH_NANCY SparkPoints: (0)
Fitness Minutes: (112,042)
Posts: 46,222
1/25/12 10:17 P


Because of the varying intensity, normal cardio trackers make it difficult to track this type of workout accurately, therefore as the previous poster mentioned, this would be an ideal situation to use a heart rate monitor.

Good luck!
Coach Nancy

KLMAY999 Posts: 57
1/25/12 9:46 P

Thanks a bunch.

I just saw online the Polar FT7 Men's Fitness Heart rate Monitor - looks to be something I might want to think about.

IODOMFIT Posts: 276
1/25/12 9:39 P

You may want to invest in a heart rate monitor that tracks calories. That will probably be your most accurate way to track calories burned. I use one with every workout. It's awesome!

KLMAY999 Posts: 57
1/25/12 9:32 P

I'm trying to locate a calculator that I can use to tell me how many calories I've burned during my HIIT.

For example - tonight I warmed up for 5 mins, did HIIT that was 45 seconds at 150+ HR and 1.5 mins at 135 HR or so.

I've been googling all night to try and find one, but have hit a wall.

Any help is greatly appreciated.


Page: 1 of (1)  

Other Fitness and Exercise Topics:

Topics: Last Post:
Fitness at 50 9/28/2016 11:59:21 PM
didn't walk far, but great 4/24/2017 3:31:01 AM
Sit and Be Fit 11/26/2016 12:44:26 PM
bike ride to xenia ohio 7/13/2016 5:01:50 PM
BEGINNER 9/20/2016 12:32:47 PM