I love peanut butter and I have tried living without it, but it was hard. I had been finding other alternatives for the food I love, but I was having a hard time finding a pb swap until I discovered Better Than Peanut Butter. Its fantastic and tastes EXACTLY like peanut butter. 2 TBSP = 100 cals!
You can find Better Than Peanut Butter at Trader Joe Markets and recently I found it at Target. I'm sure Whole Foods carries it as well as other Natural Food stores. I truly recommend trying this product. It has peanuts in it as well as other natural ingredients. Use it just like regular pb!!