I agree that physical activity is a must for children, but I disagree that mandatory PE or more vigorous activities are the answers. When I was a kid we had required PE (we called it gym back then) through 9th grade and it was torture, bad for my self esteem and havoc on my GPA because I could never do well in PE. If PE classes were tailored to the physical level of the individual child, that would be great but it isn't. It forces kids to be what they aren't. If I could have walked around the track for an hour instead of being forced to play soccer on a team that didn't want me on it, or volleyball, or whatever the game of the week was, I might have learned to enjoy physical fitness at a much younger age and stayed in much better physical shape than I did.
My BF is a 3rd grade teacher. She can attest that the days without PE or recess outside are harder to teacher because they are so ansy.
PE or recess SHOULD be MANDITORY - at least thru middle school
8/27/2012 9:35:55 PM
Whether PE is great or not depends almost completely on the teacher. Some are grossly incompetent. I had an overweight teacher who could never demonstrate anything she demanded we do. This wasn't a problem for me most of the time, since I was a skinny kid with good coordination, but I remember when she tried to force a girl with two left feet to jump over the horse again although she had broken her arm on the first try. And I remember the time when she, because I'd climbed a rope up to the ceiling without waiting for permission, started jangling the rope so I almost fell fifteen feet and my fellow students had to stop her. She could have killed me. The problem is not just that many of them are physically in terrible shape, but that some of them have obvious mental issues, and are cruel, and stupid, and bullies as some comments already mentioned. That is a much bigger problem.
8/27/2012 1:11:10 PM
Now could you explain that to my 1st grader who whines as we walk to school and home each day. LOL!
Why criticize a poll for not bothering to define the many types of families?
This poll did not presume to define "family." I took family to mean the family you choose to define. This could be three roomies or a couple or one parent with a foster child or whatever. I chose to define family as the four adults who don't always live under the same roof but we define ourselves as family.
Please, everyone, feel free to choose how to define your own family. Don't expect a little SP poll to do that for you.
This is part of why I have put my step-son in football. He's getting overweight, has some behavior issues at school (yet not at home...) and his PE at school is a joke. He definitely needed something extra-curricular to help out. He loves it! He's not very good at it yet, but his community league is very good. He plays outside at least an hour a day at home, but needs that extra push.
I HATED PE with a passion. I basically got dressed, did the warm ups, and stood there. This was the minimum I had to do to pass. If it weren't for marching band and my discovery of solitary walks in the woods I would have been completely inactive. I've tried to be open minded about PE with my kids but they aren't athletes either and similarly hate it. I'm all for encouraging activity, dh and I do try to engage the kids in family walks, but PE is not necessarily the way to do it. Its not well rounded enough. Its all about sports and some kids could care less about sports.
I totally disagree with this article. I was required to take P.E. everyday until I was a senior in high school. My grade point actually improved when I did not have to take P.E. P.E, did more to damage your self esteem than any other class. In other classes if you do not have the skills needed on the first day of class, they work with you and teach you. Not in P.E. you need to be a star athlete on the first day of class.
P.E. in my experience is where a lot of bullying takes place, and it is encouraged by the teacher.
Back in the dark ages when I was a kid, we were required to take PE every day, every semester clear through high school. We also were expected to get ourselves to school on foot or by bike. When my kids were in middle school, you could only take the bus if you lived at least two miles from the school. We were 1.9 miles so they rode their bikes, carrying their 20 lb. back packs, lunches, gym clothes, and musical instruments. I can't see that it ddi any of us any harm, especially since it is clear that there was much less obesity in those days. But then, we lived in cities with side walks and cross walks, not in pedestrian-dangerous suburbs.
I don't agree with this article - I did much much better when I was younger and less active than I ever did at high school or college. There are alot of other FACTORS not mentioned there are LOT of other factors like a stable home life etc NOT mentioned that matter AT LEAST as much as what so called fitness does.
I agree totally with this article. My 7 year old daughter is lucky enough to attend a school with these same beliefs. They have a fitness club at 7:30 in the morning where the kids are all given pedometers and they walk and/or run for 30 minutes or until they have walked 1200 steps. Once they have reached the 1200 steps they get 'rewarded' by getting to go to the other side of the gym and play games like red rover, sack races etc. At the end of the month if they have reached 50,000 steps they get awards such as skating, pizza party and the one most of the kids wat - going biking or on a hike with the principal :). She loves going and just like us it gets her body moving and her blood flowing so that when it is time for class she is wide awake and happy. Best part is that the club is absolutely free!! Last time a did a quick head count there were about 100 kids participating :)
I agree that sports, dance, or some other form of exercise is good for kids. My 3rd grader doesn't want to play baseball anymore, and doesn't want to try soccer, basketball, or football. He expressed interest in Karate, so we found a Taekwondo class that doesn't require a 6 month or 12 month contract. And since it's one price for the whole family, we're all taking it. Now when he talks about quitting, we tell him he can, but we're not so he'll have to go and sit quietly or he can participate with us...he chose the latter, thank goodness.
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkTeams, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.