Member Comments for the Article:

6 Diet Rules Meant to be Broken

Out with the Old, in with the New


Leave a Comment Return to Article
  • KSHAFFER3064
    I was lactose intolerant until I started drinking raw milk. I do intermittent fasting, eating during an 8 hour window 11 am to 7 pm. I try to stay under 100 GM carbs and around 1500 calories. good fats, very little bread and pasta, grass fed meat ,free range eggs from my own chickens and organic whole foods as much as possible. I've lost 13 lbs in 2 months without "dieting".
  • Oh, yeah, moderation really works for us. Eating that one bite of chocolate will never lead me to eat the whole giant bar..... Why not just tell all of us lazy slobs to "just eat less and move more"? That works, right?
  • Not one size fits all. You sound like one diet platform fits all people. Sorry it does not. We are unique people with individual situations and conditions and we need to find what works for us and these issues, through trial and error.
    I wish we could find these articles here. Move forward into the new science and as well away from thinking in a box. Accepting even the extremes that are working for people with special conditions. Yes this is a place to start for anyone that knows nothing about healthy eating, but I believe most people when they come here, come here for help because they are in trouble weight and health wise. Don't get me wrong THIS PLACE IS VALUABLE and wonderful, but we s well need to look beyond just one plan. I thank you that you allow us here to do that and share freely as well.
    As well I would pay for a private form with no ads, it really is a pain to work around the zapping and tracking of our every move. Just to have the flow and lack of frustrations. $5.00 a month and not have to deal with all of the ads and would make a fortune...or maybe you already do from the ads and tracking our every move?
  • These "new rules" are too general. Specifically the" Low carb is bad" idea. When i eat any high carb foods, even unprocessed ones, I get heavy fatigue because my body doesn't process them right.
    Maybe it would be wiser to encourage people to eat for their health, rather than your idea of what's good for them.
  • Why, on the G+ post of this article, are we getting a human interest story picture with a list of diet rules!?

    Mistakes like this are committed all the time by the SparkPeople poster on that platform, and it makes me ashamed to reshare articles with my friends because of it, as it makes it seem that SparkPeople is an unprofessional "throw it on the wall and see what sticks" organization. Could the Social Media liaison for SparkPeople *please* start quality reviewing the content for us before posting it.?
  • JULIA_211
    For me, as a struggling binge eater, the evening cut-off time has nothing to do with fear of gaining or indigestion, it's more a personal reminder to stop eating mindlessly before bedtime, plus I like the feeling of an empty stomach in the mornings.
  • This article is one of the reasons I need SparkPeople the most. I knew these myths many years ago and truly believed in living a balanced life (in all things). I also believed that if I listened to my body - it would tell me what it needed - then I started to listen to the myths. Just thinking about the "don't eat after 7PM". I was lactose intolerent as a child and when I stayed at Grandma's she always would have a bedtime snack, small piece of fruit or celery with peanut butter - great nights sleep were guaranteed. At home it was ice cream - I was always up roaming the house alone as a child. I have problems sleeping most of my adult life and have tried for numerous years to follow the rules like don't eat after 7pm. Recently I have been having a snack about hour before going to sleep. And guess what I have had a solid night's sleep everynight for 10 days -but 1.
  • I'm pleased to see the advice about not eating after 7pm is dismissed by SP. I have sleep problems, but contrary to advice have found that when I sometimes eat a bowl of cereal or a banana not long before going to bed I have a better night's sleep. I don't do this every night, just when I've had a string of nights with bad dreams and wakefulness.
  • I just eat smaller portion, drink plenty of water , exercise, 5 fruits and 5 veggies. It works for me.
  • So much silliness still around about what to eat & when. Since Whole Grains are the second oldest food group known to man, Meat was first, how can anyone say we can't eat them?? Whole grains led to Civilization. Anyway, I get the meaning of the article - MODERATION & PORTION CONTROL people - you can eat anything you like & lose weight if you use moderation & portion control. And complex carbohydrates - whole grains, veggies & fruits as close to original as possible are VERY important to a healthy body!!
    This is so true--I went from 276 to 165 by deleating all carbs from my diet--except a few crackers with meals--then of course I went back to 195--where I'm starting over again now..including the carbs I should have never taken from my diet--I did binge-big and learn.
  • Reading all these comments reminds me what is wrong with "dieting" in the first place. There is SO much contradictory stuff out there it could drive a person mad! Carbs are good, no carbs are bad. Fat is good, fat is bad. Only get your fat from animals, only from plants. There is NO winning. Its no wonder people just give up and keep doing what they've always been doing.

    I have to agree with the people who say moderation in all things. And it just so happens to be what my religion believes. If we truly followed this one thing, we'd all be a lot happier. Not too little food, not too much. You can have your favorite food-just moderate yourself. Exercise? Same thing there. Do a moderate amount-dont just sit on the couch thinking about doing it and don't kill yourself by doing three hours a day.

    Okay, Im through ranting......
    Interesting article about the danger behind Gluten Free Dieting
  • I cant wait tell the no gluten fad is out of our society. One of the biggest myths around. Yes there are people who should not eat Gluten, those with an intolerance. BUT gluten DOESNOT make you gain weight. WHOLE GRAIN foods are very good for you and everything is good in moderation. Cut out the white flour, white pasta and white rice and switch to whole grains and you will see a difference.
  • We don't need grains in our diet, that is outdated information pushed on us by Big Food. Becky Hand is behind the times; how many times do people have to remind SP of that?

Comment Pages (7 total)

Leave a comment

  Log in to leave a comment.