Member Comments for the Article:

The Push-Up Test

A DIY Fitness Assessment

125 Comments



  • FOXGLOVE999
    I can't do push ups, never have been able to, not when I was 115 pounds, not now, not ever. I can do a lot of things that others can't, but this is not one of them. - 9/30/2014 9:58:43 AM
  • Can't read the chart for women 50-59 because the How Fit Are You? link is blocking that part of the chart. Any way they can reposition so I can see how I did? - 9/28/2014 10:47:33 AM
  • I started doing pushups and crunches when I started this weight loss program. I am 62, soon to be 63 and I used to roller speed skate, ride bikes over 250 a weekend plus at least 150 during the week, then I trained for triathlons. Gosh, I even used to be able to do one handed pushups, pushups with a clap, you name it. I lifted 150# three times, not once but a few times. I couldn't do one push up in July when I started SP. Now I can pump out 2 sets of 15 modified pushups quite easily. My favorite thing was running/jogging. I loved the 15k the most. I ran in the Disney marathon (my first and last marathon), but I did several 5k, 7k, 15k, half marathons and many, many triathlons. It is disheartening to think I can no longer run, heck I can barely walk 1/4 mile due to the bad knees. Had a Total knee done in 2010 and it never did bend all the way nor straighten out all the way! And it buckles at will. Doc said no pounding (jumping, running etc) or it won't last 20 years. However, I do my walks (marching) here at home and do quite nicely! At least when the ole knee buckles I have something to hang on to! Oh, I've also torn the meniscus in the other knee and have bone on bone pain in it! However, I am optimistic. As long as I can do the walk videos/training videos and work out i.e.pushups,crunches etc. I'm going to keep this weight at a normal level! :) I just love the timed push up. I definitely will try that! I love SP.. :) - 8/30/2014 7:58:39 AM
  • I managed 52 in a minute, probably could have hit 55 but I was using the stopwatch on my phone and it messed up. Pretty proud of myself :D - 7/18/2014 4:43:24 PM
  • JEHOHANAN
    To all of the ladies who are dissapointed about the push up protocol you must recognize that the physiologies of the two sexes differ there's just no way around that. I'm not sure that I recall correctly but the IDF (Israeli Defence Force) and/or the US Army indicates a male advantage of 20%aerobic and 25% anerobic. This is after Basic training during which the females considerably closed the gap that existed at recruitment level. Just google this, Gender Differences in Physical Fitness of Military Recruits .
    Personaly I managed 31 push ups which is excellent for my 75 years. It wasn't that long ago (seems like yesterday) that I could do that on either hand. Since then I have aquired osteoarthritis and it's not gonna get any better. Over the past 12 to 15 years I have lost 25kg of muscle mass mostly in the upper body. When I was 50 I was drawing a 100 lb Longbow 400 times a session now I cannot get between the bow, any bow and it's string at all. I'm still fitness concious however and life goes on hopefully with a laugh or two.

    - 4/17/2014 12:30:35 AM
  • Good ideas. Thanks - 1/18/2014 6:32:41 AM
  • 17 and I'm 30. Not the best but better than I'd have guessed. Going to work up to average for my age at least. - 1/3/2014 3:29:13 PM
  • As Gomer Pyle said "Surprise, Surprise" I found out that I am in the GOOD range!! - 12/30/2013 11:25:40 AM
  • How sad is the world.....I can't do one. LOL Well, only one way to go from here right? Up!! - 12/29/2013 1:10:18 PM
  • Wow, in this case I am glad to be average!!
    - 11/13/2013 5:11:37 PM
  • For all the ladies mad about the charts - these are pretty close to the charts we were rated on in the military doing regular push ups not modified ones. So go ahead and use those charts for the regular pushups to determine how well you do push ups. I think maxed out push ups for women (it's been a few years since I got out) was around the mid 40s. - 11/7/2013 6:39:32 PM
  • JUDGEBOB
    LOL at all the mad women after reading this article. The truth is most women can't do real pushups. Sorry that you are mad at statistics. There are still lots of women that can do pushups but the article is showing the truth that most can't and if they can it is a low amount unless they are modified. Don't be offended by reality and if you are a woman and can do a lot of pushups congratulations. You are a lot stronger than the average woman. That doesn't mean the article is sexiest because you can lol.

    On the second point of a few women there is plenty of guys who can't do a pushup. Yes this is definitely true but in comparison to women its not even close. Sorry gals this isn't something to be offended about. - 10/2/2013 11:16:20 PM
  • Thanks for sharing - 9/25/2013 7:08:47 AM
  • we need a chart for women at regular push ups and modified for men ... seriously many many women can do regular ones and many men can't. - 8/29/2013 11:07:38 AM
  • The pushup chart is useless to women who do traditional pushups. Why can't we have both charts for both sexes? Please stop assuming women can't do real pushups!
    - 8/22/2013 10:05:23 AM

Comment Pages (9 total)
[1]

Leave a comment


  Log in to leave a comment.