I enjoyed this article. In particular, the following words really spoke to me today... "With every small step you take towards your goals, your confidence will build. With every goal you achieve, your self-esteem with sky-rocket. The key is to just start. It's always better to try—even if you mess up along the way — than to never try at all."
I recently watched the similar show "Extreme Makeover: Weightloss Edition" and the trainer said that for the morbidly obese, the benefits of quick weight loss outweigh (sorry!) the risks. Does anyone know if that's true?
Certainly I've always heard that for people who are just overweight, one to two pounds lost per week is appropriate - not 10 or 12!
I've watched the show and while I don't think I would appreciate Bob or Jillian in my face I usually feel really inspired by the end - these people have made the commitment and it's great to see how they've pulled their life around. Consistency IS the key and once we get our head round the idea that we are the onesin control - we put the weight on over a period of time and we'll take the weight off over a period of time and once we get to goal weight - consistently maintain it.
I've never watched the show and don't intend to-for the same reasons that one who have already posted stated. However, I really liked the article! Very realistic, and encouraging! I never thought of making up some challenges for myself, such as setting up bins and moving empty soda cans from one to the other! What a wonderful idea! Here in Florida it is so hot and muggy all summer long, most of my exercise has to be inside the house, so it can get boring. Thanks for the good article!
The points of the article are great. I just wish it hadn't been linked to the show. Losing 100 pounds in 12 weeks is not healthy nor does it suggest that it will be lasting. That is a "quick fix" and those of us in the real world, who have to change our lifestyles won't, can't and shouldn't lose weight at that pace.
Very well written! I need to work on all your points in this article, except the doing it alone. Most of us at work are helping and supporting each other, with eating better and exercising. I'm printing this so I can keep re-reading it when I need to.
I like the idea of the show. I think it is extremely motivating. I think that idea is if this person who is the oldest, heaviest, most unhealthy, etc contestant that they have ever had on the show can lose that much weight, whether it was a year or in this case 12 weeks..it's inspirational. I think, although it should not be the goal for people to lose 100+ lbs in 12 weeks, the idea is that your body can handle so much more than you think it can. I mean, look at athletes, when they work out, sometimes they do throw up, and they are conditioned to work. Now you take a person, who may have never worked out in their life and you throw them on a treadmill and make them go. Sure people are gonna throw up, but the key is KEEP GOING. That's the key - Don't give up. I think that it can be very motivating.
Great article! Don't watch the show, don't like the show, I think watching people be over worked to the point of throwing up, passing out etc, is disgusting and abusive and only feeds into the wrong ideas that too many people feed into. I feel even though they come out of this "stronger" are they really? At what cost? Humiliation, don't find any value in this. To have trainers yelling at you would not motivate me ever! I think it is a very unhealthy way to approach weightloss, and maybe some good things have come out of it, but... when you compare the pros and cons, mmm not for me... I am so not a fan!
I appreciate the biggest loser in the sense that it takes a strong person to be that confident to lose weight on tv but that is not how I feel people should lose weight. they lose too fast and it scares me. I also see all the injuries they have and it really concerns me wether this is really healthy. Yes they need to lose weight but are the broken bones, joints and all the collapses trying to tell us something? It's my own opinion and i know people will disagree but I thought I would put it out there.
I'm with Aggit99, every resource everywhere tells you to lose weight slowly. Plus, after the workouts these people do with all their extra weight, their knees, hips ankles and assorted other joints will give out in the next 5-10 years, even IF they manage to keep the weight off. This show is a bad example of the bootcamp-quick fix mentality and I can't believe that an actual fitness expert is endorsing it.
11/6/2010 9:06:21 PM
I also think that it with requiring them to stand around shirtless when they weigh in is a degrading modern equivalent to a freak show devised to inspire water cooler conversation.
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkTeams, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.