Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Member Comments for the Article:

Find Your Perfect Weight - Part 3

Only You Can Decide What's Good Enough

37 Comments







BONBIT43

2/14/2010 11:43:47 AM

BONBIT43's SparkPage
I AM APPLE SHAPE AND NEVER LIKED IT SO THIS REALLY HEPLED THANKS

ZEBRADOLL

8/11/2009 11:03:20 PM

This article did not help me at all.

SARAWITHOUTH

6/24/2009 2:14:30 PM

SARAWITHOUTH's SparkPage
This article is awesome - I was concerned when I stoped losing pounds, although I continued to lose fat. It was sad to think that I would never get down to my goal weight. Now I know, I probably won't ever be my goal weight, because my goal weight is wrong! I am much happier about my fat loss now. Thanks :-)

KRISB44

3/24/2009 12:32:26 PM

KRISB44's SparkPage
When my son was three we were out walking and he saw an old man, very wrinkled and overweight but my son could not stop looking at this man. When I asked him what he was staring at and to stop staring (as I thought he was being rude - being 3 years old) He said to me in a very awed tone, "Isn't that man beautiful Mommy?" I looked at the man again and all of a sudden it was like the life that this man had lived and the laughter that went along with each and every wrinkle was revealed to me. He was indeed "beautiful".

ALZ514

2/21/2009 2:09:45 PM

I just wanted to say how refreshing it is to see an article discussing a "perfect weight" that doesn't just spit out some irrelevant number based solely on a BMI scale. That would work if we were all cookie cutter people. I am in the process of recovering from an eating disorder that was started by a simple and innocent diet and fed by the societal acceptance I received by every pound I lost. Thank you for discussing different body types and the emotional and mental side to dieting and choosing a "perfect weight". This is one of the few articles that I've seen that discusses these topics and I just wish that everyone could read this and learn the valuable lessons and the truth behind the study of body types, acceptance of them, and also the incredibly tough question of "what weight will make you happy?" Thank you, I will tell everyone woman I know to read this article.

MYLYFE

12/11/2008 8:11:24 AM

MYLYFE's SparkPage
Good article.

**EVA**

9/23/2008 7:22:47 AM

**EVA**'s SparkPage
Somewhere along the way in life I lost control over me and listened to the brainwashings of society and those close to me. That word picture (pretend senario) jolted me awake! I am ready to get back to being ME! Thank you for walking me through the process. I feel equipped now to get off the treadmill of life and get back into my own skin and enjoy being me.

SAM60SUMTHINK

7/23/2008 1:24:46 AM

SAM60SUMTHINK's SparkPage
Fantastic article. MOTIVATING!

And loved the (ahhh very creative and mind-jogging!) the way you ended it, Coach Dean!

Thank you for yet another great article!

JIBBIE49

6/22/2008 2:52:55 AM

JIBBIE49's SparkPage
Good article.

NOTBLUSHING

6/19/2008 7:58:29 AM

NOTBLUSHING's SparkPage
Contrary to one of the statements in this article, there is a LOT of scientific evidence suggesting that people do indeed treat you very differently if you are obese.

LSTOUTE142

6/14/2008 4:23:58 AM

LSTOUTE142's SparkPage
Wow, this article really hit home for me. I started spark at 145 and my origianl goal was to lose ten pounds, then I changed it to fifteen(that whole ten percent thing). And the very last question Coach Dean asked was what really got me--I think I'm pretty happy with my current body weight. A few more pounds might be nice, but I feel good about myself and my body. Wow, I'll have to keep this article in mind as I go through my weight loss.

GIRLINMICH

6/11/2008 10:09:17 PM

I don't know what my ideal weight is, and at this point I dont care to figure it out. My first goal is to get below 250, my second goal is to get out of plus size clothing and/or get below 200. When I hit a size 14/16 again then I can re-visit what my ideal size is. It's working so far, 13 lbs in 4 weeks and still going strong - and doing it right. Good food, lots of exercise and some strength training. Spark people rules.

I feel sad for those people who are below a size 8 and think they need to lose more. healthy to me doesn't mean stick thin.

SARAHTAIT

5/1/2008 2:07:41 PM

SARAHTAIT's SparkPage
I am still having issues deciding on my goal weight as I am told I am thin enough by friends and family but by charts and my doctor I still need to lose about 10 more pounds. I am going for the ten more pounds I think to see how it feels on my but if I can not realistically have a life being that thin then I will do what I need to do to be able to eat some goodies every now and then. It is hard to find that "perfect" weight" for you and I am hoping when I find it I will know it.

GRANNY701

4/30/2008 5:20:10 AM

GRANNY701's SparkPage
Great article, but I let my doctor determine my ideal weight. It is 5 pounds higher than I would have opted for, but I pay him for his advice and so far he has always been right. I lost 35 pounds and fel\el wonderful. Am the same weight as when I graduated from high school (56 years ago),walk 2 miles each day and do cardio 3 times a week. GO SparkPeople!!!!!!!!

MYTIME

4/29/2008 6:59:52 PM

MYTIME's SparkPage
You’re at your ideal body weight when:

**You can accept your body as it is, without feeling uncomfortably self-conscious. **
You can enjoy being in your own skin, without worrying too much about how you compare to others (or cultural ideals).


I have been kind of stuck for finding motivation. After losing 100 pounds, and feeling so good, losing more just does not seem as important. The above criteria brings home to me that if I want to continue losing, I will need to seek other motivation, cuz right now, I feel GOOD!

I will be reading the first 2 installments of this series to see if I can find a way to find my "ideal" weight & work towards that.

Thanks for a great article!
Alice

Comment Pages (3 total)
[2]

Leave a comment


  Log in to leave a comment.