Team Leaders
Team Stream
Team Stats
Total SparkPoints:
19,197,121
Total Fitness Minutes:
14,665,706
Apr 2014 SparkPoints:
273,409
Apr 2014 Minutes:
256,994
See Team Leaderboards
See Category Leaderboards


Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.
 

team482forum


  Team Forum
Living Low Carb (Atkins and other Plans)

A Guide to Posting in Your SparkTeam Forum

  FORUM:   General Team Discussion Forum
TOPIC:   AMA Declares Obesity a disease 


Search
Reply Create A New Topic Subscribe to this Discussion
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.
Author: Message: Sorting Last Post on Top


GEMINIGEM6
GEMINIGEM6's Photo SparkPoints: (20,748)
Fitness Minutes: (7,550)
Posts: 3,567
6/24/13 12:10 A

GEMINIGEM6's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Lol @ SUZANNEYEA

#agreed


"It is never too late to be what you might have been."
George Eliot



 current weight: 205.0 
 
236
219.5
203
186.5
170


SKINNYYENNY
SKINNYYENNY's Photo Posts: 109
6/23/13 11:32 P

SKINNYYENNY's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I would like to believe that it will mean doctors can now prescribe things like personal trainers, gym memberships, and counseling with a dietician.

I think it might also make a lot of people take their obesity more serioiusly and really understand that this is soemthing that can and will eventually kill them.

I also think it will just simply open lines of communication between drs and patients. Rather than giving pills for hypertension, they might give advice that losing weight can be an option - that hypertension (in many cases) is a symptom of the disease of being obese rather than looking at hypertension as a disease/disorder in and of itself.

I guess time will tell.....

oh - and btw - many insurance programs already cover lap band.

Slow and steady wins the race.


 Pounds lost: 14.1 
 
0
13.5
27
40.5
54


SUZANNEYEA
SUZANNEYEA's Photo Posts: 4,342
6/20/13 4:37 P

SUZANNEYEA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
This just means that insurance companies will cover lap band surgery. No one will change their diet.



LIVINMYDREAMS
LIVINMYDREAMS's Photo Posts: 3,342
6/20/13 4:09 P

LIVINMYDREAMS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
And then with it being a disease will employers/insurance companies not be able to discriminate towards "fat" people...

Faith
RTKR - 6/23/11 - 305
Sept 2011 - 315
LTKR - 7/26/12 - 257
Jan 1st 2013 - 241
Jan 1st 2014- 231
Jan 1st 2015 - goal Onederland !!!**************************** One can never consent to creep when one feels an impulse to soar!


 current weight: 237.2 
 
315
268.75
222.5
176.25
130


HISTORYRUNNER
HISTORYRUNNER's Photo SparkPoints: (2,821)
Fitness Minutes: (0)
Posts: 400
6/20/13 11:51 A

HISTORYRUNNER's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I read the AMA's decision at several levels. First, it's an admission that as a nation we're losing the "war against obesity." Second, as several of the previous posts have stated, it portrays obesity as a disease, to be cured through the usual methods of modern western medicine. Expect an expensive search for a magic bullet "cure" for obesity (think cancer) with lots of celebrity and public fundraisers (think cancer again. I wonder what color ribbon they will pick), mixed with lots of traditional diet and exercise advice. Third, also as previously noted, this misses the base causes for obesity, which to me seem to be: outdated/wrongheaded dietary advice; generally poor cultural eating habits; and an industrial food production/distribution system which makes eating healthily very hard even for those with sufficient knowledge and resources and almost impossible for the majority of the populace which lacks these assets. So - while the additional attention that doctors will have to give to this is a plus, unless, as Birgit and Woubbie have just posted, we change our basic paradigms about how we understand the connection between nutrition, diet, and health, I fear we won't make much progress. One silver lining is that the increased costs to insurance companies might drive market forces to find more effective solutions, including "alternative" approaches to diet/nutrition?


Running records:

5-K: 22:49 (2007)
10-K: 46:50 (2012)
8-mile trail run (2013): 1:19:26
Half-Marathon: 1:49:28 (2013)


HOUNDLOVER1
HOUNDLOVER1's Photo Posts: 7,618
6/20/13 11:24 A

HOUNDLOVER1's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I saw this yesterday, too, and had mixed feelings.
My very preliminary thoughts are this: If obesity is a disease (legally) then insurance companies need to pay for treatment (without other symptoms), doctors need to treat it and our over-burdened health-care system will be even more in trouble - unless doctors become experts at curing rather than managing obesity, in which case all the diseases that are secondary to obesity are prevented in many cases.
So here is your reason to do anything you can to spread the message to every doctor in the country how obesity can be cured, and along with it heart disease, diabetes, stroke and many cancers.
I just posted this link in my blog last night but it fits in here as a great starting point to educate physicians in particular that is free on the internet. A great talk by Peter Attia that is available on youtube:
eatingacademy.com/personal/my-quantified-s
elf-part-i?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=r
ss&utm_campaign=my-quantified-self-part-i


Birgit

Edited by: HOUNDLOVER1 at: 6/20/2013 (11:27)
You can talk to God all you want and that's great, but the changes happen when you start listening to him.

BE THE CHANGE YOU WANT TO SEE IN OTHERS.




 Body Fat %: 18.3
 
23.6
22.2
20.8
19.4
18


WOUBBIE
WOUBBIE's Photo SparkPoints: (59,432)
Fitness Minutes: (15,995)
Posts: 4,147
6/20/13 11:17 A

WOUBBIE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Obesity probably IS a disease for a tiny fraction of the population - what Taubes has called a "disorder of fat metabolism". These people would be obese regardless of the food supply.

What's going on today is NOT generally caused by a disorder of fat metabolism. It is caused by our food supply - fattening, addictive, and abundant.

This label will only help people if the medical community actually ever gets its hands on good information as to the root causes of obesity, and then extrapolates the most successful means of neutralizing those causes. There is no CURE, just as there is no cure for any addiction, there is only the hope of remission and continued abstinence.

The LAST thing we need is MORE PILLS!!!!!

Edited by: WOUBBIE at: 6/20/2013 (11:19)
Pray for Ukraine... Slava Ukraina!


 current weight: 198.0 
 
232
217
202
187
172


SUZANNEYEA
SUZANNEYEA's Photo Posts: 4,342
6/20/13 10:44 A

SUZANNEYEA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Not a disease in my opinion. An addiction? Yes.



FROGMAN2013
FROGMAN2013's Photo SparkPoints: (1,747)
Fitness Minutes: (1,690)
Posts: 77
6/20/13 9:50 A

FROGMAN2013's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I am trying to maintain a positive attitude about this. For so long, the medical community has treated the symptoms rather than the cause. Hey, instead of finding treatments for heart disease, diabetes and some cancers, how about treating the causes of these (obesity and smoking) as diseases? Often, the cure to a disease is to prevent it from every happening. Maybe treating that fat 20 year old with respect and doing things to help them lose some weight will make it so you don't have to treat their diabetes years later. Maybe teaching that slightly chubby 10 year old ways that can help them never be fat would be a good thing! Maybe teaching that baby's parent good ways to keep a kid healthy would be a good thing!

Edited by: FROGMAN2013 at: 6/20/2013 (09:52)
I lost a lot of weight and maintained it for years, then I got all stressed and busy and lost my way. Starting over from a much better place (way less to lose this time!) and making things better.


 current weight: 263.0 
 
270
255
240
225
210


BUDGETMAW
Posts: 1,645
6/20/13 7:50 A

BUDGETMAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I have mixed feelings about this, for some reason. I had intended to expound on my reasons for the mixed feelings, but everything I think of sounds silly or irrelevant or something.





MOXIE6
MOXIE6's Photo Posts: 516
6/20/13 7:01 A

MOXIE6's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
www.latimes.com/news/science/la-sci-obesit
y-disease-20130619,0,4422080.story


I am starting my ticker again since starting low carb....in the home strech!
You have no control over what you weigh...only what you do.
Progress NOT Perfection!


 Pounds lost: 6.0 
 
0
10.5
21
31.5
42


 
Page: 1 of (1)  
   
Report Innappropriate Post

Other Living Low Carb (Atkins and other Plans) General Team Discussion Forum Posts


Thread URL: http://www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/team_messageboard_thread.asp?board=0x482x53814389

Review our Community Guidelines