We're loving Fred, but we've just begun it. We're only a few lessons into Apples. There's a blog called Noah's Ark Homeschool that has some neat supplemental activities to go along with Fred, but it looks like only about the first 8 lessons for Apples. The activities add some enrichment and extension, but aren't really necessary.
I think for my son's age (6) that some manipulatives are helpful. We have some pattern blocks that he loves, and I got some "table scatter" at Target a while back that we use as counters. (Cheaper than things sold as "counters," and lots of fun for different seasons.) We've used other stuff we had on hand...Duplos, Trios, etc. to work on place value concepts and pre-multiplication skills.
We're also using a book I got from Costco called "Sylvan Super Math Success." He likes doing the worksheets. He's gifted in math, so he's enjoying the challenge of the 2nd grade workbook. (Which makes up for the fact that his Fred math so far is pretty simple for him.)
Not really a review of Fred, but I'm finding all of it together is working very well, and I didn't spend very much on any of it.
I guess my biggest disadvantage when looking at the cathy duffy review is that I don't have a Wiggly Willy, Perfect Paula, or Competent Carl.... I have the Stresses over everything Sally. I have a child that everytime I ask her, " is that your final answer?" Even when she is 100% correct she doubts herself and changes everything to somehing wrong.
I can handle not having an excessive amount of review problems for her to work IF she gets understanding from the curriculum. Not to mention hubby majored on math, but he just can't be the math teacher because he doesn't understand why math doesn't come as easily to her as it did him. I am sure if. He can't create problems I can find review online or workbooks to go through as well.
I appreciate the honest review from someone who has used the curriculum. Thank you!
Mary, mom to 4 beautiful children that deserve a healthy and active mother
I've used the Fractions, Decimals and Percents, Pre-Algebra I with Biology, Beginning Algebra, and Advanced Algebra. My oldest is half way through Geometry and my second child will start Pre-Algebra II with Economics next week.
I haven't used, nor seen in person, the younger levels. However, I have compared the upper levels to Saxon Algebra I and II and to my college Algebra course, and Life of Fred more than stands on its own. Life of Fred Beginning Algebra has more in common with Saxon Algebra II than I, and Life of Fred Advanced Algebra was comparable to my college Algebra class, and in fact covered a few things more.
The issue with Life of Fred comes into play with the author's philosophies of learning math and homeschooling. His philosophy on homeschooling is that we, homeschoolers, are putting our children at a disadvantage if we give them any less than an A in a high school course because of how public schools grade and such. Because of this there are no tests, and even the "Cities" occasionally have teaching material in the solutions and can't be used as tests. The approach is simply keep at it until you master it and get record an A. This "give an A" without tests, without grading homework, just when they know the material, or repeating a chapter if they don't have it, well that is hard for some parents to feel comfortable with.
Second, the author's philosophy of how students best master material is kind of a shock to those not expecting. He feels that for a student to best “own” something that they need to wrestle or struggle with it first. He doesn’t spoon feed the information to the student, but rather explains it plain enough but then asks the students to use that information in ways he hasn’t explained. This is probably a double surprise when it comes to Life of Fred, because the story line of the books is so light hearted and silly that anyone just glancing over the books assumes that the math is equally light and “supplemental”. The books aren’t that thick, and there aren’t that many problems to do even with the Companion books, but even so it took my very mathy son a year and a half to do Beginning Algebra and a year to do Advanced Algebra (this was before the Zillions of Algebra Problems book came out too).
A saving grace for this wrestle to learn philosophy is that the author is so readily available by email. We have had to email a couple of times for help and he has always replied within just a few hours (and both times the answer was so obvious, once pointed out to us, that it was a “duh” moment).
All that to say I LOVE Life of Fred and, at the high levels at least, find it to be more than comprehensive enough to serve as a student’s sole math. BUT I do not think it is a good match for everyone. If it helps to discuss in terms of Cathy Duffy’s learning styles, my oldest is a blend of Wiggly Willy, Perfect Paula, and Competent Carl (he shares qualities of all 3 equally). Life of Fred took some time for him to get used to that method of learning, but it has been worth it and he plans to continue with it through Calculus, at least. I think that is the reason that we have had success with it even though it was such a struggle through places; he, that is my son, chose to use Life of Fred. I picked 3 or 4 Algebra programs that I felt I could live with, and I allowed him to choose which he wanted to do. When we struggled so greatly with the Beginning Algebra book, I offered him the chance to use something else for Algebra II and Geometry and he still wanted to stay with Life of Fred.
But, my second child, my daughter Lily, won’t be using Life of Fred for Algebra and above. She has done the Fractions, Decimals and Percents, and Pre-Algebra I with Biology books, and I do plan to have her continue with the Pre-Algebra II with Economics book, but she already knows that she does not want to continue with it for Algebra and above. Lily is more in line with the Perfect Paula learning style than any other.
Anyway, while I won’t be using Life of Fred with my second child for high school math, I am glad that I will have the books available as references. Some of the explanations in them are absolute gems. His method of factoring polynomials is worth the price of the Beginning Algebra book alone. So, for my second child, the Life of Fred books will be supplements, although in the respect that I plan to use them here and there as we find need, but it would be too much for her to work them completely while also doing another curriculum completely.
Robin E. Why rain as ticker? Because where I live rain is something to rejoice in.
"Perseverance is not a long race; it is many short races one after the other." ~Walter Elliot
I was almost lost on the apples, butterflies and cats... I was/ have only looked at the Pre-alg+ levels. I think I may buy the companion, the pre-alg, and the extra problems book to go through. I may consider fractions to supplement my second dd's math next year. But she seems to be doing well with MUS for now.
Mary, mom to 4 beautiful children that deserve a healthy and active mother
Pounds lost: 0.0
Fitness Minutes: (25,889) Posts: 1,978 1/18/13 4:04 P
I know of one family for whom this curriculum was a real blessing for a certain kind of learner. To borrow a few phrases from Cathy Duffy....your Competent Carl and Perfect Paula won't like it but Wiggly Willy will love it.
Proverbs 3: 5-8 "Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding; in all your ways acknowledge Him, and He will make your paths straight. Do not be wise in your own eyes; fear the Lord and shun evil. This will bring health to your body and nourishment to your bones. "
current weight: 181.0
Fitness Minutes: (64,898) Posts: 634 1/18/13 1:01 P
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.