At this point, I would suggest My Fitness Coach for a great workout (though it doesn't use the balance board... just occasional feedback using the Wiimote).
I found EA SportsActive a bit annoying because I can never get the leg strap to fit right so the either the squats or the running don't read right. But my boyfriend did like the program and didn't have the same issue.
I just bought The Biggest Loser, just have just had one day on it so far so don't have much feedback. It does have total body workout including calorie tracking.
-- Treasurer of TOPS #OH341, Westerville
aka Mistress Motivation
| current weight: 242.3