I have natural peanut butter that I've had for over a year and never refrigerated it, even though it was past the "best used by" date. If you knew you were going to use it, and you feel better about refrigerating it, get it out a couple of hours before you use it. That way it won't be cold.
I think if you keep it in a dark, cool place like a basement, it would be cool enough, I would think.
I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me
| March Minutes: 393