Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   Diet and Nutrition
TOPIC:  

Diet soda makes me hungry?



Click here to read our frequently asked Diet and Nutrition questions.

 
  Reply Create A New Topic
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
  I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top


CAH-RD
CAH-RD's Photo Posts: 945
10/9/13 11:31 A

CAH-RD's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I'd say skip the soda than. Soda (being diet or regular) is terribly unhealthy for us anyway. Can you save your soda for special occasions?

Drink water...LOTS of water. No, it's not like drinking soda, but it's healthy and good for your body. Although I'd *prefer* to drink soda, I drink water all day and make myself get at least 64oz (but lately I've been doing more like 96oz). You'll feel so much better!!



 Pounds lost: 2.0 
 
0
5.5
11
16.5
22


SUNSHINE6442
Posts: 1,791
10/9/13 9:39 A

SUNSHINE6442's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I read this article...
Does switching to diet sodas help? Although some research has suggested that people who drink artificially sweetened sodas as part of a calorie-restricted diet do lose weight, other studies have suggested that diet soft drinks could even lead to weight gain. For now, there’s no conclusive evidence either way.

Mary Nash Stoddard says, "It's well documented that excitotoxins like aspartame have the reverse affect on weight. People drinking diet drinks and eating diet food will get more hungry.

The FDA no longer allows manufacturers of diet supplement drinks and foods containing aspartame to label them as weight reduction products, but requires that they be labeled as diet drink or diet food. A study of 80,000 women who use sweeteners were evaluated through the Centers for Disease Control. It was found that they gained rather than lost weight using artificial sweeteners."

http://marystod.blogspot.com/2011/04/aspartame-and-mental-disorders.html



MISSRUTH
MISSRUTH's Photo Posts: 3,367
10/9/13 8:55 A

MISSRUTH's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I reckon if it seems like drinking diet soda makes you hungry.... try switching to water. I agree with Kris that maybe you were hungry to begin with, when you drank the soda. And filling up your stomach with a zero-calorie beverage didn't do anything for the hunger in the first place. It makes you feel full, but doesn't give your body any fuel.

IDK that I'd necessarily say diet soda makes a person crave sweets. Or that artificial sweeteners are "evil" or cause obesity. I think sometimes people fall into the kind of thinking where... "the calories in the Snickers bar are cancelled out by the Diet Coke I washed it down with". And IMO eating sugar sets up cravings for more sugar. Certainly for some people, it may be true that drinking artificially sweetened beverages sets them up for cravings for other sweet tasting things. And some people have digestive issues, with certain artificial sweeteners. IMO it's something we each have to think about and decide for ourselves. I use artificial sweeteners in my coffee every morning; I don't think that's what made me fat. What made me fat was eating waaaaay too many calories, and not exercising. Ever. I've lost the weight, I still use artificial sweeteners, and I stay away from sugar.

Ruth in Cookeville, TN Central Time Zone


Promise me you'll always remember: You're braver than you believe, and stronger than you seem, and smarter than you think - Christopher Robin to Pooh


 August Minutes: 982
 
0
500
1000
1500
2000


CALLMECARRIE
CALLMECARRIE's Photo Posts: 1,598
10/9/13 8:26 A

CALLMECARRIE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I've noticed that diet soda can make me a little hungrier, especially in large amounts. But if I drink one diet soda with my lunch or dinner, it doesn't have that effect. It seems it makes me most hungry when I was kind of hungry anyway, like at 10:00 in the morning.

One or two diet sodas or teas a day really helps me feel like I've gotten a sweet treat; it prevents me from falling prey to the cakes and cookies and pies they serve in the cafeteria where I work.

"I owe everything you see here to spaghetti."

-Sophia Loren


 current weight: 173.3 
 
285
253.75
222.5
191.25
160


JUSTEATREALFOOD
JUSTEATREALFOOD's Photo Posts: 1,164
10/9/13 7:56 A

JUSTEATREALFOOD's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I think diet soda is very sweet and can really mess up your palate.

Think about it, I haven't drank a pop diet or regular in years. I have slowly weaned myself down off sugar and am at the point where if I make muffins I sweeten them with bananas. I eat 85% dark chocolate and anything less tastes like milk chocolate and is too sweet. When I make custard for a treat I add no sugar to it and just enjoy the sliced banana I put I it for sweetness. When I make salmon patties they taste sweet to me (salmon, almond flour, egg, onions and celery). My taste buds are used to eating foods low in sugar and if I eat foods that have a lot of sweetness it ruins the food for me because the sweetness takes over all the other flavours.

Eating foods that are really sweet on a daily basis is settting yourself up to eat sweet things all the time. You get used to the flavour of sweet and therefore consume more sugar or artificial sweeteners on a consistent basis both of which I believe to be harmful to the human body.

If you can drink something else do it! Water, herbal tea, hot lemon water or even coffee. Just remember to hold the sugar and sweeteners.

JERF - Just Eat Real Food


I'm a Certified Personal Trainer.

I eat mostly vegetables, fats, meats, some fruit and dark chocolate. Unprocessed and preservative free. And it's changed my life!

5'4"
Goal weight 125lbs
36 years old
2 kids

Keeping my blood sugar levels low on my high fat/ low carb/ moderate protein diet.


Perfection is not attainable, but if we chase perfection we can catch excellence.

- Vince Lombardi


172 Maintenance Weeks
 
0
45
90
135
180


NACHTSKAI
NACHTSKAI's Photo SparkPoints: (11,921)
Fitness Minutes: (4,131)
Posts: 536
10/9/13 6:28 A

Send Private Message
Reply
I drink diet coke every morning and it doesn't make me hungary. I eat a healthy diet and get the nutrients and minerals my body needs so I don't have a need for extra food. Every body is different when it comes to soda and food.



 Pounds lost: 14.0 
 
0
8.5
17
25.5
34


SLIMMERKIWI
SLIMMERKIWI's Photo SparkPoints: (125,330)
Fitness Minutes: (32,590)
Posts: 21,262
10/9/13 5:12 A



SLIMMERKIWI's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I'm not offering an answer one way or another but here is another angle no-one seems to have stumbled on.

It is possible that you were hungry in the first place, and drank the soda, perhaps mistaking that hunger for thirst. If it can happen that people eat when in fact they are thirsty, I would imagine that the reverse can be true, too. Anyway, IF that is the case, then those who drink the diet soda, and then get ravenous may have just realized that they were hungry when it got bad after the soda, not recognizing it prior to the soda, therefore the diet soda gets the rap!

Kris



Edited by: SLIMMERKIWI at: 10/9/2013 (05:12)
Co-Moderator Dealing with Depression
www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/groups_i
ndividual.asp?gid=953


Team Leader Essential Tremors :-) (Benign and Familial) www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/groups_i
ndividual.asp?gid=30225


Co-Leader Crohn's Can't Stop Me
www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/groups_i
ndividual.asp?gid=17464


I am not a Dr - please check with your qualified Health Professional for a diagnosis and treatment plan


 current weight: 151.0 
 
211
196
181
166
151


ALORTA
ALORTA's Photo SparkPoints: (7,310)
Fitness Minutes: (3,449)
Posts: 310
10/9/13 3:26 A

ALORTA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Actually, its true that they make you hungry.
I posted about it earlier but was shot down by Betty... I've recently followed up with the doctor who lectured on the subject and he expalined why her argument that they were safe for DIABETICS is true... but that they do, in fact, induce a feeling of hunger in healthy people.
I can't find the original post but here's a summary of what he said... paraphrased and somewhat simplified;
your body, while telling you that "hey, this drink is sweet" is also telling other parts "sugar is coming", so it releases substances that prepare you for absorption of said sugar, which includes lowering the amount of sugar floating around in your bloodstream.
When you drink diet soda, no actual sugars come over... but your body has already started preparing for them, so its blood sugar dips *slightly* below its happy level. This makes it tell you that "hey, I'd like some extra sugar" aka, making you feel slightly hungry.
In diabetics, the system that controls the above is totally out of whack... that's why they have diabetes. They are either unable to make or insensitive to Insulin... so the above doesn't happen (or doesn't induce anything, anyway).
Again, this is a *tiny* change, not the kind of surge you get after a meal to prevent hyperglycemia (which is what diabetics take drugs to prevent, since they can't regulate it themselves).
In summary;
No, there's no study.
Yes, like people here have said, diet sodas can make you feel hungry... there is biochemical basis for it.
No, it probably isn't the difference between over-eating and eating right... but it might be an extra (tiny) urge you need to ignore.

In my personal opinion, we won't know how "safe" all the chem in diet sodas is for years to come, and the calories are preferable to all the extra headache of worrying if something in them will be retroactively linked to some weird cancer, etc 50yrs down the road.




 current weight: 172.0 
 
187
170.5
154
137.5
121


MANDIETERRIER1
MANDIETERRIER1's Photo Posts: 13,599
11/27/12 11:05 P

MANDIETERRIER1's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Diet sodas make me so hungry. I cannot drink them, but that is just me. I know they help some people

Made it to my maintenance weight of 125 pounds.

Even though I have reached goal. I still don't know everything about weight loss.

Please read my blog

erinwroteablogyall.blogspot.com/2014
/08/shame-shame-shame.html


16 Maintenance Weeks
 
0
5
10
15
20


DIETITIANBECKY
DIETITIANBECKY's Photo Posts: 26,532
11/27/12 6:29 P

SparkPeople Team Member

DIETITIANBECKY's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Just to correct some misinformation on this thread...
Research evidence has "not" shown artifical sweeteners to cause weight gain.

There are a couple of studies that indicate in " a few" people the sweet flavor of artificial sweeteners brings about the desire for more sweet foods. For most people this is not the case. Therefore using zero calorie beverages (ie diet drinks), is a way to cut calories from one's diet when used in place of sugar-filled drinks.

SP Dietitian Becky



DIDS70
DIDS70's Photo Posts: 5,070
11/27/12 4:59 P

DIDS70's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I have found that soda and breads make me hungry. I stopped drinking soda years ago and got off whole grains, refined flour, refined sugar and dairy within the last two years. Now a salad fills me up (i use lots of other veggies and some nuts on it.)

:)


 current weight: 250.0 
 
250
220
190
160
130


SUNSHINE6442
Posts: 1,791
11/27/12 8:28 A

SUNSHINE6442's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Dr Mark Hyman Says "Stop confusing your body. If you have a desire for something sweet, have a little sugar, but stay away from “fake” foods. Researchers found that the total food eaten over 14 days dramatically increased in the artificial sweetener group — meaning that the artificial sweetener stimulated their appetite and made them eat more!"

"THERE’S NO DOUBT about it. Artificial sweeteners cause obesity"

Eliminate sugar and artificial sweeteners and your cravings will go away: Go cold turkey. If you are addicted to narcotics or alcohol you can’t simply just cut down. You have to stop for you brain to reset. Eliminate refined sugars, sodas, fruit juices, and artificial sweeteners from your diet. These are all drugs that will fuel cravings.



MCOGIRL
MCOGIRL's Photo Posts: 91
11/27/12 7:43 A

Send Private Message
Reply
Its the artificial sugar in them. They fool your body into thinking you are drinking sugar and cause cravings. I have to limit my artificial sugars too or I just get caught in a cycle of cravings..... I try to do black coffee or unsweetened tea if I am sick of water.



MPLANE37
MPLANE37's Photo SparkPoints: (65,001)
Fitness Minutes: (35,097)
Posts: 2,166
11/27/12 5:56 A

MPLANE37's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
The weak acid in the sodas (and in most processed foods) can provoke a feeling of hunger even though there isn't any hunger. It does happen to me too, but it happens more frequently when I am under stress. I drink diet soda only occasionally, and sometimes it does nothing, other times it provokes hunger.

``Don't break the chain." -Jerry Seinfeld
``Moments of silence are part of the music." -Anonymous


 Body Fat %: 23.7
 
30
25
20
15
10


YOJULEZ
YOJULEZ's Photo SparkPoints: (15,605)
Fitness Minutes: (120)
Posts: 2,171
11/26/12 9:51 P

YOJULEZ's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I don't, but I've heard of a lot of people who do.

Since you're not drinking it for the caffeine, I'd say cut them out. Do water with lemon or something instead. If you like the fizz, get carbonated/tonic water.

Working on maintaining at 140!

If you're interested in checking out the food I've made and liked, come visit me on Pinterest, and feel free to follow me:
pinterest.com/julieanneco/foodz-trie
d-and-liked/


 current weight: 144.0 
 
188
176
164
152
140


KRISTEN_SAYS
KRISTEN_SAYS's Photo SparkPoints: (73,318)
Fitness Minutes: (34,635)
Posts: 5,088
11/26/12 9:03 P

KRISTEN_SAYS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I don't drink soda, but it might be a good idea to stop drinking it if it could potentially make you overeat.

- Kristen
Weight loss blog: fitfoodieblog.wordpress.com/

Happiness is just a step away.


 current weight: 110.0 
 
160
147.5
135
122.5
110


LUANN_IN_PA
Posts: 15,939
11/26/12 8:41 P

LUANN_IN_PA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Nope.

But if they did, I would stop drinking them!

“We cannot change the cards we are dealt, just how we play the hand.”
~ Randy Pausch

"There's a difference between interest and commitment. When you're interested in doing something, you do it only when circumstance permit. When you're committed to something, you accept no excuses, only results."
~ Art Turock

"We have a saying in Tibet: If a problem can be solved, there is no use worrying about it. If it can't be solved, worrying will do no good."
~ 7 Years in Tibet


M2MOMSC
M2MOMSC's Photo Posts: 18
11/26/12 7:06 P

M2MOMSC's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Anybody else experience this? I don't drink sugared soda, I only drink diet orange and diet gingerale. I have discovered that if I drink these I'm much more hungry than if I drink other things.

One Day At A Time


 current weight: 113.8 
 
127
123
119
115
111


 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  

I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Report Innappropriate Post


Thread URL: http://www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/messageboard.asp?imboard=7&imparent=29449735

Review our Community Guidelines



 
Diet Resources: hormones in food effects | female hormones in food | hormones in food production