Yes... or at least they should be! A 5 pound weigh on any scale should weigh in as 5 pounds.
But YOU are not the same throughout the day. Hence the fluctuations.
“We cannot change the cards we are dealt, just how we play the hand.” ~ Randy Pausch
"There's a difference between interest and commitment. When you're interested in doing something, you do it only when circumstance permit. When you're committed to something, you accept no excuses, only results." ~ Art Turock
"We have a saying in Tibet: If a problem can be solved, there is no use worrying about it. If it can't be solved, worrying will do no good." ~ 7 Years in Tibet
Even with the same scale, you may not get an accurate accounting of your weight loss. I agree that sticking to the same scale is your best bet to see progress, but you are trying to measure a system that is constantly changing - both your body as well as how the scale measures it. Changing the time of day that you weigh, the way you distribute your weight on the scale, limitations of the accuracy of the scale (especially if you change weight dramatically) and a thousand other variables determine what number shows up.
At any rate, there is quite a bit of information on this site (that I highly recommend you read) that explains why the scale might not be the best measure of success. In my mind, the biggest reason to avoid using the scale is that you have no direct control over it.
You may find much greater success in focusing on the things you can control (calories and exercise) while using several measurements to determine success.
My personal measure of success is calorie differential over a one-week period. It is something I can control directly through what I eat and how much exercise I do. When I stay focused on maintaining my target differential, the weight (averaged over time) as well as other indicators of overall health does what I expect. The nice thing about spreading my goal across a week is that it lets me lose a daily battle or two without losing the war. I can shrug it off and hit the exercise a little harder the next day. Even if I have a bad week, I can look at my differential over a month and see progress.
Pounds lost: 53.6
Fitness Minutes: (4,770)
294 2/25/14 7:31 P
Every scale is different, even ones within the doctor's office. At the last clinic I worked at I could walk from the scale at one end of the hall to the one at the other and weigh a pound and a half more or less. They were both off from my home scale by 6-8 pounds. When making comparisons always use the same scale. While I can't tell you which one is more accurate overall, weight LOSS can only be determined accurately by using the same scale each time.
Be careful about reading health books. You may die of a misprint.- Mark Twain
Pounds lost: 32.0
Fitness Minutes: (3,904)
2/25/14 1:34 P
A scale is a scale right? I went to the doctor today and the scale weighed me 5 pounds heavier than my scale at home. I was kinda freaked out. Did I over react or can my scale at home be that off? Just wondering what your thoughts are. Thanks for any advise.
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.