Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   The Guys' Lounge
TOPIC:  

am i a girlfriend or best friend?



 
  Reply Create A New Topic
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
  I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top
 
GOLFPRO is the moderator for this forum.
 


1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
11/16/13 10:05 A

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Thats kinda what i was thinking thanks for ur input this is the first time that ive went thru this its nice to know that im not the only one to deal with this emoticon

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


HAPPY-DESTINY
HAPPY-DESTINY's Photo Posts: 19,566
11/15/13 6:13 A

HAPPY-DESTINY's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Here is my take on this!

I asked if he was 'Manipulative'..Here is what you said.."hes always playing the its my dieing wish card" That is manipulation as well as emotional abuse! Does it leave you feeling 'guilty' because you don't marry him for his dying wish?

If Mom is worried about you.. perhaps you should 'trust' Mom's gut feelings about this man!

"he doesnt show public recognition he worries about what other people think alot " I think if a person loves someone.. who cares what others think!! If it is his dying wish to marry you.. then I think he would shout it to the world.. he would recognize you as 'the love of his life' !

"being stuck with debt from hospital bills " Does he have Health/Life insurance? If so..does it cover catastrophic illness??

Public displays of affection need not be 'over the top'.. Holding hands.. walking close together.. introducing you to friends immediately and being happy together.. going to favorite stores/movies/meals etc!

IF you " feel loved in private " then I feel you should be loved in public!! It is a red flag for me if someone treats me differently in public than in private! That is manipulation.. emotional abuse .. psychological abuse.. even physical abuse in the sense that he practically ignores you and fails to be close to you with his or your friends when you are together! If it is his dying wish to marry you.. then I think he would show that and share that!

I am a 'fan' of Treat Others The Way You Want To Be Treated!

Now... all that being said.. This is just my take on a 'snapshot' of the whole scene. I am NOT saying to 'Dump the guy' nor am I saying 'Marry the guy'.. IF IT WERE ME . . AND I HAVE HAD THIS HAPPEN TO ME AS A MAN BY MY EX-WIFE! ! .. I could not handle being treated in such a manner ! It's living one way by day.. another by night! (Kind of like Fiona from Shrek! )

So .. No is it NOT too much to ask for some recognition in public and NO you are NOT over reacting ! !

As God's people... We stand on our feet.. we do not grovel before anyone!



"A man who wants something will find a way; a man who doesn't will find an excuse."

Stephan Dolley Jr.

powerfulchoices.myambit.com/start-a-
business/energy-526


 current weight: 204.0 
 
267
238.25
209.5
180.75
152


1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
11/14/13 8:03 P

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I am 36 he is 55 ever since ive known him hes been going thru cancer treatment he tells me he loves me dearly and wants to marry me hes always playing the its my dieing wish card my mom doesnt want me to she knows we love eachother she just worries about me being stuck with debt from hospital bills and that is part of the reason the other part is that he doesnt show public recognition he worries about what other people think alot he treats me well in private he treats me good in public hes not demanding he opens doors hes loving kissy smoochy i feel loved in private im proud that im with him hes a great man is it too much to ask for some recognition in public or am i over reacting

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


HAPPY-DESTINY
HAPPY-DESTINY's Photo Posts: 19,566
11/13/13 5:36 A

HAPPY-DESTINY's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I was perusing through the pages to find someone to chat with and I came upon your dialogue. Please allow me to 'chime in'!

First: Did he ask you to marry him while he was going through cancer treatment?

Second: This 'generation' thing..How old is he? ( I am 56 and never heard of it . . even us Hippies were never that cool!)

Third: How does he treat you in private? Is he demanding? Is he manipulative? ( IE: "If you love me you will blah blah blah .. IF you . . ) Does he hold the door for you? Does he 'make excuses' for his behavior that you may find unacceptable? (Other than rejecting you in public?)


Fourth: Would you give him your heart if he needed it?
Would he give you his heart if you needed it?

I do not mean to sound so callous yet I will reserve my thoughts when I see your replies (meaning when I get more information.. I do not know him nor what he is thinking) but I am willing to share what I see from my perspective thus far of his behavior. I too am a 'Been there . . Done that . . That happened to me too' kind of person!

I know these are personal questions to you and you need not answer them here in a public forum if you chose not to. I do not want my replies to be a form of embarrassment on your part! You seem like a nice person yet you are looking out for yourself. My goal is to help with self-edification (Be your own Cheerleader)!

ne illegitimi carborundum!

"A man who wants something will find a way; a man who doesn't will find an excuse."

Stephan Dolley Jr.

powerfulchoices.myambit.com/start-a-
business/energy-526


 current weight: 204.0 
 
267
238.25
209.5
180.75
152


1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
10/18/13 3:12 P

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
You may b right about him protecting hisself but everytime he needs me im there he has terminal cancer before we were together and almost died twice on me i cant c myself without him ever but i feel like i should get some kind of recognition that were together a public one is what i mean

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
10/18/13 3:07 P

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
He makes sure that i know he loves me i turned him down twice not because i dont love him but because he has an issue he has to fix first he is working on it at the moment

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
10/18/13 3:01 P

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Thanks guys yall r so helpful and rivetpa tell me about what u went thru twice in curious it might help me

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


ERICWS
ERICWS's Photo SparkPoints: (8,307)
Fitness Minutes: (22,220)
Posts: 1,537
10/18/13 11:39 A

ERICWS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Now I second-guess myself: did you TURN DOWN his proposals?

If you did, why? Maybe he is keeping his guard up to try to limit the pain of rejection by not calling you his girlfriend after you turned him down?





ERICWS
ERICWS's Photo SparkPoints: (8,307)
Fitness Minutes: (22,220)
Posts: 1,537
10/18/13 11:37 A

ERICWS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
"Labels" show commitment or lack thereof.

If you and he are hooking up, and you know what I mean, and he isn't calling you his "girlfriend", then in my opinion he is openly communicating to everyone, including you, that he wants to keep his opyions open and not appear to be tied down or committed.

No offense intended, but you did ask. I think it is a line of BS that he says that "nobody uses those terms anymore", etc. I guess you need to decide what you want out of this, and be strong in your resolve if you and he want different things......





RODGRODMEDFLOD
RODGRODMEDFLOD's Photo Posts: 3,121
10/18/13 11:29 A

RODGRODMEDFLOD's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I agree with the other people who have responded. There's something else going on here!

I've been with my partner for over 4 years and do not refer to her as my girlfriend. It just seems weird at this point in our lives. I usually call her my wife and she usually calls me her husband or partner.

As Rivetpa says, be careful.



 Pounds lost: 59.0 
 
0
22
44
66
88


RIVETPA
RIVETPA's Photo Posts: 974
10/18/13 11:09 A

RIVETPA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Yeah, it sounds like a trend that would continue if you were to get married... some people just want to put that part of life's puzzle in place - the get married thing - and then move on to conquer other things.

Just be careful is all... I've been down that road twice myself...



1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
10/18/13 10:57 A

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
U r so helpful my thoughts exactly i just cant seem to figure him out hes asked me twice to marry him i feel like if im not introduced as his girlfriend now and hurt it would b three times as hurtful if i wasnt introduced as his wife he doesnt seem to get it everyone seems to know who i am i dont know if when im not there that he lets them know that were together and just doesnt say anything and thats y he doesnt introduce me like that he says everyone knows were together maybe its just me im confused

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


RIVETPA
RIVETPA's Photo Posts: 974
10/18/13 10:20 A

RIVETPA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Or another planet maybe...hahahaha

I think people who are together should be happy and proud to introduce them as girlfriend or boyfriend.. if not then there's a red flag for you, and an issue somewhere.



1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
10/17/13 3:29 P

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Thanks i did express that i was upset he said that i was overreacting that were togethwr he is just from another generation where people dont introduce eachother like that

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


KJFITNESSDUDE
KJFITNESSDUDE's Photo Posts: 15,787
10/17/13 1:44 P

Send Private Message
Reply
"....this is my girlfriend."

that's it, tell him you're upset that he doesn't introduce you that way. In my opinion guys are wordsmiths and not saying the word "girlfriend" totally means you're not his girlfriend.

USING SP TO HELP YOU KEEP TRACK OF WEIGHT LOSs, CALORIE INTAKE AND EXERCISE "IS" THE SHORTCUT!!!!!!
sTOP TRYING TO CONSUME A MAGIC WEIGHTLOSS PILL, OY!


RIVETPA
RIVETPA's Photo Posts: 974
10/17/13 1:41 P

RIVETPA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Well in my opinion, after 4 years you (and he) should be able to talk about what you are to each other... whether that be best friend, girlfriend, etc.

I find that the direct approach is always best - just ask the question "what am I to you?" and see what he says to that.

Otherwise you could spend hours beating around the bush to get to what really matters



1977SHAW
1977SHAW's Photo SparkPoints: (3,993)
Fitness Minutes: (542)
Posts: 91
10/17/13 11:49 A

1977SHAW's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
i need some info. from a mans point of view if u have been seeing a guy for 4 years and when he introduces u he says ur his best friend or calls by ur first name should u b insulted that he didn't introduce u as his girl friend? im totally lossed here

I AM STRONG! I CAN DO THIS!


 current weight: 229.6 
 
236
222
208
194
180


 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  

I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Report Innappropriate Post


Thread URL: http://www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/messageboard.asp?imboard=60&imparent=32222265

Review our Community Guidelines



 
Diet Resources: body composition analysis test | composition of the human body | measuring body composition