Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   Fitness and Exercise
TOPIC:  

Strength training or cardio?



Click here to read our frequently asked Fitness and Exercise questions.

 
  Reply Create A New Topic
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
  I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top


KNEEMAKER
SparkPoints: (41,670)
Fitness Minutes: (14,509)
Posts: 1,259
6/27/14 11:29 P

KNEEMAKER's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
both is best for certain

Knee maker not a pace maker!


BELLENGLISH
BELLENGLISH's Photo Posts: 920
6/27/14 3:01 P

BELLENGLISH's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Both

"Stay focused, prayerful, determined, motivated and you will become successful."

"Keep the Faith and Lose the Pounds!"


"If you do what you always did, then you will get what you always got!"


"Nothing beats a failure but a try!"


"When you know better, you do better."



Love and Peace,
Bell


 Pounds lost: 20.0 
 
0
11
22
33
44


SERGEANTMAJOR
SERGEANTMAJOR's Photo Posts: 6,399
6/27/14 2:04 P

SERGEANTMAJOR's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Minor correction if I may there Hokie, you are doing combination training not circuit training. Classical circuit training is to do a series of different strength training exercises without a break then take a break before repeating the circuit multiple more times. Done this way the cardio is incorporated into the strength training according to the research.

The research on combination training such as you are doing is that alternating strength and cardio in the same workout tends to degrade the quality of both portions of the workout.

The above are based on the findings of the long white lab coats crowd.




It is called WORK-ing out for a reason.

I said getting fit was simple, I did not say it was easy.

Cardio burns calories, strength work burns fat.

Eat well to lose weight, exercise to get fit

You can not build a six pack using twelve packs


Often when we seek a magic bullet for fitness we end up shooting ourselves in the foot.

"I think calories are little germs in food that all moms are afraid of" Dennis the Menace



H0KIE_GIRL
H0KIE_GIRL's Photo SparkPoints: (3,349)
Fitness Minutes: (4,308)
Posts: 88
6/27/14 9:27 A

H0KIE_GIRL's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I incorporate my cardio into my strength training with circuit training. What I do is have 6-8 machines picked out half for upper half for lower and then I'll row a quick 1000 meters go do 1 set of each of my upper body machines and repeat the machines 3 times then I'm back rowing another speed round of 1000 meters before I do the the same thing I did with the upper body machines for lower body. I finish it off with another speed round of rowing 1000 meters. I can normally get this done in about 45 minutes so if I'm tight on time its time for me to hit the showers but if not its 5-10 miles on the bike to finish off with more cardio.

My trainer always told me if I'm doing to do cardio with strength training always mix it in with circuit training but if I need that burst of extended cardio do it at the end because you're metabolism is raised and you're less likely not to decide to not do strength training because you are tired



 July Minutes: 936
 
0
350
700
1050
1400


MUSIC123JJ
MUSIC123JJ's Photo SparkPoints: (18,903)
Fitness Minutes: (7,055)
Posts: 291
6/27/14 6:14 A

MUSIC123JJ's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
both



 July Minutes: 1,773
 
0
46.25
92.5
138.75
185


SERGEANTMAJOR
SERGEANTMAJOR's Photo Posts: 6,399
6/26/14 5:31 P

SERGEANTMAJOR's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Contrary to popular opinion cardio is not the route to fat loss, in fact it is in last place in the formula. The formula for fat loss is 80% nutrition and only 20% exercise with the exercise splint into 15% strength training and only 5% cardio. A properly structured strentth training programme will include the cardio 5% negating the need for dedicated cardio.

I did not create this or dream it up, the people in the long white lab coats are responsible for the findings, not anecdotal evidence.


It is called WORK-ing out for a reason.

I said getting fit was simple, I did not say it was easy.

Cardio burns calories, strength work burns fat.

Eat well to lose weight, exercise to get fit

You can not build a six pack using twelve packs


Often when we seek a magic bullet for fitness we end up shooting ourselves in the foot.

"I think calories are little germs in food that all moms are afraid of" Dennis the Menace



FITZOMBIESLAYER
SparkPoints: (4)
Fitness Minutes: (0)
Posts: 1
6/26/14 5:27 P

Send Private Message
Reply
I'm doing both to gain strength and tone as I slim down. I workout on a 3 days on, 1 day off schedule and I do cardio every workout session, and strength training three times out of the week. My cardio is about 60ish minutes and my strength training is 20 minutes, and I am building on that. I love cardio which is why I go for about 60 minutes when I do it. I find it relazing and it clears my head. Anyway, both are good and should be done together IMO.



 Pounds lost: 30.0 
 
0
30.25
60.5
90.75
121


GOAL_DIGGER
GOAL_DIGGER's Photo SparkPoints: (44)
Fitness Minutes: (0)
Posts: 7
6/26/14 3:08 P

Send Private Message
Reply
If your goal is weight loss there is no way around cardio emoticon and if your like me you loathe it. Im not sure how much time you have to devote to the gym but doing both is advisable. However if you have to choose one. Low intensity cardio in a fasted state is ideal but cardio in general is a must.

Anything worth having is worth working for.


 current weight: 203.8 
 
204
190.5
177
163.5
150


CJGODESS101
CJGODESS101's Photo SparkPoints: (27,156)
Fitness Minutes: (7,479)
Posts: 537
6/26/14 9:28 A

CJGODESS101's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I alternate my workouts. On days where I strength train, every 2-3 days, I will do some light walking. On days I don't strength train, I will do harder cardio or a class. You don't want to strength train everyday unless you are lifting using different muscles every day.



 current weight: 188.0 
 
220
209.5
199
188.5
178


VEG_GIRL04
VEG_GIRL04's Photo Posts: 770
6/26/14 8:59 A

VEG_GIRL04's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Both!

"If you're going through hell, keep going!" - Winston Churchill


100 Days until:  Our Wedding!
 
100
75
50
25
0


MOTHERBOARDER
MOTHERBOARDER's Photo SparkPoints: (109,143)
Fitness Minutes: (83,815)
Posts: 5,384
6/26/14 8:51 A

MOTHERBOARDER's SparkPage
Reply
both



 current weight: 123.6 
 
250
218.25
186.5
154.75
123


MUSIC123JJ
MUSIC123JJ's Photo SparkPoints: (18,903)
Fitness Minutes: (7,055)
Posts: 291
6/26/14 6:18 A

MUSIC123JJ's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
both



 July Minutes: 1,773
 
0
46.25
92.5
138.75
185


DONALD362
SparkPoints: (21)
Fitness Minutes: (0)
Posts: 13
6/26/14 1:25 A

Send Private Message
Reply
Same here I too prefer both :)



MOMNAMEMANTOOTH
MOMNAMEMANTOOTH's Photo Posts: 940
6/25/14 3:31 P

MOMNAMEMANTOOTH's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Both! But I really don't do enough strength I think.

I have a personal trainer that I meet for 45 minutes once a week, but getting myself to do more strength training...

Obese to Healthy 2014!!!


 current weight: 191.4 
 
200
186.25
172.5
158.75
145


TACDGB
TACDGB's Photo Posts: 6,024
6/25/14 3:28 P

TACDGB's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I do both... Cardio burns calories while u are doing it..strength training burns calories up to 24 hours later. Cardio is a good way to lower your body fat. %. Just remember u can't out train a bad diet.

Terri


 current weight: 115.5 
 
136
130.75
125.5
120.25
115


SERGEANTMAJOR
SERGEANTMAJOR's Photo Posts: 6,399
6/25/14 2:23 P

SERGEANTMAJOR's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
While the common response will be cardio you can actually create a strength based workout which allows you to no do dedicated cardio. The advantage here is that you can then do some form of active recreation which will supplement this cardio, biking is an excellent choice which combines recreation and a cardio benefit.

As an aside, in my opinion unless you are training for and endurance based activity workouts in excess of 30 minutes indicate to me as a trainer that you are exchanging duration of intensity which is not the best choice.

Edited by: SERGEANTMAJOR at: 6/25/2014 (22:52)

It is called WORK-ing out for a reason.

I said getting fit was simple, I did not say it was easy.

Cardio burns calories, strength work burns fat.

Eat well to lose weight, exercise to get fit

You can not build a six pack using twelve packs


Often when we seek a magic bullet for fitness we end up shooting ourselves in the foot.

"I think calories are little germs in food that all moms are afraid of" Dennis the Menace



PAIGENESS
PAIGENESS's Photo Posts: 44
6/25/14 1:21 P

PAIGENESS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply


DEANNA0725
SparkPoints: (18,344)
Fitness Minutes: (10,932)
Posts: 1,620
6/25/14 9:12 A

DEANNA0725's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I do cardio now, but I think I am going to get some weights for my birthday to start toning up.



 current weight: 158.0 
 
162
157.75
153.5
149.25
145


RUBYREDSTAR19
RUBYREDSTAR19's Photo Posts: 1,712
6/25/14 9:08 A

RUBYREDSTAR19's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Cardio will help lose the weight, but lifting will help burn the calories all day long and TONE you up instead of losing. So do both. Good Luck to yoU!!



 Body Fat %: 20.0
 
28
26
24
22
20


LEC358
SparkPoints: (8,926)
Fitness Minutes: (6,540)
Posts: 2,005
6/25/14 8:15 A

Send Private Message
Reply
I do strength training twice a week for an hour and cardio 3 times a week for 30 min to 2 hours. If I wasn't working up to running a half marathon, it'd probably be strength training three times a week for an hour and cardio for an hour twice a week. To me, it's more important to be strong than fast.



 current weight: -0.8  under
 
5
2.5
0
-2.5
-5


NMRUDOLPH
Posts: 144
6/25/14 7:23 A

Send Private Message
Reply
I do strenght training 3 days a week for 40-60 min, the rest of my exercise is cardio or yoga.


Online Now
PATTYGIVENS
SparkPoints: (14,587)
Fitness Minutes: (1,975)
Posts: 950
6/25/14 6:53 A

Send Private Message
Reply
cardio



MOTIVATED@LAST
MOTIVATED@LAST's Photo Posts: 13,952
6/25/14 6:43 A

MOTIVATED@LAST's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
A program that includes BOTH ST and cardio is better than one that includes just one or the other.

ST works by creating microscopic tears in the muscle fibers, which then grow back stronger, but it takes time for this to happen. Most experts recommend leaving 48 hours between ST sessions. If you want to exercise more than 3 times per week, you will have some cardio only sessions as well as ST.

If you do ST and cardio back-to-back, whichever you do second is going to suffer. If you can, seperate ST and cardio on different days, or morning and afternoon, rather than doing them in the same session.

Also, hiking with a pack, or cycling on hills is merely more strenuous cardio. It is NOT strength training.

M@L

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.


 current weight: 178.0 
 
220
203.5
187
170.5
154


MUSIC123JJ
MUSIC123JJ's Photo SparkPoints: (18,903)
Fitness Minutes: (7,055)
Posts: 291
6/25/14 6:17 A

MUSIC123JJ's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
cardio



 July Minutes: 1,773
 
0
46.25
92.5
138.75
185


BELLENGLISH
BELLENGLISH's Photo Posts: 920
6/24/14 11:44 P

BELLENGLISH's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
cardio

"Stay focused, prayerful, determined, motivated and you will become successful."

"Keep the Faith and Lose the Pounds!"


"If you do what you always did, then you will get what you always got!"


"Nothing beats a failure but a try!"


"When you know better, you do better."



Love and Peace,
Bell


 Pounds lost: 20.0 
 
0
11
22
33
44


SHOTOKIDO
SparkPoints: (14,319)
Fitness Minutes: (6,661)
Posts: 237
6/24/14 11:43 P

SHOTOKIDO's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I prefer to do both, similar to your 1/2 hour split plan.

I also like doing things that involve both, such as bicycle riding on hilly terrain or hiking with a weighted backpack.



 July Minutes: 1,970
 
0
750
1500
2250
3000


SP_COACH_DENISE
SP_COACH_DENISE's Photo Posts: 29,791
6/24/14 10:35 P

SparkPeople Team Member

SP_COACH_DENISE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Generally, you want to do both, but they don't have to be done on the same day. Some people like to split it up and do cardio 3-4 days a week and then strength train 2 days a week on the other days they aren't doing cardio, while others like to do them on the same day. Cardio will help you with fat loss and strength training will help you retain more muscle during your weight loss journey and eventually help you gain muscle. You don't have to spend an hour doing each of those every time though. If you were to do them the same day, you may want to lessen the time for both.

Here are some resources that you may find helpful with this:

www.sparkpeople.com/blog/blog.asp?post=you
_asked_is_it_true_that_strength_traini
ng_burns_more_fat_than_cardio_if_i_can
_only_do_one_should_i_pick_weight_training


www.sparkpeople.com/resource/fitness_artic
les.asp?id=773


www.sparkpeople.com/blog/blog.asp?post=how
_to_design_your_ideal_workout_plan


Coach Denise

"Obstacles don't have to stop you. If you run into a wall, don't turn around and give up. Figure out how to climb it, go through it, or work around it." - Michael Jordan

Searching for a buddy? Try using the search feature in the SparkPages section.


1,757 Days since:  No Soda
 
0
450
900
1350
1800


DETERMIN8SHUN
SparkPoints: (13)
Fitness Minutes: (0)
Posts: 1
6/24/14 9:30 P

Send Private Message
Reply
I just joined spark people today, is it best to do cardio for one hour, strength training for one hour or break it up, 1/2 hr cardio, 1/2hour strength training? I read somewhere you lose more calories burning muscle with weight lifting than cardio workouts. My goal is to lose weight.



 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  

I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Report Innappropriate Post


Thread URL: http://www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/messageboard.asp?imboard=6&imparent=33931539

Review our Community Guidelines



 
Diet Resources: the worst food you can eat | worst food you can eat | worst junk food