Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   Fitness and Exercise
TOPIC:  

Body Monitors (Bodybugg, Fitbit, Bodymedia, etc.)



Click here to read our frequently asked Fitness and Exercise questions.

 
  Reply Create A New Topic
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
  I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top


YANNIEII
Posts: 51
5/17/14 4:00 P

YANNIEII's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
they're off



GYPSYGOTH
GYPSYGOTH's Photo SparkPoints: (83,345)
Fitness Minutes: (47,202)
Posts: 43,996
8/22/13 12:35 A

GYPSYGOTH's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I adore my fitbit "zip" and find it is very accurate for steps taken; I checked by counting steps and also shaking it which produced no gain in steps unlike a scrappy pedometer... not sure about overall algorithm and whether it is perfect, but I have lost almost 20 lbs using it.

The integration is OK, so you do not have to log in both places, but if you remove something from SP, it stays on fitbit's site which is SUPER annoying, so I just do not use fitbit's tracking tools at all, just sync my steps to SP.

~desiree/dez/D~
Always welcoming new members in The Hen House!
teams.sparkpeople.com/thehenhouse

My blog about my long-term unemployment:
desperationpapers.wordpress.com/


 current weight: 132.0 
 
170
158.25
146.5
134.75
123


SERGEANTMAJOR
SERGEANTMAJOR's Photo Posts: 6,397
8/21/13 11:11 P

SERGEANTMAJOR's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I want to remind everyone that all of the values from any monitor are guesstimates since the algorithms are based on averages. In a standard bell shaped curve 50% of any sample fall at either end of the curve meaning for 25% they are too low and for the other end 25% they are too high.

Track them as you choose with the knowledge that they are not absolute values of anything.


It is called WORK-ing out for a reason.

I said getting fit was simple, I did not say it was easy.

Cardio burns calories, strength work burns fat.

Eat well to lose weight, exercise to get fit

You can not build a six pack using twelve packs


Often when we seek a magic bullet for fitness we end up shooting ourselves in the foot.

"I think calories are little germs in food that all moms are afraid of" Dennis the Menace



THAGREATONE30
THAGREATONE30's Photo SparkPoints: (1,748)
Fitness Minutes: (1,365)
Posts: 15
8/21/13 9:51 P

THAGREATONE30's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Im considering getting a fitbit flex.Anyone have one yet and does it integrate well with this site?I would hate to have to track my calories eaten on two different apps.



 current weight: 248.6 
 
261
248.25
235.5
222.75
210


ANNASMOM12
SparkPoints: (36,611)
Fitness Minutes: (48,206)
Posts: 129
8/21/13 9:18 P

ANNASMOM12's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
it seems like my fitbit is missing the stairs when I climb them




REBCCA
REBCCA's Photo SparkPoints: (255,490)
Fitness Minutes: (148,817)
Posts: 20,143
8/21/13 9:10 P



REBCCA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I have a BodyMedia Fit and have worn it for 2.5 years and find the feedback accurate and uesful.
emoticon

...where attention goes, energy flows...


549 Maintenance Weeks
 
0
140
280
420
560


RHONDAEURE
RHONDAEURE's Photo Posts: 46
8/21/13 2:54 P

RHONDAEURE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I also bought a used Bodybugg and I was able to register it. I did it when the ApexFitness site had it, now Bodymedia has it but you should be able to register it. It won't register as a new one, I think it was as pre-owned.



 Pounds lost: 7.0 
 
0
21.25
42.5
63.75
85


MAIM138
MAIM138's Photo Posts: 748
5/7/13 12:28 P

MAIM138's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
This is all really helpful.

I play roller derby and wear a BodyMedia armband at practice sometimes. I take down the before/afters on calorie burn to see what I'm burning at practice. I usually end up in the 500-600 range.

But I was recently talking to a girl who plays derby in another city, and she was saying she gets up in 1000-1200 calorie range during a practice.

We weigh about the same, and based on her descriptions of a "normal" practice for them, I feel like my practices are much more intense (we focus a lot on endurance and sprinting). I don't remember what brand of monitor she had, but I'd been curious for a while as to whether hers was high, or mine was low.

I'm thinking BodyMedia is the accurate burn, though.

Hollie
NW Indiana/Chicago at heart



 Pounds lost: 51.0 
 
0
27.5
55
82.5
110


FITWITHIN
FITWITHIN's Photo SparkPoints: (261,073)
Fitness Minutes: (183,864)
Posts: 19,946
5/4/13 4:32 P

FITWITHIN's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I've been wearing my Bodymedia monitor for 2 years and absolutely love it. I would not trade it in for the world. It's one of several best personal investments to myself.

Progress may be slow, but it happens!
No such thing as last place only finishers.


 July Minutes: 895
 
0
500
1000
1500
2000


ANNASMOM12
SparkPoints: (36,611)
Fitness Minutes: (48,206)
Posts: 129
5/4/13 10:31 A

ANNASMOM12's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
i love mine, when i can see how many steps i have taken in a day,



PANDORA2013
SparkPoints: (2,082)
Fitness Minutes: (4,376)
Posts: 13
5/4/13 9:22 A

PANDORA2013's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Just bought a Bodybugg on Craigslist and so far I really like it. I wasn't able to register it though for the monitoring service since it was used. Still the calorie count on the wrist band is really helpful. I tend to way overestimate my calorie burn so this a really keeping me in check.

Ready to start living a healthy lifestyle, not just follow a diet.


 current weight: 122.0 
 
129
124.25
119.5
114.75
110


PURPLELEAF13
SparkPoints: (13,695)
Fitness Minutes: (31,004)
Posts: 38
4/10/13 11:22 A

PURPLELEAF13's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I have had the bodymedia monitor for two weeks. Love it. Even though no one really knows what your doing activity wise, having the monitor makes me feel like I must get plenty of exercise data on there, or else it was a waste of time and money. It has served me well so far. I would like it if Sparkpeople did a body media challenge like they have the fitbit challenge! No wthat would be motivation! : )



 current weight: 187.0 
 
187
172.75
158.5
144.25
130


ANNASMOM12
SparkPoints: (36,611)
Fitness Minutes: (48,206)
Posts: 129
4/10/13 10:59 A

ANNASMOM12's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
i love my fitbit i would love to try some other ones to see how the work




TRIXIETEXAS
TRIXIETEXAS's Photo SparkPoints: (24,079)
Fitness Minutes: (40,779)
Posts: 478
4/10/13 10:28 A

TRIXIETEXAS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I have had a fitbit for about 2 months now and I love it. It reminds me to KEEP MOVING. Even if it isn't 100% accurate, for me that isn't the point so much as staying motivated to squeeze in extra activity where ever I can.

I'm a FIGHTER!
BLC23 C.A.M.O. CREW
Violet Assassins Squad

Christina


 current weight: 189.5 
 
294
255.5
217
178.5
140


ANNASMOM12
SparkPoints: (36,611)
Fitness Minutes: (48,206)
Posts: 129
4/9/13 8:26 P

ANNASMOM12's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
i got my fitbit and had no problems yet




BLONDIES155
Posts: 1
4/9/13 7:57 P

Send Private Message
Reply
Hi! How do I get by body bugg to add my steps to my fitness tracker? Will it only occur when I Physically link to system or can it sync remotely? Thanks!



ANNASMOM12
SparkPoints: (36,611)
Fitness Minutes: (48,206)
Posts: 129
4/4/13 7:56 A

ANNASMOM12's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
i just brought fitbit so i hope works, the way i want to are it will go back



OMGEEEHORSES
OMGEEEHORSES's Photo Posts: 278
4/4/13 1:57 A

OMGEEEHORSES's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
It depends on what you are looking for, I bought a fitbit one and used it for a week and HATED IT!!!, I mean how is a tiny device that clips on my clothes suppose to be any accuracy to whta my body is really doing. I was getting HUGE numbers too for walking and such, when I was hardly doing anything.

I swapped it for a bodymedia core armband and display ( deal going on for both together $129) and found I LOVE IT!!! its 100% accurate, I forget a great deal of times I am wearing it and I don't care who sees it so I wear short and long sleeves and let it track away. I now use My Fitness Pal as whatever you track on there goes automatically to Bodymedia page to sum up your deficit for the day. It is water resistant and can go no farther than 30 meters ( i believe) underwater. CUSTOMER SERVICE IS AMAZING!!! I had a band break on me and emailed them and they sent me two out with no hassle at all! they didn't even want the broken one back. SO they take you at your word. I mean its just an amazing little device. I can't rave about it enough. Also I wouldn't go with an armband monitor as its not going off anything as well, its simply around your arm and tracks your movement not your body temp and everything that the bodymedia armband does. I mean this is my opinion, but I guarantee if you go with a Bodymedia armband you will not be disappointed!!

☆⊱Heather⊰☆
Unless You Puke, Faint or Die...KEEP GOING!!!!!


 current weight: 285.6 
 
330
280
230
180
130


ANNASMOM12
SparkPoints: (36,611)
Fitness Minutes: (48,206)
Posts: 129
3/17/13 11:00 P

ANNASMOM12's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
What is the differnce on Fitbit/bodymeida. want to buy one, but i dont know what one to get. please help




SERGEANTMAJOR
SERGEANTMAJOR's Photo Posts: 6,397
3/16/13 9:01 P

SERGEANTMAJOR's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I test drove a Fitbit for Spark people and found it a nice to have not need to have item. I tend to being a Luddite when it comes to fitness being very old school in my training and in the programmes create for clients. For the nerds and number crunchers I am sure they are a happy dance item but as to whether or not they improve progress toward a fitness goal I think not. It is the work you do not the numbers you monitor and record which is the secret to programme success.

My current heart rate monitor is and RPE, rate of perceived exertion which has been research proven to match up one to one with the electronic readouts. The nicest thing about using an RPE is that it self recalibrates to your physical ability every day.


It is called WORK-ing out for a reason.

I said getting fit was simple, I did not say it was easy.

Cardio burns calories, strength work burns fat.

Eat well to lose weight, exercise to get fit

You can not build a six pack using twelve packs


Often when we seek a magic bullet for fitness we end up shooting ourselves in the foot.

"I think calories are little germs in food that all moms are afraid of" Dennis the Menace



MAISIA
MAISIA's Photo Posts: 1,213
3/16/13 5:09 P

Send Private Message
Reply
Ok so I have read a couple threads on the fit-bit and Google them also, and I think I want one.

Was just curious what the regular price is on these. My bf and I saw them today at target for $99. And when I was Google them kept coming across sales adds for them but they were all pretty much the same price as target.

Also as I was reading though post on here it sounds like the fit-bit one can estimate when you will lose a lbs of weight from calories consumed and calories burned? is that correct?

thank you matalynn

Team Leader--Looking Sexy!!! http://www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/groups_
individual.asp?gid=13253

~~**HOLD THE IMAGE OF THE LIFE YOU WANT AND THAT IMAGE WILL BECOME FACT**~~ �
~~**�LIVE THE LIFE YOU LOVE, LOVE THE LIFE YOU LIVE**~~


KATELJM
KATELJM's Photo Posts: 2,442
3/16/13 9:10 A

KATELJM's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
SOTIREDOFTHIS, thank you for the reminder. Last time I checked Costco, they were out, Today they are in stock and available for $119.99 with 3-5 business day shipping, that includes 12-months subscription. I'm looking forward to receiving mine.

Kate (or Kathy), Joppa, MD, USA
EDT

Healthy Weight reached 12.10.09 -- need to reach that again!

Summer 2014 5% Challenge - WRJ&G team
Current Weight: 164.9 pounds
Target Weight: 156.7 pounds (5%)
By When: August 16, 2014
1) Post exercise & LTGL points daily
2) 10000 steps daily
3) 8 cups water daily



 current weight: 160.1 
 
177
167.25
157.5
147.75
138


SOTIREDOFTHIS
SparkPoints: (4,965)
Fitness Minutes: (3,419)
Posts: 191
2/28/13 7:32 P

SOTIREDOFTHIS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
If you are looking to purchase the Bodymedia armband, look into purchasing it at Costco. If you crunch the numbers I think it ends up being cheaper because they give you a year subscription to Body Media's data service which you need to see all of your data. Also, if you decide that you do not like it, Costco has a very liberal return policy....Costco does not offer this in the store, you have to purchase it online and it ships free.

Also, if you are leaning towards the fitbit, they are releasing the fitbit flex soon. You wear it on your wrist and it tracks your sleep too. I am not sure how accurate it will be, but the upside is that you do not have to pay a fee for access to your data.

Hope this helps!



 Pounds lost: 19.0 
 
0
26.25
52.5
78.75
105


PKTRUCKDRIVER
PKTRUCKDRIVER's Photo SparkPoints: (2,491)
Fitness Minutes: (1,738)
Posts: 78
2/28/13 6:38 P

PKTRUCKDRIVER's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Wow I asked and got 2 response, oh well, no biggie.

Good thing I started to look around.

Patrick


http://pktruckdriver.blogspot.com/

Never, ever give up


 current weight: 413.0 
 
505
447.5
390
332.5
275


MITCHARVEY
MITCHARVEY's Photo Posts: 161
2/27/13 8:44 P

Send Private Message
Reply
thanks everyone this was helpful

Keep fit and have fun.


 current weight: 173.0 
 
185
171.25
157.5
143.75
130


LI4ME2
LI4ME2's Photo SparkPoints: (8,038)
Fitness Minutes: (25,963)
Posts: 11
2/7/13 12:22 P

Send Private Message
Reply
I have the BodyMedia Fit and have been wearing it for almost 2 years (never had a problem with it).

Near the beginning, I compared their charts in Activity Manager with the MET data from a number of sources and found it to be quite accurate. In addition it has really made me more aware of my sleep problems, and helped to change my life-style to ensure I get more quality sleep.

With regard to their customer service, I have always contacted them via email and received responses the same day. Very helpful.

Lastly, I am a data geek. Numbers I can crunch in various ways in Excel always appeal to me.

MET resources:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metabolic_equivalent

www.buchholzmedgroup.com/new_content/CA_PR
EVENTION/MET%20table%20Exercise.pdf

www.uihealthcare.com/topics/medicaldepartm
ents/internalmedicine/champs/metchart.
html

https://sites.google.com/site/compendiumof
physicalactivities/corrected-mets




KESTRUNK
Posts: 195
1/31/13 9:37 A

KESTRUNK's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I am loving my Fitbit - In terms of accuracy - it might not be 100%, but I like being able to see the trends, and as long as I am trending in the right direction I feel good!



 Pounds lost: 3.0 
 
0
2.25
4.5
6.75
9


WHOVIAN85
WHOVIAN85's Photo Posts: 861
1/31/13 7:21 A

Send Private Message
Reply
I love polar hrm watches with the chest straps, they are so accurate on my calorie burn and heart rate. Im actuakly looking to buying another one now.

"The good things dont always soften the bad things but vice versa the bad things dont necessarily spoil the good things or make them unimportant."
Doctor Who Series 5: Vincent and the Doctor
SW: 232
CW: 203.2
LGW: 150


 current weight: 211.0 
 
232
208.75
185.5
162.25
139


HUNGRYWOMAN2
HUNGRYWOMAN2's Photo Posts: 10,798
1/31/13 7:10 A

HUNGRYWOMAN2's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I like using my fitbit for daily activities. However, I do not believe it is as accurate when I am exercising or in my extremely active zone. I believe using my heart-rate monitor gives a more accurate individualized account. However, if I don't feel like changing fitbit is a good general indicator, particularly if I don't add the specifics myself.

Teresa






~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Men's best successes come after their worst failures"

Henry Ward Beecher


 Pounds lost: 6.6 
 
0
2.5
5
7.5
10


LALAFITZ
LALAFITZ's Photo SparkPoints: (43,810)
Fitness Minutes: (40,822)
Posts: 3,292
1/30/13 9:34 P

LALAFITZ's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Fitbit - Like.

~ Lala

Peace and Joy. Always.
SEASONS CHANGE ... And So Can I.


 current weight: 188.7 
 
191
188
185
182
179


CONSTRGIRL
CONSTRGIRL's Photo Posts: 25
1/30/13 8:59 P

CONSTRGIRL's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
How are you liking your bodymedia. I just got mine in today. When you sync the monitor, does your Sparkpeople food diary sync also? Or do you have to reenter your food into bodymedia account. I am a little confused. thanks for your help

http://www.sparkpeople.com/sparksolution/d
efault.asp?f=icon


 Pounds lost: 0.0 
 
0
8.25
16.5
24.75
33


MELTINGAWAY1112
MELTINGAWAY1112's Photo SparkPoints: (258)
Fitness Minutes: (342)
Posts: 11
12/8/12 8:05 P

MELTINGAWAY1112's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I've had the bodybugg in the past and loved it except for the size. Now I just recently bought the Bodymedia Fit which in my opinion is almost the same thing but these new versions are smaller and I'm in love all over again!

Hey apple! Apple! Hey! Hey apple! Hey apple! Apple! Hey apple! Apple! Hey! Hey apple! -Annoying Orange


 current weight: 225.0 
 
250
225
200
175
150


CHELE519
Posts: 13
12/8/12 7:22 A

Reply
I've had the Bodymedia for a while and I love it. I had the display unit replaced under warranty and had no issues with customer support. They were difficult to reach in the past but that seems to have improved greatly in recent months. I would highly recommend it. In fact, I just put my core armband up on ebay so I can upgrade to the link version.



BETHANYBOO
BETHANYBOO's Photo Posts: 1,998
11/30/12 2:42 P

BETHANYBOO's SparkPage
Reply
I had a bodymedia fit for a while and I can't really recommend it. I had 2 different devices break and getting through to their customer support was a nightmare.

Strong is the new skinny!!


 current weight: 139.8 
 
139.8
136.85
133.9
130.95
128


STEVIEBEE569
STEVIEBEE569's Photo Posts: 9,781
11/29/12 8:31 P

STEVIEBEE569's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I use Polar's Heart Rate Monitors! It's pretty close to my heart rate. For example, I have a Treadclimber that tracks my heart rate as long as I'm wearing the chest band. One day, I wore my heart rate monitor, while walking on the Treadclimber. Both had the same heart rates while working out. The calories burned were slightly off. With the Treadclimber, the calories burned would be let's say 300 calories, where the HRM would indicate 294 calories. So, I chose Polar! This of course is my opinion!

Phil. 4:13 I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me!

No one can do what you are called to do, but you!

Great works are performed not by strength but by perserverance. - Samuel Johnson


 current weight: 129.6 
 
182
168.9
155.8
142.7
129.6


SLYSAM
SLYSAM's Photo SparkPoints: (37,033)
Fitness Minutes: (90,815)
Posts: 1,450
11/29/12 5:56 P

SLYSAM's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I don't have a bodymedia/bugg though I imagine that might be more accurate since they use more sensors and track perspiration and body temperature as well as movement. I do have a fitbit and have for more than two years. I may be in the fitbit sweet zone, as it seems pretty accurate for me as near as I can tell. I think either of these or other trackers like a Nike Fuel, pedometer, jawbone up, striive etc. can be either great or a waste of money depending on the individual.

Since I only have a fitbit and have felt no need to change, I'll just explain with that device. I also have a heart rate monitor I usually wear for intentional exercise including some types that it would not accurately estimate calorie burn for (they really are only set up for aerobic exercise from my understanding). I think it helps if you start understanding any device has limits and all are giving estimates not direct measures. As long as it is in the ballpark and consistent it can work and it may depend on what you want it to do for you.

The fitbit really only tracks movement and only movement it can pickup from where it is placed. It is calibrated to be worn on the torso between the hip and bra area on the chest. I should say I wear mine slightly outside the suggested area--I wear it on my bra where the strap and cup connect because that just works better for me to keep it discreet and convenient. That placement hasn't compromised accuracy for me as near as I can tell. I just did a step test where I took one hundred counted steps and watched the fitbit count when done. The first time, I complicated it too much with lateral steps, forward and backward and it counted 105 steps. I tried again with just forward and backward and it counted 101 steps. I may have had an error in coordinating my stepping and counting, but I think it is close enough.

I calibrated my walking and running average stride settings by doing one lap walking on a track and one lap jogging. I basically used a formula that divided the distance by the number of steps that the fitbit counted in those laps. Since doing this, my distance and pace stats are always the same or close to what I find if I return to that track, use a treadmill, or use a GPS app. It is more consistent than the GPS app on my phone, as I've noticed with the GPS app sometimes my away and return trips on the exact same route, the same day vary more form each other than the fitbit records for those same trips. Some people are not able to get the stride as accurate, so it may depend how variable your actual strides are. So there are limits.

The other thing I judge it by is whether the four activity levels fitbit assigns to each minute matches my perceived exertion. Firtbit classes activity into sedentary, lightly active, fairly active and very active by how much and how fast you move in that time period. Well, that is more variable. It is pretty good with step based activity now my strides are calibrated, and I think it is good for an overall picture of whether I was either sedentary or lightly active or more for a non-exercise period of time. But it will underestimate exertion from well, just about any activity involving resistance or not involving movements that can be translated into steps. This can be fixed by manually logging those activities.

The floors is also variable in accuracy. It credits you with a floor if you are moving through 10 foot elevation gains. But it can be fooled by changes in air pressure or if your stair floor is less than 10 feet it won't consistently count it. I sometimes do stair laps in my apartment building 5 floors up and 5 down. Sometimes it is spot on, and sometimes it misses floors (usually just one or two but sometimes 5 floors will be missed if I do a lot of laps). It usually catches them if I walk at a steady pace and don't stop up and down, but if I run the laps or meet a neighbor and pause it can vary.

Calorie burn... How do we really know? For me, for cardio activity including step like movements and little or no added resistance it often matches my Polar heart rate monitor calorie burn or is close. This has included jogging, jump roping, some dance, and cardio kickboxing dvds. For walking on flat ground it masures higher than my hrm--a little not too bad. For some vigorous cardio or anything involving resistance it measures low. I usually just log the activity if it is much different (like 50 calories for an hour) and then I check if that resulting activity level matches my perceived exertion. I know this is wrong for accuracy, but I use my hrm burn for strength training mainly to get the right exertion level as I don't like seeing a brisk walk rated as more vigorous than kettlebell circuits. My hrm tends to give me low burn credit (almost always lower than the database entries on Spark and Fitbit and other sites) so even if it is wrong it is still adding less than if I log it from a database.

My results in bodyweight have been pretty much in line with what fitbit numbers would predict if I am logging food (sometimes I fall off the wagon with logging food). So even if the numbers are flawed estimates, they are close enough for me. When I log the way I describe, I had found I lost a pound whenever fitbit estimated I had a deficit between 2500 and 4000. I don't think that is too bad. It would not give any after burn credit, as near as I can tell, just based on movement (or what you log) and whatever bmr estimate they use.

I experimented in October with no manual logging of activity including strength training (other than two swimming sessions as I wasn't wearing my fitbit in the water). That month I had the best loss results so perhaps that was actually most accurate for my calorie burn. I did return t logging some activity though as I like to use it as a log and archive. But you may not need to log strength training and be fine. There are quite a few activities most users prefer to log though such as cycling, yoga, rowing, etc. There are a few GPS apps and heart rate monitor apps that can log to fitbit and you can always manually log so there are options depending on your preference. I don't have any affiliation with fitbit other than being a long time user and it seems I have pretty good luck with mine overall.

I was originally interested in the bugg or media. The main reason I didn't go that route is it was more expensive, involved a monthly fee and involved wearing an armband. I know I would tire of wearing the arm band even if it is comfortable so that was the main dealbreaker for me. These are only useful in helping improve activity levels if we use them consistently and I feared I might not use the bugg/media as consistently as the fitbit.



 July Minutes: 663
 
0
500
1000
1500
2000


INSPIREBYNATURE
INSPIREBYNATURE's Photo Posts: 17,699
11/29/12 4:41 P

INSPIREBYNATURE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
only been two days, but I love my bodymedia

*~Blaize~*
Proud Sunny Gal!

Keeping your body healthy is an expression of gratitude to the whole cosmos- the trees, the clouds, everything.- Thich Nhat Hanh



 current weight: 239.0 
 
265
240
215
190
165


PAPAMIKIE
PAPAMIKIE's Photo SparkPoints: (41,242)
Fitness Minutes: (86,226)
Posts: 3,853
9/27/12 11:00 A

Community Team Member

PAPAMIKIE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
In my opinion, after doing research on various body monitors, I am left very seceptical that they do what they claim. Small not on the after burn thing. The best research I have seen so far comes from work using a Metabolic Chamber. It suggest that after burn for any exercises types is very limited (both strength and HITS) and typically is in the 10s of calories per hour for less than 14 hours.

I should note I have not used one of these, but I have tried to keep up with review, etc. My opinion is that you can estimate calories just about as well with various free trackers and looking at your results as you can with Body Monitors and heart rate monitors (I am a user of a heart rate monitor, but when cross comparing Calorie estimates with other estimates I found no significan difference.)

Popie

Good running and be Careful out there

Popie
Certified Chi Running and Chi Walking Instructor


 current weight: 160.0 
 
244
220.5
197
173.5
150


THEONERM5
SparkPoints: (4,846)
Fitness Minutes: (2,211)
Posts: 91
9/27/12 12:05 A

Send Private Message
Reply
For a while I thought about getting one. I did my research and I found that fitbit would have been best for me. I ended up not getting that because I finally determined it would be useless and I didn't have money to waste.



 Pounds lost: 0.0 
 
0
22.5
45
67.5
90


CORTNEY-LEE
CORTNEY-LEE's Photo SparkPoints: (50,009)
Fitness Minutes: (42,779)
Posts: 2,980
9/25/12 10:23 P

CORTNEY-LEE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I adore my FitBit - I don't think I could live without it. It really helps keep me motivated!





 current weight: 126.6 
 
260
226.65
193.3
159.95
126.6


REBCCA
REBCCA's Photo SparkPoints: (255,490)
Fitness Minutes: (148,817)
Posts: 20,143
9/25/12 9:32 P



REBCCA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I love my BodyMedia Fit too. I have improved my sleep with the feedback it gives.

...where attention goes, energy flows...


549 Maintenance Weeks
 
0
140
280
420
560


FATBOTTOMGRL1
FATBOTTOMGRL1's Photo Posts: 1,081
9/25/12 7:47 P

Send Private Message
Reply
I love my bodymedia fit~~~ I have actually compared the numbers on an excel spreadsheet to that of Spark. Pretty much dead on! I know the armband is a pain, but once you wear it for a bit, you forget it is there.

I have another teammate that wears a bodymedia and she loves it as well!

Karah
Having another chance to get it right~ SP
Co-leader LEMON TEAM


 Pounds lost: 30.0 
 
0
22.5
45
67.5
90


CURVYCHELLE
CURVYCHELLE's Photo SparkPoints: (3,375)
Fitness Minutes: (1,578)
Posts: 45
9/25/12 4:06 P

Send Private Message
Reply
Oh, and for an overall review, here is my take: I found the BodyMedia Fit to be very accurate and it provided great data. It was very accurate regarding my sleep and appeared to be extremely accurate regarding calorie burn and steps taken. I loved having the data and tracking myself. The only downside was the arm band. I am a psychiatrist and live in Georgia. For me, having the armband was really distracting and I constantly had to explain to patients what it was (I see people almost every thirty minutes). It just became a nuisance. It gets really hot here in Georgia so I couldn't wear long sleeves all of the time to hide it and it itched sometimes. I wanted something more discreet. So after a year of not wearing my BodyMedia (because of reasons listed above), I purchased a FitBit.

I think the FitBit overestimates the number of steps I take (actually I know it does because I tracked it one day). But it is much more discreet. I clip it on my bra and no one knows it is there. It doesn't cost extra for a display like the BodyMedia does. I didn't purchase the display for the Body Media, so I had to log on every time I wanted to check my burn. Having the constant data from the FitBit was much more motivating. The overall calorie burn was very similar between the two devices, so I think it is just as accurate as the BodyMedia (although BodyMedia apparently has more ways to track your burn) It is also cheaper. The only downsides were that it didn't track my sleep as well and it can easily get lost in the washing machine since it is so small and discreet. That happened once, but it still actually works fine. So there is my take on it. If I had to do it again, I'd probably go with the FitBit, but that's just me.

Rachelle


 current weight: 231.6 
 
255
231.25
207.5
183.75
160


CURVYCHELLE
CURVYCHELLE's Photo SparkPoints: (3,375)
Fitness Minutes: (1,578)
Posts: 45
9/25/12 3:57 P

Send Private Message
Reply
I have both a BodyMedia and a FitBit (long story). The point of those is that you don't have to enter them manually. Particularly with the BodyMedia, it will continue to track the calories you burn even during strength training. The BodyMedia is really accurate. I found that when I did a HIIT workout, my calorie burn would be up a little bit the next day, reflecting the afterburn effect. I found that most online trackers were overestimating my calorie burn during strength training.

Rachelle


 current weight: 231.6 
 
255
231.25
207.5
183.75
160


DRAGONCHILDE
DRAGONCHILDE's Photo SparkPoints: (56,135)
Fitness Minutes: (14,204)
Posts: 9,566
9/25/12 3:35 P



DRAGONCHILDE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Attempting to use a monitor for calorie burn during strength training isn't a good idea; the equations don't match up, and it's too easy to grossly overestimate your calorie burn if you wear a heart rate monitor while strength training. It's not cardio. Strength training burn is more indirect-- afterburn and boosted metabolism over time. Not so much on the active calorie burn. :)

Heather
Writer, mother, wife, and breadwinner. I love to run, but running doesn't love me, so I'm switching to my low-impact bike.

I'm not pregnant, just fat: My blog.

fatnotpregnant.blogspot.com/


 current weight: 179.8 
 
211
197
183
169
155


IVEBEENREDEEMED
IVEBEENREDEEMED's Photo Posts: 93
9/25/12 3:22 P

IVEBEENREDEEMED's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Hello all! I'm wanting to purchase a body/fitness monitor, but with so many options, I'm a little overwhelmed. I've read great things about nearly all of them, and so far I'm leaning toward Bodymedia. But here's my situation, I do a lot of weightlifting, so I'm needing some way to track that. I've found that some are compatible with heart rate monitors, and I can use that to track calories, and others you have to manually enter your exercises into the online tracker.

Do you guys have any suggestions or recommendations? I'd love to hear your reviews of any monitors that you've tried, or that you've heard about!! Thanks in advance!!

~I would freely give my eyes if you might but see Christ; and I would willingly give my hands if you might but lay hold upon him.~


 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  

I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Report Innappropriate Post


Thread URL: http://www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/messageboard.asp?imboard=6&imparent=28906600

Review our Community Guidelines



 
Diet Resources: morning workout tips | morning workout video | morning ab workout