Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   SparkPeople Cafe
TOPIC:  

Dr. Oz



 
  Reply Create A New Topic
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
  I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top
 
ON2VICTORY is the moderator for this forum.
 


IMJUSTGRANDMA
SparkPoints: (34,330)
Fitness Minutes: (24,945)
Posts: 977
9/7/13 1:42 A

IMJUSTGRANDMA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I was not able to keep up with the new miracle everday. After a few times rushing out to find something he recommends and the next day it is something else I became disillusioned.

"DIANA NYAD ADMIRER"---'FIND A WAY'


 Pounds lost: 54.7 
 
0
15
30
45
60


GRAPHICS2
Posts: 2,578
9/6/13 10:18 P

GRAPHICS2's SparkPage
Reply
I don't watch Dr. Oz every day, but I don't think he is peddling anything. He has opened our
eyes to a lot of things in the medical profession that we were not aware of, or didn't understand. He is also making a lot of people more comfortable with their bodies, and how it
should, or should not function.



JANIEWWJD
JANIEWWJD's Photo SparkPoints: (207,348)
Fitness Minutes: (187,960)
Posts: 6,554
9/6/13 10:16 P

JANIEWWJD's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I didn't get to watch that particular show, but I wish I had.

Janie Garcia Moreno

"WITH GOD ALL THINGS ARE POSSIBLE"

"PRAYER CHANGES THINGS"

"NEVER PUT A QUESTION MARK WHERE GOD HAS PUT A PERIOD!"

"WHAT THE MIND CAN CONCEIVE AND BELIEVE, IT CAN ACHIEVE!"


 current weight: 120.0 
 
145
138.75
132.5
126.25
120


ANARIE
ANARIE's Photo Posts: 12,318
9/6/13 10:13 P



ANARIE's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Actually, I don't think Oz does make money directly from supplement companies (although his wife does to a limited extent.) If he were doing that directly, they could pull his medical license.

The problem with Oz is that he's a victim of his own success. When he was making his name through guest appearances and popular-press books, he was pretty phenomenal. He had a gift for sharing his knowledge in easily understandable terms, without talking down to his audience/reader. He could go on Oprah for fifteen minutes a week and just talk about things he knew, and it was entertaining and informative all at once.

But then he got his own show, and all of a sudden he had almost 20 times as much time to fill. NOBODY is smart enough to talk about what they know on TV for five hours a week and be entertaining to a general audience, especially as a side job while being a cardiothoracic surgeon!

At that point, he had a couple of choices:
--give up practicing medicine to become a researcher and present that on his show
--hire a bunch of other expert researchers and do a semi-scripted show presenting information he didn't personally know all that well
--bring on guests and let them talk about whatever they wanted to talk about

Oz chose the last option-- but unfortunately, he didn't screen his early guests well and he didn't research their topics. He let a few snake oil salesmen on and he didn't know enough to be secure in saying, "Wait a minute, that's total bull****."

And then it was all downhill from there. Because he had let those first quacks on without challenging them, he couldn't suddenly start refusing quacks or he would be accused of bias. He couldn't suddenly start challenging them for the same reason. Before he knew it, he'd become the venue of choice for quacks, and serious people wouldn't go on his show anymore because they didn't want to be associated with the quacks. Now he's in a hole he can't get out of. His show has become a free infomercial venue for crackpots and cheats.

Old friends and colleagues are actually worried about his mental health because he's acting like he believes in these magical potions when he KNOWS there's no scientific or even basic logical backing for them.

By the way, somebody said something about the FDA. The FDA has nothing to do with supplements. They're the Food and Drug Administration, and supplement makers have spent billions of dollars lobbying to make sure their products are not classed as foods or drugs. The FDA can't touch any of these people; the FDA enforces laws, and there ARE NO LAWS for supplements except that they can't use the words "treat" or "cure" and they can't put actual drugs in their products. In my opinion, it's really important to know that the FDA is legally barred from protecting people against supplements.

However, the FTC (Federal Trade Commission) and the FCC (Federal Communications Commission) have a little influence. If a supplement makes fraudulent claims, the FTC can get involved, and if they do it on TV or radio, the FCC can have something to say about it. They rarely do, but they're the ones who could, in theory. If enough people complained about Dr Oz, and it was proven that his show promotes fraud, the FCC could threaten to fine the stations that carry the program. It's hard to do, though, because as long as the products aren't illegal, people are entitled to free speech about them.



 current weight: 132.0 
 
184
169
154
139
124


ETHELMERZ
SparkPoints: (75,697)
Fitness Minutes: (55,320)
Posts: 3,367
9/6/13 9:33 P

Send Private Message
Reply
After the first month his show went "national", all of a sudden, he was not reasonable anymore, simply because he finally realized his show needed and existed because of sponsors, and he needed sponsors so badly, his company began to go with anything, enema companies, even though Dr. Oz at first said not to worry about "cleanses", they didn't do a think, supplements, oh My, he owns several companies that make supplements, same as Oprah does. That is how he "touts" products, he doesn't necessarily tell the audience to buy this and that brand, his show AND his web site is full of baloney products. Some of his guests do the same thing, that Andrew Weil is one of them for sure, and on and on. His is not the only show that does this, of course. But just using his photo sells products, especially to the elderly, particularly women.

Plan for tomorrow, but enjoy the heck out of today.


9 Days until:  anniversary
 
50
37
25
12
0


KPA1B2
SparkPoints: (39,078)
Fitness Minutes: (20,588)
Posts: 723
9/6/13 9:06 P

KPA1B2's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I've watched bits and pieces of his show. I remember seeing him do a segment on things that work i.e. toothpaste on zits. I then saw him do a segment on how that was a myth. I don't trust him.



Total SparkPoints: 39,078
 
30,000
32,499
34,999
37,499
39,999
SparkPoints Level 15


BLUENOSE63
SparkPoints: (95,813)
Fitness Minutes: (74,165)
Posts: 2,905
9/6/13 8:59 P

BLUENOSE63's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
LOVE$KITTIES hit the nail on the head. I really find Dr. Oz annoying!



 July Minutes: 0
 
0
625
1250
1875
2500


SIMPLYME80
SIMPLYME80's Photo Posts: 406
9/6/13 8:55 P

Send Private Message
Reply
At first I enjoyed his show, he promoted healthy weight loss, sensible plans and foods, exercise, and was very informative. Mentioned, vitaman/herbal supplements on rare occasions. Since taking over Oprahs time slot he has become a pill/supplement pusher-something he never did on older shows.

Highest weight-340+
Started Spark-255 lbs
Mini goal-200 lbs
Goal- around 160 lbs


 current weight: 225.0 
 
255
241.25
227.5
213.75
200


JULIA1154
Posts: 1,782
9/6/13 7:30 P

JULIA1154's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
He has no credibility with me, for a variety of reasons. His show is one of many that I don't have time for.



 current weight: 106.0 
 
150
138.75
127.5
116.25
105


MAMA_CD
MAMA_CD's Photo Posts: 1,479
9/6/13 6:39 P

MAMA_CD's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I saw the show, I'm often hesitant to respond to ads, so it's wise to check the source, if it's legit then the company will have something on their site to signify that.

MAMA_CD...count your blessings!
"To give anything less than your best is to sacrifice the gift.
www.mamaCD.org


 Pounds lost: 94.0 
 
0
26.5
53
79.5
106


THOMS1
THOMS1's Photo Posts: 10,631
9/6/13 6:38 P

THOMS1's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I like Dr. Oz but I just don't totally agree with him on a lot of things.

Becky


"Anything is possible, It's your choice whether or not you choose to make IT happen."




"If a man really wants something he will find a way, if he doesn't he will find an excuse." Stephen Dolley, Jr.





 current weight: 172.2 
 
350
305
260
215
170


LOLEMA
SparkPoints: (88,270)
Fitness Minutes: (109,189)
Posts: 4,234
9/6/13 6:34 P

LOLEMA's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I love Dr. Oz, but I don't know what to believe or who to trust his endorsements.



 Pounds lost: 15.0 
 
0
25.75
51.5
77.25
103


BREWERFAN71
BREWERFAN71's Photo SparkPoints: (29,516)
Fitness Minutes: (52,554)
Posts: 367
9/6/13 5:23 P

BREWERFAN71's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Ok, I'll probably get jumped on for this, but can anyone tell me what it is that he "hawks" that is causing all the hate? I am curious-I've only seen bits & pieces of his talk show, but I really liked the show NY Med that he was involved in. I may be wrong, but I know there are nutrition guidelines he promotes that have to do with "non-inflammatory" foods I think? For some reason that pops to mind.

I do believe a lot of what is out there is false like what he said on his show-just like the ads that use Oprah, Rachel Ray, etc. At least he has a true medical background & knows what he's talking about, not like the other doctor Oprah introduced us to who I think is a quack, Dr. Phil-but that's another story! :)



 Pounds lost: 31.0 
 
0
17.5
35
52.5
70


TACDGB
TACDGB's Photo Posts: 6,012
9/6/13 5:01 P

TACDGB's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
He should change his name from dr Oz to dr duck.........he's a quack...! He will peddle anything to promote his name........and make $$$$. That is my opinion.

Terri


 current weight: 115.5 
 
136
130.75
125.5
120.25
115


DEANNA0725
SparkPoints: (17,765)
Fitness Minutes: (10,700)
Posts: 1,561
9/6/13 4:32 P

DEANNA0725's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
One of the best things that I have done for my son and I is to turn off the TV. We watch a total of 10 hours a week and it has been wonderful. He wasn't all that thrilled about it when I told him what I was going to do, but after a few weeks everything was fine. We made it even easier to do by getting rid of cable and just having the basic channels. Sorry for being off topic, but I never liked Dr. Oz in the first place and agree that he is a pusher of all things that will make him $$$$



 current weight: 158.0 
 
162
157.75
153.5
149.25
145


ANTONIO54
ANTONIO54's Photo Posts: 58
9/6/13 4:16 P

ANTONIO54's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I must say that I've learned a Lot today.
Also: You folks have done OUTSTANDING jobs with the weight loss. Well Done



 Pounds lost: 13.5 
 
0
10
20
30
40


CAPTNSHORTBOB
CAPTNSHORTBOB's Photo Posts: 1,305
9/6/13 1:43 P

CAPTNSHORTBOB's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
He is an alarmist and peddles all kinds of stuff that probably isn't good for us. I hate how so many people think he is so wonderful when all he does every time I am unfortunate enough to catch his show is make people afraid for their lives so they go running to order his stuff. He is jsut a modern day snake oil salesman.

Sarah in Indiana

You're so surprised to find you can't stop me. - Tenacious D

You're sure to suffer crushing if you sit still. - Kompressor

Be excellent to each other. - Abraham Lincoln, San Dimas, Ca.


JHAACK39
JHAACK39's Photo SparkPoints: (12,039)
Fitness Minutes: (8,304)
Posts: 252
9/6/13 12:14 P

JHAACK39's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
If he didn't sensationally hype and hawk so many different products/plans/diets, he wouldn't have this problem. I get a lot of Ozspam. His problem is, even though most of what he hawks/hypes is rooted in science, the actual effect is overstated or left unaddressed.

Just because a study shows that consuming __________ shows an increase/decrease in ____________ in lab rats/humans/etc. does not mean that it will have a noticeable effect. Much of what he promotes would have nothing beyond a marginally measurable effect in reality.





 current weight: 187.2 
 
290
264.3
238.6
212.9
187.2


LOSE4LIFE47
LOSE4LIFE47's Photo Posts: 35,523
9/6/13 11:12 A

LOSE4LIFE47's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I was taught if something looks to good to be true then don't do it. I do my best to follow that unless I feel pressured sometimes.

Peggy (Colorado)

Please check out the teams I am on Challenged by Arthritis, DO IT FOR LOVE!, Isagenix users & Osteoarthritis in (Hips or knees) mild or Severe teams!!!!







 July SparkPoints: 1,920
 
0
250
500
750
1000


ANTONIO54
ANTONIO54's Photo Posts: 58
9/6/13 10:41 A

ANTONIO54's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Oh geez, how naive I am. I didn't think of that at all. He sure sold me if what your saying is true.



 Pounds lost: 13.5 
 
0
10
20
30
40


SHERYLDS
SHERYLDS's Photo Posts: 11,486
9/6/13 10:10 A

SHERYLDS's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
I totally agree with LOVE4KITTIES
I use the medical websites to investigate issues and I search for news articles before buying into any hype. The food and drug industry has become so money hungry and the FDA is less and less powerful (or vigilant ?) that we need to do our own thinking these days.

the old saying ... if it sounds too good to be true...it is.

USA EST


 Pounds lost: 2.0 
 
0
3
6
9
12


LOVE4KITTIES
LOVE4KITTIES's Photo Posts: 1,794
9/6/13 10:03 A

LOVE4KITTIES's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
Dr. Oz promotes a lot of fad diets, supplements, etc. ON his show that don't work and could possibly be dangerous. He knows what he's doing...he's saying whatever he needs to in order to gain as much popularity and as many viewers as possible. This means more sponsors and more $$$ to line his pockets. Oz doesn't make any money when his name is used without his permission and I'm willing to bet that this (and not any concerns about his viewers' health) is his chief concern. I'm willing to bet that the preponderance of websites using Oz's name also upset his sponsors because they are paying him to use his name and want limited use of that name so they can sell more of their product to people who buy stuff simply because it's endorsed by Oz. In other words, it makes Oz-sponsored products less special (thus creates less sales) if lots of places are using the Oz name vs just a select few.

Overall...
Dr. Oz uses his medical degree to give himself credibility that he does not deserve. He's anything but credible. He lends his name to certain companies for $$$ in order to give their products credibility that they do not deserve. Other websites use his name without his permission to give themselves credibility that they do not deserve... All of them are promoting nonsense at best and stuff which could harm you at worst. Your best bet is actually to avoid getting health/diet information from Oz and avoid any products that he promotes or which use his name without his permission.



Total SparkPoints: 13,450
 
10,000
11,249
12,499
13,749
14,999
SparkPoints Level 11


ANTONIO54
ANTONIO54's Photo Posts: 58
9/6/13 9:27 A

ANTONIO54's SparkPage
Send Private Message
Reply
on tv, Monday, Labor Day.
Dr; Oz's show was about fake ads using his name.
He asked that everyone who see's his name being used any other place except "HIS" web site contact the web site doing the false ads.
Did anyone else see this show?
More importantly, buyer beware! They are selling fake or even dangerous suppliments using his name.

Your thoughts?



 Pounds lost: 13.5 
 
0
10
20
30
40


 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  

I Liked This Topic Subscribe to this Discussion Share
Add This to My SparkFavorites
Report Innappropriate Post


Thread URL: http://www.sparkpeople.com/myspark/messageboard.asp?imboard=1&imparent=31919645

Review our Community Guidelines



 
Diet Resources: diabetes portion control | portion control containers | portion control diets