Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

    CTUPTON   157,689
150,000-199,999 SparkPoints

Should obesity be considered a disease? SP article.

Sunday, November 03, 2013

I think this is a good idea. First of all insurance is more likely to pay for things like exercise opportunities like membership in a health club, pool, zumba class, WW meetings, etc.


Member Comments About This Blog Post:
DJ4HEALTH 11/5/2013 7:39PM

    They just want to make it a disease just to give more drugs out and not help the people that need to be helped. Just read what they say and in it is all about drugs or that surgery that messed up the insides and most people end up back where they were before the surgery or in poorer health later down the road

Report Inappropriate Comment
MARGARITTM 11/4/2013 2:08PM

    SO if obestiy is a disease then it is safe to say that Surgical procedures for obesity should be covered with no criteria other than a high BMI...... no previous attempts at less intrusive measures, no psychological work up. .... what about medical coverage for the removal of extra skin - tummy tucks etc..... after all the only reason the person needs it is because of a disease.

Who is tired of people not "owning their issues"?

Report Inappropriate Comment
SHERYLP461 11/4/2013 9:05AM

    My insurance already pays for gym memberships, preventative medicine should be covered always

Report Inappropriate Comment

    I agree Chris

Report Inappropriate Comment
NANCYPAT1 11/4/2013 5:59AM

    Thanks for this one - it has caused a lot of stir and people have VERY strong opinions about it,.

Report Inappropriate Comment
TIMOTHYNOHE 11/3/2013 11:05PM

    My sister is one who is all in favor of the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare). In our conversations she points to Mammograms being included are "prevention". I am not opposed to it. But when I asked about Weight Watchers or gym memberships or race costs she fairly recoiled. "You can pay for them yourself! Those have nothing to do with health care." I pointed out that by the same token, mammograms were not preventative; strictly speak they were only diagnostic. "But weight loss/management programs and fitness program were 100% preventative."

I guess she is of the opinion that poor people shouldn't have access to such things.

Report Inappropriate Comment
2HAMSDIET 11/3/2013 10:47PM


Report Inappropriate Comment
ARTJAC 11/3/2013 9:35PM

    emoticon emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
JIM546 11/3/2013 3:44PM

    GI Warrior 9
Gunny Gym is back from cross training with the Navy. Those guys really have it soft. He hardly ever thought about the “GI Diet Wars” for five months but he did put on a few pounds. Now he finds himself back on the front again battling Scale lines. Portion control is where he needs to post extra sentries because he likes the taste of even healthy foods. He loves the taste of so many foods that it makes nutrition a problem. He eats broccoli, cabbage, double fiber bread, low fat yogurt, fruit, nuts, and oatmeal with skim milk already. He writes in a journal, and tracks meals until he burns out and needs some time off. He walks 30 minutes every day. He has made healthy changes after healthy changes. He has changed so many bad habits that he should be invisible by now, but he is not. Every little change should make a difference. Why doesn’t it?
The answer is metabolism which affects how he maintains, loses, or gains weight. The Gunny has gained about a pound a year since he was 15. This goes in cycles sometimes up sometimes forced down but always back to the trend line over time. He is now approaching 75 (that is 60 years) and he was 60 scale lines from victory. One pound a year is only 3,500 calories. That is an average of 9.6 calories too many each day for sixty years. Why haven’t little changes made the difference? I guess they have but there is some unknown regulator in his body that is set 9.6 calories a day too high. Someday maybe a little laboratory mouse will show people how to correct their metabolism and then the GI warrior will be able to retire and have a beer that he doesn’t have to count.. “Giving up sausage is the Wurst.”
So! Should the GI Warrior give up in his war on Scale? Never! Spark people is life for him because he needs to be healthy and happy. The Scale War must go on for him to stay that way.
What good would it do to be a disease? Insurance companies would just use it against anyone that tried to get help and lawyers would have a ball defining it.

Report Inappropriate Comment
LIFEISSWEET2 11/3/2013 12:33PM

    I agree that obesity should be classified as a disease. If you are obese, not just a little overweight but obese, it's not a simple as: eat less food. It is a complicated issue that's physical, mental, & emotional. If we look at this as a disease then perhaps we can change the way we treat obesity, both medically and socially.

Report Inappropriate Comment
CINDYWAGNER1 11/3/2013 11:23AM

    emoticon emoticon emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
GRAMMACATHY 11/3/2013 11:15AM

    Obesity is the result of over-eating. Certain foods are terribly addictive. Others are so processed there is no nutritive value, so we are inclined to keep eating trying to get the nutrition we need. More education at an earlier age in school will help. I think maybe the doctors need to start prescribing apples, natural foods and organic food before handing out more pills. I think sending patients to nutritionists for education would be wise and to counselors to help them deal with emotional eating and to the gym to get educated on safe ways to exercise w/o causing injury.

Report Inappropriate Comment
LIS193 11/3/2013 10:52AM

    It's another ploy to sell drugs etc - it will only help the "health care" and drug industries. They are interested in selling their "product" nit in curing anything.
It all comes down to personal responsibility - stop eating processed "food" and eat the real stuff!

Report Inappropriate Comment
JUSTYNA7 11/3/2013 10:01AM

    Unlike many diseases there is so much hope to deal with obesity... but many people need help, education and support. I agree. Yes, make it a disease. CErtainly my eating disorder is a disease. If is such a complicated thing. People get stuck in loops. Food can be a drug. Yes, yes, yes.

Comment edited on: 11/3/2013 10:03:02 AM

Report Inappropriate Comment
SANDRALEET 11/3/2013 9:17AM

    prevention can mean your health and even your life I have been on a program like that for 5 years I learned so much Ignorance is not bless

Report Inappropriate Comment
DS9KIE 11/3/2013 9:03AM

    i agree if they really get exercise and diet help but my fear is that they will push more drugs and surgeries.

Report Inappropriate Comment

Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

Log in to post a comment.

Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.