15,000-19,999 SparkPoints 19,076

Reasons why low-carb diets may not work or not work very well and how to correct that

Wednesday, March 06, 2013

I run into a few people from time to time who tell me that low-carb did not work for them. Many times the reasons are related to things mentioned in this helpful article:


Many other times people have other health issues that keep them from being successful. Common problems are two that I have experienced in the past: hypothyroidism and other allergies that affect how comfortable and energetic one feels.

Another factor that can play a role are existing eating disorders, an unhealthy environment (family not on board, too much stress, too little sleep etc.) . These are all reasons why other steps need to be added to a low-carb diet (or any diet) to be successful.
Share This Post With Others
Member Comments About This Blog Post
  • -LINDA_S
    Thanks, Birgit! Very informative!
    1807 days ago
    I was tested for thyroid issues last November in trying to rule out what some of my issues have been and was perplexed when they came out negative - but now am trying low carb. So on the bright side, I won't have to deal with hypothyroidism while doing this experiment!
    1808 days ago
    Great info, thanks for the link

    1808 days ago
    Thanks for this blog it really got us talking

    Country Living Team

    1809 days ago
    Thanks for sharing . I have never really thought about anything other then calories in calories out. I believe it is all about moderation emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon
    1809 days ago
    I'll have to read the article, but another issue is having a cheat day - to eat what you gave up, I mean you gave it up for a reason, but you gotta have a cheat day to have it again? I understand that it might be hard not to resist certain foods - but a cheat day ? Planned ? I don't do them.. they can throw my whole food management out the window. Just my 2 cents eh emoticon dinner time, gotta go - cheers
    1809 days ago
  • M77355
    What a helpful blogpost!
    1809 days ago
    Great article! Thanks for posting! I haven't weighed myself so I don't know if the low-carb thing is working or not. But I do feel better for the most part eating fewer carbs and that matters more to me than the weight. I'm still learning how to eat low-carb but I'm doing fairly well overall. Honestly, I wouldn't go back to eating more carbs. I may go over on my carb limit but it's not by too terribly much and like I said, I feel better eating with the low-carb diet.
    1809 days ago
    Low carb diets work for me, I just really LOVE my carbs and found it hard to say no. I've been much better at it lately and the scales show it, YAY.
    1809 days ago
    Great article.
    1809 days ago
    Yep I know that a low carb diet would never work for me as I need the glycemin that carbs produce to keep the level normal in my body. Our body has a set Glycemic Index and when you let that amount fall to low, then the body goes into self preservation mode and keeps weight on even though you are exercising. These levels need to be replenished after every exercising session . ...foods like bananas, apples, strawberries, avacadoes etc.
    1809 days ago

    Comment edited on: 3/6/2013 5:12:22 PM
  • Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

    Log in to post a comment

    Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.