15,000-19,999 SparkPoints 19,506

Reality vs. Entertainment

Wednesday, January 09, 2013

Article that kicked off this blog entry:

While I understand that a lot of Southern stereotypes are there for a reason, I don't agree with using them to exploit people for entertainment purposes. I know that people can make their own choices when it comes airing out their lives publicly, but when it comes to people struggling with poverty vs. celebrities, I think there is a huge difference. And yet, instead of trying to help these people climb out of poverty and not judge them because they are different, we throw huge wads of cash at them and laugh at their "backward" ways. I don't blame the networks too much because they are only going along with what the masses demand in terms of entertainment. However, the argument from the networks that these shows shed light on rural poverty and make people aware of it is a load of crap. This just feeds that need for superiority. To truly help these people, networks should portray situations like this in a balanced, non-judgmental way. I guess that's just not as entertaining for us.

How does this tie back to SP? Well, first of all, we have the weight loss reality shows. They are a little less irksome to me because they do provide benefits and motivation to not only the participants, but the viewers of the show. However, I think the grueling Boot Camps that push people to the point of being ill, the focus on weight loss instead of body composition, the "all or nothing" mentality of the competition (lose big or go home), and lack of real world relevance all in the name of "entertainment" is pretty aggravating because I see people try to emulate that and just give up when they fail or are faced with real life. Some of the shows create a disturbing portrayal of the participants "before" life. There's a difference between reality we can relate to and reality that reinforces stereotypes of "all fat, lazy slobs who don't care about themselves".

Finally, I think an important goal in healthy living is a healthy mindset. I don't think any of us have the resolution to be a judgmental a-hole in our everyday lives, but we all fall victim to feeling superior over someone. Make it a daily goal to be kind and accepting to everyone, regardless of where they live, how big they are, or how different they are from you.

And now back to our regularly scheduled lol:

Share This Post With Others
Member Comments About This Blog Post
  • PUNKY100
    AMEN!!!!! I was JUST thinking this when watching the biggest loser premiere the other night. The guy who was working his @$$ off and becoming a real athlete was sent home. Why? Because he lost 5 lbs in a week. He lost 20 the first week!! I remember hearing one of the trainers say 'if you have a bad day here, you're going home'. That actually made me upset. That is NOT the way it works, as we all know here. When you have a bad day, you should be able to dust yourself off and get back to it. Not throw in the towel because suddenly you're losing 'only' 5 lbs instead of 10 in a frickin week.

    Whew, rant over. Needless to say, I agree with you about this whole blog. And I will NOT be watching that West Virginia 'jersey shore' show. I never watched the Jersey one, and I can't imagine laughing at poor people would make me happy.
    1892 days ago
    These weight loss shows has caused people to be disappointed in a 2 or 3 pound weekly weight loss. People feel they should be able to lose 100 lbs in six months. They may be able to but will they keep it off? Will they have learned to change their relationship with food? People forget that these people are locked on a ranch and exercising is their JOB. Working out 5 hours a day is not reasonable.
    1894 days ago
    "Make it a daily goal to be kind and accepting to everyone, regardless of where they live, how big they are, or how different they are from you."
    That is so true! Thank you for sharing!
    1894 days ago
    Good point of view. Thanks for sharing.
    1894 days ago
  • Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

    Log in to post a comment

    Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.