SparkPeople advertisers help keep the site free! Learn more


    SPARK_UK_NICOLA   1,849
SparkPoints
1,000-2,499 SparkPoints
 
 
Mind Over Matter – Can Paul McKenna & Marisa Peer Really Make You Thin?

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Two British hypnotherapists tell us how to lose weight using the most powerful tool available to us – our mind!

This approach is very appealing to many as people tend to think that you don’t have to do anything - Paul McKenna will do it all! Well it’s true that the hypnotic approach won’t have you doing push ups at 8am on a Saturday morning in the park and you won’t have to exist on nothing but fresh air and cabbage soup for a week but the hypnotherapy approach shouldn’t be thought of as easy either. To succeed you have to be willing to push yourself out of a comfort zone that is even more alluring than your bed on a Saturday morning and work to change your mind set and thought patterns.

There is an air of mystique when it comes to hypnotherapy, we’re so used to seeing hypnotic techniques played out on stage for our entertainment and there is a sense of magic or wizardry that accompanies the ‘look into my eyes’ approach but modern day hypnotherapy is different to the old school stage days. Its more conversational and systematic and involves other psychological techniques as well as hypnosis. The two books (and techniques) I’m talking about in this post are Paul McKenna’s ‘I Can Make you Thin’ and Marisa Peer’s ‘You Can Be Thin’. Both books take you through what seem like very practical and straight forward steps but both also claim to be written in what they call ‘hypnotic language’ There is that mystique again! Both come with a hypnosis CD, which for best results should be listened to regularly.

First up, here is what Paul McKenna sets out as his ‘I Can Make You Thin’ guidelines:

1. Eat when you are hungry
Starving yourself can actually make you fat. Not eating slows down your metabolism, which makes you feel tired. It can also lead to false hunger signals and subsequently, binge-eating. You need to train yourself to eat only when you're hungry

2. Eat what you want - not what you think you should
As soon as you tell yourself to avoid certain foods, you upset the balance of your relationship with them. By eating what you want, you establish a balanced diet. Your tastes change and you may find yourself craving the very foods you're "supposed" to be eating. If you want it, eat it. Resistance is futile.

3. Eat consciously - enjoy every mouthful
People who are overweight often eat too quickly in order to get a serotonin high. Eating "subconsciously" can expand your stomach and cause weight gain.
Eat what you want, whenever you want, so long as you enjoy every bite. Chew every mouthful, slowing your eating speed down to a quarter of what it used to be, and you'll automatically eat less and feel better.

4. When you think you are full, stop eating
When you've eaten enough, your body should receive a signal in your solar plexus, which says it's satisfied. The more you pay attention to this, the more satisfied you will feel and you'll know when to stop eating. You need to re-sensitise yourself to your 'inner thermostat' so you stop eating food when you're full.

Marisa Peer adds in some other little tricks which I found really interesting, focusing a lot on NLP (neuro-linguistic programming) techniques:

1. Change your language.
Changing the way you speak to yourself and the words you use everyday will make you change the pictures in your mind. This is important as the pictures we have in our mind can quite easily become our reality. Whatever we tell ourselves the mind absorbs and accepts. I have experienced this with my clients too. I remember a few years ago a client telling me that she changed the password she used to access her computer several times a day from ‘fat pig’ to ‘slim and happy’ and she believes this had a profound effect on how she saw herself and helped her to lose weight.

Taking ownership of things is also a powerful mind tool. When we use ‘my’ and ‘mine’ our minds form an attachment to those things, believing them to be something valuable and important to us. Most things we call mine are important to us, like ‘my baby’, ‘my career’, ‘my home’ but what about ‘I hate my fat thighs’ and ‘I wish my fat belly would disappear’ We’re also taking ownership of the things we don’t want my saying ‘my’. Marisa advises that anything you want to be free of you should prefix with ‘the’ rather than ‘my’.

Overeating can stem from a general feeling of lack. Tell yourself you are enough with positive affirmations several times a day.

Choose to be thinner by replacing ‘I can’t’ with ‘I choose not to have that’. This assertion is stronger than willpower as your brain believes you to be making a choice. Make your brain believe that you want this and it will ultimately give you power. This moves you away from denial and resistance.

2. Change your mindset:
Accept certain restrictions. You don’t stay at home when you should be working or go out when taking care of children, or go on dates with people you’re attracted to when you’re married – life is full of restrictions that we naturally accept without difficulty so you can also accept that this is reality when it comes to deciding what to eat too.

Think about how much it costs you to eat cheap food. Not the amount of money it costs to buy but the real cost of eating unhealthy food. What are you missing out on by continuing to eat food that makes you unhealthy and overweight? Quality of life, self esteem, love life, career? Many of us also have a weakness for free food when it offered, despite it being healthy or not. One way to convince yourself not to eat it is to say to yourself, ‘I have my whole life to eat, its not free, it will cost me a lot to eat it.’

3. Positive Visualization.
Thinking positively about weight reduction can activate neurons that secrete endogenous opiates, which make us feel good and allow us to stop comfort eating. The opposite is also true – thinking negatively activates the release of stress hormones like cortisol, which encourages over-eating and weight gain. Spend some time visualizing yourself as the person you want to be, feel how happy it would make you and make it as vivid and real as you can. As well as forming the right picture in your mind, tell yourself the right words. Don’t use negative words like ‘I’m not’ and ‘I can’t’. Instead use ‘I am’, ‘I can’, ‘I always’, ‘I do’.

I believe all of these techniques work if they are practiced over and over again until they become habitual. Changing the way your mind works and undoing negative thought patterns can take a lot of time and effort but if it gives you back the power of control over your eating habits, weight and ultimately health then surely it’s worth the effort? I’d be interested to get your feedback on this one. Have you read either of these books yourself, or any other hypnotherapy weight loss books? Have you had a hypnotherapy session? Please share!
SHARE
  Member Comments About This Blog Post:

JULIEHEDGER 4/29/2013 5:24AM

    i found pmk[s cd very good and it certainly helped with my self esteem,i[ve also got a lot braver since listening to it (i even perform with a belly dancing group) but as for the over eating.yes i know i do it but it gives me the choice.i used to blame everyone else now i dont.its me guilty.

Report Inappropriate Comment
HERMES418 2/9/2013 6:58AM

    I have Paul McKenna's book, and 4 CDs bought as a pack from QVC. I tried it but it did nothing for me. It had no effect at all. Sometimes when I've had a 'nanna nap' I wake up and the first thing I think of is food and need to eat. Not quite the effect I was looking for but I do manage to control the urge to eat after a nap by consciously telling myself that I don't really need food and go get myself a drink of water instead.

Report Inappropriate Comment
FUTUREHOPE49 1/14/2013 7:39PM

    I have attended an NLP course and it really did work for me, but it was not for weight loss, it gave me confidence. I am sure it would work for weight loss too. Great blog! Thank you!

Report Inappropriate Comment
SUPERSYLPH 1/2/2013 2:56PM

    I haven't read either of these books, but all of the points make sense. What we tell ourselves is very important.

Report Inappropriate Comment
LAURENVJC 1/1/2013 8:08AM

    I have used the Paul McKenna hypnosis but on my iPhone (it comes as an app), I actually find that whenever I fall asleep listening to it.....(for people struggling to sleep its brilliant!) ...but generally I wake up extremely hungry and find myself eating more food that day. Is it just me or has anyone else found this???

X

Report Inappropriate Comment
ALLYBEE13 12/17/2012 10:13AM

    I used the PMcK CD a while ago and found that it really did help me to change my relationship with certain foods. For instance, I discovered that if I concentrated on the taste and texture of things it made me re-evaluate whether I really liked them. I can now be honest with myself and say that I don't like chocolate. Also, if I am eating something and I'm not enjoying it I will just stop eating it and find an alternative (healthy of course).

I'm currently using visualisation to keep my goal in focus. A further tip I'd like to add is that if you are going to use visualisation then keep the picture moving - just like a movie. If you're aiming for that swimsuit or little black dress then picture yourself moving in it, for example walking along the beach in your swimsuit or dancing in your LBD as this makes it easier to visualise than trying to imagine a static picture.

Report Inappropriate Comment
ROSESOAN 11/30/2012 4:49PM

  I had forgotten the Paul McKenna's advice. I will go back and read the book again. Thank you for the blogg, Very interesting emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
STRONGWARRIOR1 11/19/2012 12:52PM

    Hardly any body uses the full potential of mind of matter exercises. It does work, but has to practised daily. People can be lazy and its easier to pass responsability onto something or somebody else.

Report Inappropriate Comment
ALEXGRAY 11/11/2012 12:38PM

    McKenna has good (if rather obvious and basic) advice, but I hate his delivery.

You didn't mention Peer's rather faddy food advice, e.g. her weird obsession with bread. While yes, bread is one of those things that provides a lot more calories than you expect, her rationale for not eating it is so bizarre, it destroys her credibility as a dietary advisor. (I still don't get what that thing about mushing up water and bread was supposed to prove.)

I quite like Ursula James' "You Can Think Yourself Thin", which also has NLP techniques (she never says that's what they are, but there's definitely timeline and NLP-style anchoring in there, maybe some other stuff that I've forgotten) and more practical exercises as well. Also I like the fact that she's dressed up in a posh frock on the cover for no better reason than that it's her book and if she wants to dress up in a posh frock for it, she will! (James, alas, has gone a bit nutty in the years since that book & CD was published, but don't let her later "mystical" work put you off that book.)


Report Inappropriate Comment
DANLENO1949 11/7/2012 5:33AM

    Some good tips there. I will give some of them a try. emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
POLSKARENIA 11/3/2012 1:30PM

    An interesting blog and some interesting comments too - I particularly like the comment about having food in your mouth and empty hands... it is all too easy to shovel in the food wothouit enjoying it.. and forget about it before it even reaches its destination!

Report Inappropriate Comment
STONECOT 11/2/2012 8:53AM

    I read Paul McKenna and listened to his CD, I lost 30 lbs, and after the first couple of weeks I didn't find it particularly difficult. I have kept that 30lbs off except for 3! Which seem to stick. The CD also did wonders for my confidence, and I found myself tackling situations that previously I would have avoided. I still listen to it once a week.

Report Inappropriate Comment
EXIDIA 11/2/2012 5:21AM

    There are some great ideas here - all grist to the mill!

Report Inappropriate Comment
SCREWIE 11/2/2012 5:10AM

    Thank you for highlighting these two options. They sound very helpful.

Report Inappropriate Comment
ARTJAC 11/2/2012 4:39AM

    emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
ELLEKTRA 11/1/2012 6:07PM

    Brilliant

Report Inappropriate Comment
OLIVIANIGHT 11/1/2012 5:18PM

    I saw 'I can make you thin' on TV a few years ago. I was so skeptical I almost didn't try it, but I'm so glad I did because just concentrating on what I ate lost me 3 stone.
It did take a lot of work, I kept forgetting at the start and then feeling bad but once I got into the swing it was really easy. And it helped me realise that I don't actually like chocolate!

Report Inappropriate Comment
PUSSEY5 11/1/2012 2:25PM

  very interesting . Thank you carolxx

Comment edited on: 11/1/2012 2:26:41 PM

Report Inappropriate Comment
MARUKI52 11/1/2012 1:24PM

    This was really interesting to read. I have read Paul McKennas book and listened to his cd and found them helpful so I was interested to read your take on his book and also Marisa Peers which I have not read. Thank you for reminding me of what I have read and also the information from Marisa Peers book. It is good to have a reminder from time to time of helpful suggestions. Sometimes we forget.

Report Inappropriate Comment
MILLIE5522 11/1/2012 12:01PM

    Great blog! I came across Paul Mckenna's "I can make you slim" several years ago and tried to use his techniques as much as I could. They certainly helped me to see my relationship with food in a more positive light but I still needed the nutritional knowledge and motivational support that I got from SP to be successful. emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
LINDAK25 11/1/2012 11:15AM

    I haven't read either of these books, nor have I tried hypnotherapy. However, the techniques and guidelines you mentioned are all things that Spark People promotes. And yes, positive thinking really works.

Isn't it all a matter of perception? How we see ourselves, what we say to ourselves, and how we visualize our goals helps us to succeed. If hypnosis works for someone, then that's great. We all have to find what works for each of us.

Report Inappropriate Comment
SLIMLEAF 11/1/2012 11:10AM

    Interesting. I definitely need to change the way I think about food if I'm ever going to achieve and maintain a healthy weight.

Report Inappropriate Comment
WONDERINGONE 11/1/2012 10:52AM

  As a hypnotherapist I use most of these techniques and would like to add one more, simple, way of eating.

If there is something in your mouth there should be nothing in your hands!
Most people fill their mouths with food and as soon as this is done they are busy moving food around the plate and deciding what to put on the fork and into their mouths next.
Whilst doing this concentration has moved from the pleasure of what can be tasted and enjoyed to thinking about how nice the next mouthful is going to be. As soon as the fork is full they swallow and the whole thing starts again.

And just to make things even better eating one mouthful at a time takes longer and gives time to realise the feeling of fullness.



Report Inappropriate Comment
ANGEMCC 11/1/2012 10:09AM

    Thanks for this blog, very helpful! :-)

Report Inappropriate Comment
L*I*T*A* 10/31/2012 11:29PM

    interesting!!!
great share.........
blessings and hugs.........lita

Report Inappropriate Comment
LVMAMAW 10/31/2012 8:32PM

    emoticon Very interesting. emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
GABY1948 10/31/2012 4:11PM

    A very lot of info, thanks for sharing! emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
NEW-CAZ 10/31/2012 2:42PM

    Paul's methods have some merit!

Report Inappropriate Comment
LEXIE63 10/31/2012 11:50AM

    Actually, the hypnosis aside (I tried Paul McKenna's stop smoking hypnosis thingee, and it didn't work for me) there is a lot of common sense in what is suggested by both these people, especially the turning negative thoughts into positive ones by changing how you say things. I did eventually stop smoking, largely by taking literally one day at a time so it wasn't an 'all or nothing' quit, and learning that I was not depriving myself of something I liked, but freeing myself of something I disliked - namely me a slave to nicotine!

The same thing can work with food. As soon as you stop 'depriving' yourself of what you like, and just eat it in a different way, and use positive reinforcement language alongside, it is amazing how much better you feel, and how freeing that is!

There is some really good help in there, so thanks for bringing it to our attention. :-)

Hugs,
Lex xxx

Report Inappropriate Comment

Add Your Comment to the Blog Post


Log in to post a comment.