Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

    VHALKYRIE   16,242
15,000-19,999 SparkPoints

Carb Cycling

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

When you get into the single digits left for weight loss goals, losing even .5% bodyfat is cause for celebration and dancing in the streets. I *only* have 7-8lbs to lose as a goal milestone, but I've been stuck for over 3 months.

When I had 40lbs to lose, just cutting out soda and walking more was enough to lose weight.

When I had 30lbs to lose, I needed to eat cleaner. I eliminated processed and fast foods.

When I had 20lbs to lose, I had to cut back carbohydrates. 160g carbs was simply too high for me. Eating less than 100g carbs trimmed off fat nicely.

Now that I have less than 10lbs to lose, what to do?

I'm experimenting with carb cycling. This is a technique used by bodybuilders to trim fat before competition. While I am not even close to a bodybuilder, I thought it might do the trick to kick start fat burn again.

Basically it works by alternating no carb, low carb, and high carb days. No carb clears out fat storage hormones (insulin). High carb resets leptin and muscle growth hormones. Both of which can get out of whack on very low carb and very high carb diets. Carb cycling, the theory goes, juggles the hormones around to optimize fat loss. It's supposed to work better when a person is already at normal or low body fat levels. So I'm giving it a try.

I'm also upping the intensity of my workouts with circuit training to increase both calorie burn and resistance. I'm all about efficiency, and circuit training is more bang for the time buck. It's been pretty brutal this week, but I think it's working.

My plan is something like this:

No carb (less than 40g): Veggies/Protein
Low Carb (less than 80g): Veggies/Protein/Fruit
High Carb (approx 100-120g): Veggies/Protein/Fruit/Starch

"No carb" isn't exactly 0, and "high carb" isn't exactly high for my purposes.

It's cycled like this:

Mon: No Carb
Tues: Low Carb
Weds: High Carb
Thurs: No Carb
Fri: No Carb
Sat: Low Carb
Sun: High Carb

That means a couple of days a week and on weekends I can indulge in a side of mashed potatoes, rice, bread or even a small dessert.

My exercise routine is alternating between short, high intensity (elliptical/spinning/circuit x30mins) and long, low intensity (walking/cycling x1hr+) - 3x HIIT and 4x LIIT.

Tues: LIIT
Weds: HIIT
Thurs: LIIT

I'll let you know in a few weeks if this does the trick.

Member Comments About This Blog Post:
IRP1114 10/28/2012 10:45PM

    Lowering carbs does seem to do the trick for most. Hope it works out for you. I like that you are varying to your energy needs :-)

Report Inappropriate Comment
MRS.CARLY 10/28/2012 9:51PM

    I've always done well on carb cycling diets! Good luck!

Report Inappropriate Comment
VHALKYRIE 10/25/2012 12:48PM

    EGALITAIRE: Excellent questions!! I was going to wait to explain more of the concept until after I tried out the n=1 experiment on myself for a couple of weeks. I don't know if this will actually work, so I was holding off on getting too deep into it until I had more 'evidence' in my trial. But you all are getting into some very, very good questions and ideas, so I'll try to compile all this into a follow up blog.

Great discussion, all!

Report Inappropriate Comment
EGALITAIRE 10/25/2012 12:28PM

    This is a great discussion - I love hear all the different perspectives and experiences.

I am interested in the concept of needing extra carbs on a high intensity exercise day - what would happen if one didn't carb load - that being a relative term.

My carbs are between 40 and 80 most days, but I don't cycle intentionally, just vary the menu.

I am increasing the number of Tabata protocols I do each week, and I do a long (2+ hour) ride each week. I don't notice feeling like I need extra carbs on or after those days - for those of you who feel you need extra carbs - what are the indicators?

Report Inappropriate Comment
VHALKYRIE 10/25/2012 12:17PM

    LadyRose: I think you and I have the similar ideas about "rest day". :)

Hmm...I think this would be a good topic for a blog!

Report Inappropriate Comment
DEELB1 10/25/2012 12:05PM

  emoticon interesting

Report Inappropriate Comment
LADYROSE 10/25/2012 11:52AM

    *whew* didn't want you to think I was knocking your plan! :)

"What do you think? Does rest day mean 'sedentary'?"

Honestly, I truly believe you need some total down, do nothing time. I know that a lot of people get fidgety and antsy when they just sit and/or are still. Most people just don't know how to be still (count me in that) but by constantly feeling like you need to be doing - again, fast track to burnout.

The big thing on a 'rest' day to keep in mind: it's about recovery - mind, body and spirit. If you enjoy taking a stroll on the beach, by all means do it - stop, look at shells and rocks, laugh, throw sand at each other (if you're walking with the hubby or a friend) or just take the time to be in nature and don't think about heart rate, number of miles/steps, etc. And if you can do a little bit of stretching along the way, even better!

I think about the life pre-industrialization: people worked hard, then came in for the night, had dinner, then sat and talked, prayed, laughed with family, then went to bed at a decent hour to start it all over. They usually had 1-2 days where they did the minimum, then just hung out the rest of the day.

That all make sense?

Report Inappropriate Comment
BILL60 10/25/2012 8:01AM

    I agree with SALONKITTY's remark. I do high intensity cycling 3X weekly and have to repair by consuming some carbs. I couldn't limit my carbs on those days. Let us know how it goes. And BTW, you're doing incredible well. The very best to you.

Report Inappropriate Comment
ADZY86 10/25/2012 4:56AM

    I'm really intrigued to see how this is going to pan out. Keep us posted. Right now I just do low carb cos I find it easier, but I've read time and time again that you do need to 'confuse' your body to keep it burning. I do this with my workouts, but not yet with my food.
Hope it works out.

Report Inappropriate Comment
GREENGENES 10/24/2012 11:46PM

    Nice idea if you can stick to it. I couldn't keep track of that kind of program but then I'm lucky if I can remember what day it is.

Report Inappropriate Comment
EGALITAIRE 10/24/2012 11:28PM

    Yes, also looking forward to seeing how this works for you. I am in a somewhat similar place - with more to lose - but have plateaued for a few months after dropping weight quickly and regularly.

My main goal is health, so I am patient with finding out what will make the scale move - I have been tweaking my exercise, although not as scientifically as would be needed to actually know what's working and what's not.

I have not really changed my diet much.

Report Inappropriate Comment
VHALKYRIE 10/24/2012 8:56PM

    They're always coming up with something, aren't they? I read it on a bodybuilder forum. The more extreme measure is the ketogenic diet. I've been trying to avoid it, but if carb cycling doesn't work, then that may be a last resort.

"Keeping the body guessing" is why I'm cycling high/low carbs AND exercise!

Report Inappropriate Comment
MYLADY4 10/24/2012 8:37PM

    Good luck with this and I am curious to see how it works. I have tried it before but just could not committ to it fully. It was just easier to eat low carb. Maybe the new year.

Report Inappropriate Comment
GETSTRONGRRR 10/24/2012 8:35PM

    Sounds like an interesting concept, hadn't heard of it (although my son, the "Bodybuilder", heralds the concept of "keeping your body guessing" by constantly changing his workouts.

you mentioned a while back that the Low Intensity of long walks, hikes etc. of more than an hour or two were most effective in burning fat. Maybe a long leisurely work on the weekends....

Report Inappropriate Comment
VHALKYRIE 10/24/2012 7:50PM

    Great thoughts, LadyRose! The strength training is included in my circuit training. "Rest" days are included in the LIIT - very leisurely activities like walking around a park. :) I didn't think of rest days as necessarily sedentary.

What do you think? Does rest day mean 'sedentary'? By low intensity I mean very low, like walking. The weekend walks on the beach and cycling are at a very leisurely pace - like 50-55 HRM.

Comment edited on: 10/24/2012 7:58:52 PM

Report Inappropriate Comment
LADYROSE 10/24/2012 7:19PM

    Good call SalonKitty... was just going to mention that... with the HIIT workouts, you'll be burning through your glycogen stores pretty quick, so will need to put the high carb day before those workouts and maybe the day off, or at least as part of your post-workout meal, then you can drop the carbs.

Can't wait to see how the experiement works!

PS - You ARE a bodybuilder! You're doing the work to build an awesome, healthy body!!

PPS - that brings up a question: where's the weights in your exercise routine? I'd suggest 1-cutting a couple of LIIT days and making those weight training days (doesn't have to be complicated, just some body weights or if you're at the gym, lift really heavy things.) and 2 - add a rest day in there! Not a 'doing less' day, an actual rest day to allow the body to recover. All -IIt and no rest is an equation for overtraining.

Comment edited on: 10/24/2012 7:22:52 PM

Report Inappropriate Comment
VHALKYRIE 10/24/2012 4:23PM

    Great point, SalonKitty! The research I did on carb cycling didn't mention exercise, so I'm kinda fitting this in with some of my fitness goals. I think you are on to something, though, that perhaps I should sync up my high intensity days with higher carb. Thanks for the thought!

Comment edited on: 10/24/2012 4:24:16 PM

Report Inappropriate Comment
SALONKITTY 10/24/2012 4:18PM

    I think it's a good idea to give this a try, Vhalkyrie...what I am curious about is if the no/low/high carb days should be somehow sync'd up with the types of workouts you're doing...did you find any info suggesting that, or does it not matter?

Report Inappropriate Comment

Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

Log in to post a comment.

Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.