SparkPeople advertisers help keep the site free! Learn more


    CRYSTALJEM   19,642
SparkPoints
15,000-19,999 SparkPoints
 
 
Too Fit? Really? Hmmmmm.

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

Ok, awhile back I read the following article which is about a gym that has a new (I think) way of attracting customers. They want people to feel comfortable, so long and short, if you become "too" fit you might graduate from that gym eg. not be welcome any longer. OR, you might not be able to join because you're too fit.

www.theglobeandmail.com/
life/the-hot-button/too-fi
t-youre-not-welcome-at-thi
s-gym/article4362979/


Now, I found this an interesting concept and like most things, I recognized that this idea had both good points and bad points. I'm still now sure how I feel about the concept truthfully.

So, I thought I'd pose some questions (which I've posed to others before) in a blog format and see what others think about this. Good idea? Bad idea? Somewhere in between? Silly? Sensible?

Here goes:

* What do you think about gyms where membership criteria is based on weight and physical condition? In other words, you have to be At LEAST a certain amount overweight and out of shape. The idea of course is to attract people who are "shy".

* How would you feel about the possibility of your membership not being renewed if you subsequently lost an amount of weight and reached a fitness level that would no longer make you eligible for membership. You would now be considered "too" fit and too close to or at "goal weight".

* Do you think basing membership on this type of criteria is beneficial for and will get more unfit, overweight people involved in gyms to get healthy, or is the strategy flawed?

On similar topics, but not directly related to the article:

* What are your thoughts on gym memberships based on sex - men only or women only. Would you prefer or even consider being a member of a female only gym?

* If you had unlimited resources (or at least close enough), what's your dream gym - how would you run it - or would you forget the gym and have a personal trainer in your own gym?

Ok, there's your food for thought today - and the good news - it's all 0 calories.

I'm feeling better... but still looking for my happy. Know I left it around here somewhere!

CJ

emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon emoticon
SHARE
  Member Comments About This Blog Post:

KALIGIRL 8/29/2012 8:30AM

    Interesting idea - and as with life, when you 'solve' a problem, you 'create' another one - the question is which is worse...

Hope you find your emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
_LINDA 8/29/2012 2:04AM

    Having been a member of the all women Curves, I must say I enjoyed that, but wouldn't make it a requirement for a gym. I can really see the idea of making a gym for overweight people - a lot are intimidated by going into a place and seeing all the spandex thin people. I have only one or two obese people in all the classes I attend -considering how many are out there, its a very low percentage. Even the low impact class has only one obese female. So there must be something keeping them away. That idea may work. I would see a gym and classes geared towards beginners to fitness. Then, as they get better in shape, they would outgrow the need for this style of gym and perhaps graduate to a regular gym when they find it no longer challenging, so it wouldn't be a matter of refusing their membership, they would be willing to move on.
I don't mind a Co ed gym and classes at all -in fact one of my classes is half male. What I don't like is children in a place, especially when it comes to the pool and hot tub. I have had water aerobics classes where the kids and their playing, splashing, etc. disturb the classes. I especially hate them splashing around and playing with their toys in the hot tub when you are trying to relax after a hard workout. So adults only for me...
Hoping you find your happy! You can do it! Think of the gorgeous bonus of hot weather we are having!!
emoticon emoticon emoticon
Walking on Sunshine theme for today!

Report Inappropriate Comment
WATERMELLEN 8/28/2012 6:47PM

    I really love my gym, the Y where I've been a member for 30+ years. It's a bit shabby (but clean); it has all the equipment I need for cardio, ST and stretch plus several pools; it's not intimidating, serves people of all ages and types (and provides free/subsidized memberships for people who need that); and I have friends and acquaintances there who go back a long long way. Wouldn't change a thing, especially not the outstanding staff/fitness coaches!

Report Inappropriate Comment
PATTYKLAVER 8/28/2012 1:06PM

    My dream gym would make everyone feel welcome, have different levels of classes and equipment, definitely have a supervised room for kids, ...oh I could dream on and on. It definitely got me thinking.

Report Inappropriate Comment
JEWELY_ROADS 8/28/2012 12:02PM

    My dream gym?... Well, it would probably be the new fangled, warm salt water pool that I can't afford to goto right now... And I'd prefer a smaller more intimate facility vs large and impersonal... I could have my own pool but, then I'd be isolated, not good either. Then, I may want a few buddies to get outside with for other activities, within my physical limitations.

Now regarding specific criteria for joining a gym? Why not, if it helps to get people out of their house and socializing with others. I have had gym experiences that sucked, being around super fit people while I struggled, or feeling self-conscious in work-out clothes, being gawked at by guys... Can be a drag... I've also gone to a Ladies only gym, I liked it, but overall I personally wasn't into the gym scene regardless. For me I need fitness to be part of my lifestyle, like bike riding around the countryside or swimming at the park, walking, hiking. I've given up on sculpting my body, I'm very content with being at a healthy BMI and fitting my clothes better. I don't need the six pack! LOL, I guess my age is showing. I've tried many yoga classes too, but it's not for me, I'm not a good pretzel. Oh well... emoticon emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment

Add Your Comment to the Blog Post


Log in to post a comment.