Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

    LADYIRISH317   73,910
60,000-79,999 SparkPoints

My new treasure

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

First of all, I owe a huge thanks to all the wonderful Sparkers who supported me the last couple of days. Everyone is right, I am NOT going to let a self-righteous sourpuss drag me down.

Today I received the Hope Diamond. All right, not really. I got my copy of Good Eats: The Early Years. It's gorgeous -- so many pictures, a lot of liner notes, tons of photos, all the recipes from the shows AND recipes that were never on TV. I skimmed through it every spare second I could get (the package came to my office), and I plan to sit down and read it like a novel. I seriously can't wait to get the other two volumes and his other books. Alton is giving Bobby a serious run for my attention lately.

But it raises an old conundrum for me. The book is SO beautiful! I find myself afraid to crack the binding or damage the pages. I almost want to keep it like a museum piece. But is that what a cookbook is for? In the foreward Alton talks about his favorite cookbook (The Frugal Gourmet). He says his copy is dogeared, stained and about to fall apart. And he totally loves it. So I'm asking myself -- is a cookbook more beautiful in its pristine state from the dealer? Or with a binding cracked from use, a stain of broth on this page, a splotch of butter on that? I'm asking myself if the real beauty isn't what I do with it, not the book itself.

I have a nagging feeling I know what Alton would say if I could ask him.

Member Comments About This Blog Post:
SHARON10002 8/21/2012 6:29PM

    My favorite cookbook, The Joy of Cooking, has it's binding all broken and unglued, pages falling out, and cooking/baking stains all over the cover and all throughout it. That's how a good cookbook should be. Well used and loved. Now I use a cookbook holder which does help keep my newer ones a little cleaner. emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
THINRONNA 8/20/2012 3:19AM

    Oh you gotta use your cookbook! That is what they are for. Simple. I even write notes in mine...sometimes with small changes I have made, conversions or thoughts on the item. I think they become more treasured with use...they become truly "yours".

Report Inappropriate Comment
MRS_TOAD 8/17/2012 8:06AM

    Use it and enjoy every moment! It is one of your greatest passions and joy! emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
MONETRUBY 8/15/2012 9:27PM

    Yes, you do know what Alton would say-use the darn thing until it falls apart! It is a sign of your love of his work, and your love of cooking, if it falls apart and becomes stained from years of use. Don't make yourself feel guilty for enjoying and using your new new treasure!

Report Inappropriate Comment
POETLKNG2LOSE 8/15/2012 8:37PM

    Go ahead and cook to your heart's content. You can always modify the recipes that are higher in fat or calories. That is what we try to do unless we have to cut too much then we don't make it. For instance this one Betty Crocker Recipe had a chocolate cake that was over 1.000 calories for 1 piece. The calories came from all the chocolate that was in it plus the butter and other stuff.

Report Inappropriate Comment
RAINBOWFALLS 8/15/2012 7:49PM

    I wore one cookbook out so badly that my son found the same one and gave it tome for Christmas one year.

Report Inappropriate Comment
CARRAND 8/15/2012 6:08PM

    Use the book and enjoy it! Books are meant to be read.

Report Inappropriate Comment
MISSKELEBEK 8/15/2012 5:31PM

    "binding cracked from use, a stain of broth on this page, a splotch of butter on that"

That's how I remember which recipes are the best in the book emoticon Don't be afraid to use your new cookbook .

Report Inappropriate Comment
WESTIEGAL1 8/15/2012 4:57PM

    Definitely use the book, just like your pots and pans and other appliances. Their beauty will shine through in the food that you make. They were made for you to use them! emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
CAROLJEAN64 8/15/2012 4:22PM

    I took my mother's cookbooks after she died and my sister-in-law wondered why. She said, "The bindings are broken, some pages are loose and many stained." Those are exactly the reasons I wanted those books. They have the recipe, badly stained from the chocolate cake that was Mom's specialty and the first thing I ever baked. Each page is a memory.

Report Inappropriate Comment
BECKYSRN 8/15/2012 3:48PM

    My favorite cookbook has pages falling out and cooking/baking stains all over it. That's how a good cookbook should use.
If you keep yours as a museum piece, then all it will do is make you ask 'what might have been?'
Happy cooking!

Report Inappropriate Comment
LITTLEWIND53 8/15/2012 3:26PM

    I agree with what everyone else has said. A pristine book is a boring book and what is the use of a cookbook if you don't use it......


Report Inappropriate Comment
REACHING4HOME 8/15/2012 1:30PM


Report Inappropriate Comment
CHEFSOPHIE 8/15/2012 1:21PM

    I definately vote for using it. A back up could be to find the ones you want to try and see if they are also on line, and if so print them off for when you are cooking.

Report Inappropriate Comment
LIS193 8/15/2012 10:49AM

    Have fun using your new cookbook! What is the point of it keeping it pristine rather than using it? Cook some great dishes and enjoy!

Report Inappropriate Comment
MPARKER67 8/15/2012 10:11AM

    I would rather see a used cookbook. To me, it means there are many good recipes in it. If it looks unused I would feel the recipes aren't worth making.

Report Inappropriate Comment
JAMARIGOLD 8/15/2012 9:54AM

    If I went into a kitchen and saw pristine cookbooks and a well worn cookbook, I'd be more interested in seeing the worn book because it would be obvious it was loved! I'm sure Alton would rather see it in that condition. Enjoy it fully!! emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
1CRAZYDOG 8/15/2012 9:02AM

    USE that cookbook! You know, I am obsessed with the 1953 version of Betty Crockers Picture Cook Book. It's the cookbook my Mom had. Then I found one for myself when I got married 23 yrs. ago. It got very dogeared . .. I mean duct tape on the spine of the book so it wouldn't fall apart! THEN about 5 yrs. ago or so the cook book was reprinted in binder edition, and I got that. So, if all else fails, buy one as a "spare!" Sounds squirrley, but they's how I handled it!

I have so many cook books and just saw Alton's book @ Costco. Am going for it today! LOVE it. He intrigues me because he's the only one who really explaing the science behind the recipes. I love that.

Enjoy your book! And, of course, Good Eats!

Report Inappropriate Comment
BIGPAWSUP 8/15/2012 8:50AM

    I'm not a cook, but I do have my dog training books. My favorites look like I gave them to the dogs for toys. The sign of a good book is in it's tattered pages. Make it a loved book.


Report Inappropriate Comment
IAMFRANSGIRL 8/15/2012 7:51AM

    My favorites are all dogeared and written in like my sketchbooks. The notes about who liked this or that and such are as lovely as the illustrations, stories and recipes themselves. My mother would be horrified, but heck, they're my books and my memories. I say it's more important what you do with your cook books than what they look like.
p.s am totally envious of your Hope Diamond...

Report Inappropriate Comment
NUTRON3 8/15/2012 7:46AM

    Enjoy it!

Report Inappropriate Comment
GINNJEN1974 8/15/2012 7:14AM

    Yeah I think Alton would say hop in and cook some Good Eats! If the book shows some wear over the years it just shows how important it is to you.

Report Inappropriate Comment
FERRETLOVER1 8/15/2012 7:12AM

    Knock your socks off and USE THAT COOKBOOK! Life is too short not to. Go for it!!

Report Inappropriate Comment
SPIRIT42013 8/15/2012 3:16AM

    Well, you could rob a bank and get 2 copies!?! emoticon

Report Inappropriate Comment
GLAMNGLOWDIVA 8/15/2012 2:58AM

    Use it and enjoy. You should see my cookbook from Giada, post-it notes, comments and all in there. It is well used. Have fun making something.

Report Inappropriate Comment
WINDSONG~ 8/15/2012 2:38AM

    Use it to its fullest!
I use to watch the Frugal Gourmet!

Report Inappropriate Comment
BLUE42DOWN 8/15/2012 12:50AM

    I missed the furor, but am glad so many others were available to reassure and support you.

To me the most beautiful cookbooks are the ones with notes along the edges, a smudge or smear on the pages of favorite recipes. A book that is sterile and untouched may look pretty on the outside, but for all intents and purposes it might as well be empty on the inside.

We don't buy books for the binding or the condition of the pages. We buy them for the text and images on those pages and how we will use them. With a novel that is becoming involved in the characters and story. With a cookbook that is finding and following a recipe.

Report Inappropriate Comment
FRENCHMARKET 8/15/2012 12:38AM

    I agree with what Alton would say!!! A pristine cookbook is like a home that is just a showplace!!!

Report Inappropriate Comment

Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

Log in to post a comment.

Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.

Other Entries by LADYIRISH317