Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

    4A-HEALTHY-BMI   47,887
40,000-49,999 SparkPoints

Learning Maintenance: Levels

Wednesday, August 01, 2012

I believe maintenance can be learned. Iíve been at this now for over two and half years, and I seem to be getting better at it. Hereís one way of looking at my progress, based on the number on the scale. See the bottom of this post for a link about how I frame my progress in terms of mental phases.

There are various levels of maintenance. You can define weight maintenance in many ways.

I have several nested weight-based definitions Iíve been using.

1) Keeping off at least 10% of my original weight (under 302 lbs)
Iíve managed this since January 2010. This is the broadest definition I use when Iím talking about my overall maintenance path since losing the weight in 2009. Iíve been within this definition consistently since January 2010.

2) Keeping under 160 lbs, with attention paid to body composition.
This was my original goal, since at this weight my BMI is under 25. I removed the emphasis on BMI in order to be consistent with my more recent philosophy that any BMI under 30 can be considered ďhealthyĒ (since BMI doesnít account for muscle mass or bone weight). I like how I look and feel here. When I am above 160 itís usually because I have more fat on me.

Iíve been inside and outside of this range since January 2010. I had a 4-month streak within that range January 2010-April 2010. Then I gained out of this range. I briefly dropped back under 160 in June 2011. Then I regained. I again dropped back under in December 2011 and Iíve managed to stay here for the past 8 months. In two weeks Iíll have managed 9 months here. Iím shooting for a year - that will be an accomplishment, for sure.

3) Keeping within +/- 3% around 150 lbs (145.5 -154.5)
This is the most stringent definition that I use. Itís based on the paper described here:
. Itís also the definition we use for the maintenance challenges in the At Goal and Maintaining Team
My central goal weight has slowly dropped. At first it was 155 (150.4-159.7), then it was 152.5 (147.9-157.1), and now itís 150. Iíve discovered that I can do more stuff in my kayak at a smaller size, so thatís where I like to be. As with the previous definition, if I weigh more than this range itís usually because I have more fat on me.

So far I havenít yet managed to stay within my chosen +/- 3% weight range during one of our team maintenance challenges. I keep trying, though, and I think Iím getting better at doing it. We just started a new one this month, and Iím going to do my best to hang in there for the next 12 weeks. Part of the reason I run these challenges is to give myself the accountability and motivation to keep working at it.

The good news is that I am getting better at staying within a goal weight range, with less and less fluctuation. There are people on the At Goal and Maintaining team who consistently manage this, so I know itís possible. And since I am getting better at it, I think itís reasonable to assume that if I keep working at it, one day I can be one of them, too.

Perhaps in a couple of years Iíll discover I like life better at a higher weight or a lower one, or maybe Iíll have found a more accurate way to assess body composition and that will become how I gauge maintenance. But for now, watching the scale and my % body fat and my athletic performance suffices.

(Update and clarification; I DO track my body composition, and here is a post explaining how:

Here is a related blog post about learning maintenance, framing it in terms of mental phases:

Member Comments About This Blog Post:
WATERMELLEN 5/29/2013 11:02PM

    Like you, I believe maintenance can be learned. And has to be learned. And then has to be relearned . . . ! (Which is not the same as yo-yoing . . .because we are changing up techniques to stay within our chosen maintenance range).

Thanks, Anja, for all of this collected wisdom on the Big Page of Links.

Really enjoyed the article about the pain and shame of regaining too.

Report Inappropriate Comment
LOGOULD 10/17/2012 11:15PM

    Still working on figuring out where my final goal weight range will end up, but more important to me right now is consistently staying within a range.

Report Inappropriate Comment
CELIAMINER 8/22/2012 9:18AM

    I like the progressive definitions of maintenance. As for staying within the +/- 3 pounds, I think it is easier post menopause, when hormonal fluctuations don't produce a 5-pound water weight gain every month.

Report Inappropriate Comment
KAYOTIC 8/4/2012 12:38PM

    I think it's good idea to keep an open mind about the final goal range. I've adjusted mine up and down over the past few years, currently I use 135 as my goal point, and go for the 3% above and below that, and it's been working very well.

I'm bummed I missed the first week of the latest challenge, I think I was looking for an e-mail, I might have missed it, but I was also on vacation, so that may have been the culprit! I'll be eagerly awaiting the next one though, as I found the last few challenges to be really great in helping me stay in my range (and figure out what that range is!)

Report Inappropriate Comment
4A-HEALTHY-BMI 8/2/2012 1:57AM

No one at the YMCA was willing to do caliper measurements for me. I have a system using averaged BIA numbers:

Report Inappropriate Comment
LBLYKOWSKI 8/2/2012 1:17AM

    I like tracking my body composition by having my gym measure my body fat. They take measurements using a little metal pincher in a few places (for women its belly, hip and back of arm). It's fairly accurate compared to what by doctor has done previously. Check it out.

Report Inappropriate Comment
MYSTERY-LADY1 8/1/2012 9:22PM

    emoticon Thanks

Report Inappropriate Comment

Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

Log in to post a comment.

Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.