Hey there Pookie. How can I check your food tracker to see how you are doing this? I typically do the lower carb thing, and have switched to calorie counting. Needless to say,it has given me carb bloat as I call it. Thanks!
well i've been eating between 100 - 120 grams of carbs per day and today is the first day i think i will eat the recommended 1200 calories, i think once i have been doing this for a while i will get into the swing of things, thanks for all the feedback :)
Not all low carb diets are a fad - I eat low carb because I have PCOS, so the max amount of carbs I eat per day is 100-140g...and that's a high! If I do eat carbs it's 100% whole grain...otherwise all carbs are in the form of fruits and veggies. It took some getting used to, but now it's second nature. I eat lots of salads, fajitas without the tortilla, tacos without the chips (I just make a salad), tuna or salmon salad without the bread...etc. etc. Basically whatever I want...just without the starch added to it. If I stray from this diet I gain weight very quickly and it makes losing weight even more difficult.
On another note...1200 calories a day is the minimum calories you should be consuming. And yes, if you consume less than this your weight loss will slow down tremendously. :)
Similar issue with me only because I'm gluten-intolerant. I don't have wicked symptoms, but my doctor and I have talked about avoiding gluten as best I can because it can get worse. That pretty much means no bread, crackers or other handy carbs. I still cheat, but getting the carb numbers up usually comes from milk and fruit. I'm still trying to balance it all out, but I do think you need some!
Actually, the reason the older group talks about reducing carbs (bread, potatoes etc) has to do with trends in diabetes education and not dieting. Controlling their "starch" was the primary message of diabetes education when the focus was on four food groups. In the early 1990's the Food Pyramid hit the scene and exploded the Basic Four and made carbohydrates the focus and so was born the war against them.
8/18/10 11:59 A
Funny - any older person I have ever asked about weight loss has never included a low carb advice. It was always about portion control - just eat less... In fact, the proliferation of diet books themselves is a relatively recent phenomenon
low-carb diets are actually the way everybody used to lose weight before the low-fat fad that's been going on for the last couple decades. ask any older person that hasn't been indoctrinated by low-fat how to lose some weight and they'll tell you to eat less bread (whole wheat and processed), potatoes, and sugar. low-carb! that's how tons of diet books went back in the old days.
low calories on low carb is so easy because carbs can stimulate the appetite. just make sure you keep your fats and protein up. you can make chicken curries over cauliflower that has been grated to have a texture like rice. a veggie omelet is good too, chock full of spinach and peppers and mushrooms.
We would encourage a controlled carbohydrate approach compared to "low carb" which doesn't have a foundation for amount. That term is what sets people off many times because of arbitrary carbohydrates numbers that don't have any foundation in ratio to total caloric intake.
Let me give an example. In the hospital setting, doctors routinely order 1800 calorie diabetic diets for people that are admitted with diabetes. They pull that number out without knowing if the person is 100 pounds or 300 pounds. The ratio ratio of carbohydrates and need by the body are very different based on body size and type and there isn't a one size fits all approach.
If your Spark plan suggests 1200 calories and you are following a 100 gram carbohydrate diet - that is about 30% of your calories (which is a little lower than recommended level of 40%). That is very different than someone that has a calculated need for 2000 calories and only consumes 100 grams of carbohydrates which only provides 20%.
Carbohydrates are the body's ideal fuel for most functions. They supply the body with the energy needed for the muscles, brain and central nervous system. In fact, the human brain depends exclusively on carbohydrates for its energy.
We certainly agree that carbohydrates from fruits, vegetables, beans, dairy products, foods made from whole grain products are favorable over those that include sweeteners such as sugar, honey, molasses, and corn syrup.
We encourage everyone to use those nutrient rich carbohydrate sources to include enough carbohydrate that is no less than 40% of your total calories recommended to ensure your body has all the energy it needs to reach the goals you have set.
8/18/10 7:57 A
Pookie, it's totally a fad, and a bourgeois one at that. What do you call a low-carb China, India, or Eastern Europe? Famine.
Sure, there have always been hunter-gatherer societies, but it's no accident that they occur near the equator in lush environments with low populations and a lot of edible wildlife.
Anyway, to the OP, there's no need to worry about carbs as long as you're within your ranges. I usually can't meet my daily minimum in carbs, though, probably because I rarely eat anything with added sugar. I eat one piece of fruit a day, a ton of veggies, only 1 slice of bread most days (a half-sandwich at lunch), and 1 cup of rice or pasta at dinner.
Fitness Minutes: (86,575)
8/18/10 7:24 A
MissArrow.... low carb isnt a fad... unless you count a fad as being something thats been around as long as humans have been.
Fitness Minutes: (86,575)
8/18/10 7:22 A
I eat under 100g carbs and over 100g protein a day.
I was eating at 1200 (just moving into maintainance now)
If you want to do this you need to have your carbs from fruit/veg/unprocessed grains... things like pasta/bread have way too many calories/carbs to fit in eating this low.
Its perfectly doable and I was perfectly happy at it.
Why not look over my food tracker for a few weeks back *laughs* ignoring the days I have eaten out recently!
8/18/10 7:22 A
The low-carb thing is just a fad. Are you going over your recommended carb range for the day?
I've been told so many things about carbs its hard to know whats right, I've been eating whole wheat instead of white so i think what i am doing is along the right track, if i don't eat 1200 calories a day is it true that your body stores fat because you aren't getting enough energy?
Fitness Minutes: (1,706)
151 8/17/10 11:40 P
Try for low processed carbs, not low carb in general. This means, instead of white, processed foods, aim for whole wheat and whole grains, which keep you full longer and don't spike your blood sugar.
hey everyone, I've only just started counting calories and carbs and all the rest of it, firstly i'm finding it quite hard to eat 1200 calories a day and finding it even harder to eat low carbs, if anyone has some helpful tips it would be greatly appreciated :)
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved. No portion of this website can be used without the permission of SparkPeople or its authorized affiliates.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.