Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   Diet and Nutrition
TOPIC:  

Which one should I focus on?



Click here to read our frequently asked Diet and Nutrition questions.

 
 
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
      Share
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top


RUSSELL_40
Posts: 16,826
9/16/13 1:27 P

I only do walking, and sometimes swim, play basketball or bike leisurely. Basketball is my only real strenuous exercise. I tend to exercise longer, but not as hard. Some of my friends find it good to work out very hard for 15-30 minutes a day, and mix up what they do. I don't see any reason to exercise very hard, for long periods of time. That just makes people hungry, and they eat more, which means that they are just exercising, but eating the calories back, so net, not that much of a negative calorie balance.

I started out not really able to work out very much, because of my heart issues, so the decision was out of my hands. So I focused on diet. I started walking to my mailbox, which exhausted me, and as I dropped weight, I exercised more. Now I do 45-75 minutes a day. I don't go torture myself in the gym, instead choosing to "play " away my calories.

I put in 1750 calories ( 250 a day) burnt for the week, and got a range from SP. As my weight has dropped, I just cut down little by little on the calories. I don't eat extra if I play basketball, instead of walk today. I just eat the same, and know I burned an extra 200 calories.

If you are losing 1-2 lbs a week, and eating 20000 calories for example, there is no reason to eat 2300 if you burned 1300. Just stick with your average calories eaten. We all have times when we feel awesome, and burn more, but then follow it up with a week we don't feel like waking up to go exercise. It averages out. Look at the average calories in the weeks you lost weight like you wanted, and stick close to that.

At a certain point, you don't need to burn any extra calories. I walk 45 minutes most days. I could easily walk 60, but it takes me about 45 minutes to walk the 1.5 mile path along the river. I could do it twice, and get 90 minutes, but why? If you have been exercising for a while, you should just pick an activity that burns a certain amount of calories, and that you enjoy doing, and do it 4-7 times a week. That way your calories burned doesn't change, and what you have to eat stays around the same.

I wake up, walk 45 minutes, and eat about 1800 calories a day. No math problems to factor out. This is your life, not some chore to figure out. Make it simple. Eat in range, and exercise a certain amount, and as long as you lose 1-2 lbs. , just relax, and enjoy the success.

In the end, a healthy weight will lead to exercise. If you feel like you are pushing yourself too hard, you probably are. So by focusing on weight loss, you will increase, and be focusing on, exercise. They aren't exclusive. Diet will help with weight loss, and exercise will make you healthier cardiovascular-ly. I think you are wondering about exercise as a weight loss tool, and it isn't a real good one. Burn whatever you need to get the cardiovascular benefits, but not extra.



DIETITIANBECKY
Posts: 26,573
9/15/13 3:16 P

Unless you are doing an intense amount of exercise each and every day---you probably do not need to "eat back" those calories. In fact, for some---it stalls weight loss.

If you are hungry--then eat a little more. However, if you are satisfied--then don't feel you "must" eat back more.

Becky
your SP Registered Dietitian



SINCERELYSHERYL
SparkPoints: (3,353)
Fitness Minutes: (10,347)
Posts: 5
9/15/13 1:47 P

Most important for me.. I want to get healthy.. But of course I want to lose weight also. I have been syncing my fitbit flex with sparkpeople but I never use the fitbit site. I prefer sparkpeople.. I love how the fitbit adds my calories burned etc. but then my calorie range changes. Should I focus more on staying within my range as it changes due to activity or should I be aiming to reach my 1000 calorie deficit? Most times if I get within my calorie range after it adjusts with my fitbit then my deficit never makes it to 1000 and if I reach my deficit I'm a few hundred calories from my new minimum calorie range. Technically I'm going in the right direction (down) but this past week I worked hard to hit 1000 calorie deficit and only lost 1 lb. I'm still happy with that pound, don't get me wrong. I would just like to ask what you focus on..



 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  



Share


 
Diet Resources: foods that destress | destress activities | destress gifts
x Lose 10 Pounds by October 30! Get a FREE Personalized Plan