Fitness Minutes: (42,794)
1,843 10/2/12 2:01 P
The diuretic qualities of tea and coffee are grossly overrated. I haven't drank soda for years (I drink tea, coffee, fruit juice, and water), and I can say that yes, tea or coffee work just fine for hydration purposes. Any liquid does count. If you're trying to limit caffeine intake, you should opt for decaf or lower-caf options like green or white teas, but otherwise, drink on.
Everything "counts" in that all fluids will hydrate your body and each 8oz glass of something wet will provide the same hydration as 8oz of water.
However, some people might choose that for them personally, they want to drink 8 glasses of "only water", and not "count" their other fluid intakes towards that. That is a personal choice and more power to anyone choosing that!
It's just not true though that there's any "rule" as to what counts and what doesn't. If you want to make up your own rules for you personally, go nuts. But "fluid" is "water". All fluids. There are no rules. :)
Deb, in New Zealand
Fitness Minutes: (26,983)
873 10/1/12 4:46 P
I count my unsweetened black tea as water. Even though there's some caffeine in there, it's not nearly as much as coffee or soda, and I know there are many who count those as well. Several dietitian friends of mine have said it counts...
There's no reason not to count caffeine-containing drinks. As Unident has already mentioned, ALL drinks count. Doesn't matter if they have flavor, color, sugar, sweetener, caffeine, whatever...they ALL COUNT.
Medical researcher for 25 years. Trying to find help for the obesity epidemic.
Fitness Minutes: (0)
39 10/1/12 12:36 P
I've also heard that this is a good rule: count water and herbal tea, but nothing with caffein.
Green tea is the area this confuses me, as it does contain caffein, just lower levels than black tea. Would you normally count it given it's other beneficial health effects?
Fitness Minutes: (1,441)
10/1/12 10:04 A
I count herbal tea, but I don't count caffeinated beverages. I also don't count soda since although it's liquid, it's still a bunch of sugar. I usually have no problem drinking plenty of water.
Rebecca, Married to Andre "Go confidently in the direction of your dreams. Live the life you have imagined." --Henry David Thoreau
Fitness Minutes: (1,238)
53 10/1/12 9:13 A
I purchased 2 identical water bottles. I made sure they were dishwasher safe and that they have the oz.'s marked on them. Each bottle holds 32 oz. I fill one with regular water and the other with green tea. ( I like to experiment with the tea so usually brew green with a flavored tea such as cranberry, blueberry, or raspberry. ) At the end of the day each bottle should be empty. If so, then I know for sure that I got at least 8 - 8oz. glasses of water in for the day.
Taking Baby steps daily will = Giant positive results.
Fitness Minutes: (175,490)
4,090 10/1/12 5:32 A
I drink over ten cups of tea a day. Some plain water, some coffee - but I DO count my tea as water.
�Keep on asking, and you will receive what you ask for. Keep on seeking, and you will find. Keep on knocking, and the door will be opened to you� (Matthew 7:7, NLT)
All fluids are "water" including tea, coffee, milk, juice, sodas and even energy drinks. You should limit caffeines, energy drinks and sodas for other reaons, and juice and milk do come loaded with calories, but yes everything "fluid" is "water".
Deb, in New Zealand
Fitness Minutes: (59,214)
3,458 9/30/12 11:29 P
all liquid counts according to my RD
Fitness Minutes: (1,306)
9/30/12 10:15 P
So having adopted a more old-school typical chinese diet (and by diet I mean what I eat, it's actually a lifestyle change) I've been consuming quite a bit of green tea inbetween meals. My question is, given that I add nothing to it (I actually like it unsweetened) can I count it as water? It's basically just herbally flavored water anyhow.
"Life is all about choices. I can make choices in line with my goals or choices that oppose them, but in the end the choice is mine. I CHOOSE to take an ACTIVE role in my health, for I am the master of my life and have a vision for what I shall become. Every day I work hard to bring this vision into existence. So it is and so it shall be!"
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.