Fitness Minutes: (106,442)
3,981 12/4/12 4:17 A
I am a runner and used a heart rate monitor and also six other estatmite to estimate my calorie burn. These were all within about 10 to 15%. The estimate of errors in the estimates is typically larger than this difference, that suggests that statistically there is no difference or very little difference.
Outside of a lab there is not way to get a very accurate estimate of calories burned. In my heart rate forumal I included a personal factor that allowed you to adjust the estimate. I decreased my estimate by 10% and had a friend who increased herss by 10%. We each did this to reflect what we experienced in the real world (that is weight loss, etc)
Edited Dec 4 2012.
I thought I would be more explicit that In my opinion a heart rate monitor is not really much better than all the rest. In fact, my friend and I adjusted the results from heart rate monitor caclulations by 20% (me down 10% and her up 10%) to make a reliable match between the estimates of the heart rate monitor and the real world results. So yes, heart rate monitors are slightly better and are in fact the best we can do outside a lab, however they are still not much more than a ball park 10-20%. 100 calories reported by a heart rate monitor should be considered somewhere between 90 and 110 calories at best.
So even the heart rate monitor is only a guestimate.
Edited by: PAPAMIKIE at: 12/4/2012 (10:47)
Good running and be Careful out there
Popie Certified Chi Running and Chi Walking Instructor
You can't know. The most likely to be closest to accurate is the one that uses your height and weight in figuring out the burn. Personally, in order to keep from overestimating, I'd go with the lower, or enter the middle ground manually. You might try another site and see which it is closer to as well. I like caloriesperhour.com. If you don't use a HRM, any internet tool is just a guesstimate.
I am 5'4". Starting Weight (4.6.11) 164.6 First Goal 130 - Reached September 2011 Currently maintaining under 120 and working on changing my mental image of myself!
Fitness Minutes: (703)
103 12/3/12 3:18 P
How do you find out which calories burned is right? I used Free Tool that shows calories website and they are different from SparkPeople. How do you know which to use?
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.