Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Message Boards
FORUM:   Diet and Nutrition


Click here to read our frequently asked Diet and Nutrition questions.

Search the
Message Boards:
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top

Posts: 9
7/30/13 3:21 P

Thank you all so much for your input. I think I WILL bring it back. It's just not worth the risk!

Posts: 12,406
7/30/13 11:13 A

There are no effects on the kids YET. If you're close to this family, be sure you advocate for them as they get older. If they come down with strange cancers as adults, or if their children have birth defects, let their doctors know that they used this as children. It could make a difference in their treatment, and they and their mom probably won't even think of mentioning it because it seemed normal.

Posts: 4,947
7/30/13 11:11 A

Here is a link to the NIH database of information that might help with the specific name brand safety concerns.

Coach Tanya

Posts: 467
7/30/13 11:05 A

I know a fren who uses spiriluna frequently. When I asked her, she claimed that it has a high protein content. She even used the powder form to mix with milk and feed her babies from birth all the way to a year. There wasn't any side effects or whatever health problems with the kids. They are fine young children now. Having said that, all I know about spiriluna is from this fren and I know nothing more than that.

Posts: 12,406
7/30/13 10:51 A

Nobody knows if it's safe. A big part of the problem is that it's sold as a supplement, not a food, so the manufacturers don't have to verify that they're getting it from a clean, safe source. They could be skimming it off the waste pond at an abandoned chemical plant for all you know. It's known to absorb and concentrate a lot of contaminants, so even if the water is safe to drink, the algae can still be dangerous.

Why did you think you wanted it? It has been shown INeffective for weight loss. It provides iron and B vitamins, but so do a lot of foods that are known to be safe. The only thing it's been tested for that turned out to have even a hint of possibility is that it *might* have a teeny-tiny protective effect against mouth cancer for people who chew tobacco. Not for smokers, though. If you're not vegan and don't chew, there's absolutely no reason you would need spirulina. If you are vegan, there are still safer sources of iron and B vitamins (and if you do chew, you could just quit...)

It's definitely NOT considered safe during pregnancy or for children, mainly because there's no way to know what contaminants it has picked up from the water it has grown in.

My advice is to take it back and get a refund. Just tell them what you told us-- you read the label and it scares you. If you bought it at a reputable place, they'll give you your money back even if you opened the jar. If they won't give you your money back, then you know they're not a reputable place that cares about your safety, and hopefully you'll stop going there.

Posts: 9
7/30/13 10:33 A

Has anyone every used Spirulina powder? I bought some the other day, but I read the jar it scared me... it said something about it may cause birth defects. Does anyone know if this is safe?

Page: 1 of (1)  


Diet Resources: low protein intake | dietary protein intake | daily recommended intake of protein
x Lose 10 Pounds by November 1! Get a FREE Personalized Plan