I like them as snacks or for on the run. I think shakes are a good supplement.
Fitness Minutes: (2,872)
106 11/10/13 10:20 P
Thank you everyone for your responses. They made me feel much more comfortable. about using already-prepared meal-replacement drinks. I suppose I meant by "shrinking my stomach muscle" was getting more in touch with my real hunger/appetite. But, I always thought that if you ate large quantities of food your stomach muscle expaned and you needed more to fill it--sort of like a balloon. I've noticed in the two weeks that I've been eating healthier, I'm eating much smaller portions than I used to.
I looked at the nutrition info for the Special K shake. This is not a protein shake; rather this is a meal replacement shake. And this is what you need to be using since you are replacing meals. A meal replacement shake has the correct blend of protein, fat and carbs---similar to a meal (not just primarily protein). In the Special K shake you are getting 190 calories, 10 grams protein; but also 5 grams fat, 29 carbs, and vitamins, minerals, fiber.
A meal replacement shake like this is fine to use; especially when you are using it due to a time schedule crunch. It is really just a way to control calories in a portion control size.
As JENNILACEY mentioned, be sure that if you're using any kind of shake instead of a meal, that it says it's intended for that purpose. Otherwise, you're depriving your body of vital nutrients.
I drink an Atkins shake every morning because I take a lot of Rxs and supplements, and I need something thicker than water to get those down. That seems to be okay - and I am mindful about it, because if I get hungry, I will eat real food. Some days I do want solid food food for b'fast, so I don't do the shake on those mornings.
When you say "shrink your stomach muscle" -- do you mean reducing your stomach volume capacity? Eating less or smaller meals will eventually result in a smaller stomach (organ). It won't do anything about increased belly/abdominal contour though, at least until that changes due to overall weight loss. You can't pinpoint a specific place to diet fat out of.
I think using nutritional drinks as meals is probably okay, so long as they're labeled for it. But be sure to still eat a good "real" meal every day, and monitor how you're feeling. If you start to lose energy, you know perhaps you need to eat more real food.
Edited by: EXOTEC at: 11/10/2013 (19:56)
Fitness Minutes: (75,770)
2,489 11/10/13 7:35 P
If they are actual meal replacements I'm sure they'll be ok. Of course it's always healthier, more beneficial to learning how to eat for weight management and I imagine more satisfying to eat real food. I'm not quite sure I understand why you would want to "shrink your stomach muscle"? Or where you heard that drinking protein shakes/meal replacements would do that?
Fitness Minutes: (2,872)
106 11/10/13 6:18 P
Prior to starting Spark Coach, I had been drinking protein drinks (Special K, Equate meal replacement protein drink, South Beach, etc.) to help me shrink my stomach muscle and cut back on my appetitel I really like them for breakfast and for lunch because I have an incredibly busy job and find it difficult to do a sit-down lunch. Is it a problem to continue with them, rather than eating food for lunch and breakfast?
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.