Author: Sorting Last Post on Top Message:
DIETITIANBECKY Posts: 26,699
7/27/13 5:31 P

There have been several recent studies published on this topic.
Check out several from PubMed:

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=mifflin+
st+jeor%2C+harris+bennedict%2C+obesity
%2C+accuracy


Becky
SP Registered Dietitian

ANARIE Posts: 12,487
7/27/13 1:02 P

That's not surprising. The formulas weren't really made for obese people. They were developed using "average" healthy people, and just assume that every pound of body weight uses the same number of calories. As far as I know, nobody has done any work in finding out how to calculate metabolic rates for the pounds above a healthy weight.

SIMONEKP Posts: 2,561
7/27/13 12:25 P

Thought I would add an update. Got the test done this morning RMR is 1550 and I'm mostly sedentary so daily calorie need is 1860 approx. My measured RMR is lower than the results from the 4 most popular estimation formulas by a good bit, difference in ( ).

Katch- 1639 (89)
Cunningham 1792 (242)
Mifflin 1753 (203)
Harris-B 1813 (263)

As you can see, Katch was the closest and is the method that will probably be best for me to use on a monthly basis (I measure body composition monthly) to determine my calorie range. I will probably get the actual test done in another 6-12 months depending on how much weight I lose over that time and how much my body composition changes.

DIETITIANBECKY Posts: 26,699
7/26/13 7:13 P

Less body fat and more muscle mass can increase your metabolism.
This is why SP recommends cardio exercises but also strength training (resistance exercises) too.

Becky

ANNA19821982 SparkPoints: (1,007)
Fitness Minutes: (0)
Posts: 79
7/26/13 8:25 A

My metabolic is very low, what can I do to get my metabolic high

CHERIMOOSE Posts: 391
7/25/13 4:33 P

I had it done a while back, but i didn't compare it to the formulas, sorry.
I did find it more useful to use an accurate calorie tracker device (BodyBugg, Bodmedia), which take into account activity level too, not just RMR. Good ones are over 90% accurate.

SIMONEKP Posts: 2,561
7/25/13 2:29 P

Thanks Sunshine, did you have the test done? If so, I'm asking whether you saw a variance compared to using the Harris-Benedict, Mifflin St Jeor, Katch-McArdle or Cunningham formulas for calculating BMR. And if so, how much of a variance. I am not asking about variance between different individuals.

SUNSHINE6442 Posts: 1,901
7/25/13 2:15 P

A personís RMR is the amount of calories the body burns throughout the day in order to function properly...daily activities and exercise are not included in the results so results I assume would vary...

Knowing your RMR will help you decide what your calorie intake should be...and you should receive your results and an explanation from a registered dietitian following the procedure.

Just make sure you do not eat, exercise, drink caffeinated beverages for 4 hours before the test, but I am sure you were already told that.

SIMONEKP Posts: 2,561
7/25/13 1:05 P

Decided to get my RMR tested. I am scheduled for Saturday morning, they will be using the Medgem machine. Has anyone else had this done? How did the results measure up the common estimates?

Page: 1 of (1)  




Other Diet and Nutrition Topics:

Topics: Last Post:
Canned Fruit - Nutritional Information 10/9/2013 4:02:44 PM
Eating healthy at the county fair 9/3/2013 2:31:31 PM
Diet Advice 12/23/2013 11:07:37 PM
Vitamins 10/9/2013 8:52:09 AM
cravings 10/12/2013 10:33:15 AM

Diet Resources: strained forearm muscle | what is bursitis | bursitis trochanteric