Author: Sorting Last Post on Top Message:
BABYDOLL0205 Posts: 2,588
1/14/11 5:52 P

I don't have any of their DVD's but would love to get them. I like them both, but have to be in the mood. I prefer my runs & weight training with my music, they can be a bit too intense for me.

KITKA82 Posts: 670
1/14/11 12:40 P

I like both. In comparing Jillian's No More Trouble Zones to Jackie's Total Body Circuit (which are both strength training, and about 40 min long), I would say I have a slight preference for Jackie's workout. It moves faster for me. With NMTZ I get a good workout and am sore, but I get bored. With Total Body, I feel like I've been kicked repeatedly in the abs... lol!

"Commit to the LORD whatever you do, and your plans will succeed."

Proverbs 16:3
KOWGIRLUP SparkPoints: (5,235)
Fitness Minutes: (2,831)
Posts: 12
12/1/10 12:54 A

MAMA2DOSGIRLS SparkPoints: (0)
Fitness Minutes: (0)
Posts: 1
11/30/10 9:56 P

The funny thing is is that Jillian Michaels and Jackie Warner co-own Sky Sport and Spa. (That you see in Jackie's show). They are very good friends in real life :)

BWT123 Posts: 14
11/26/10 11:35 P

Never tried Jillian. Love Jackie!! I noticed a big difference in my body with Jackie's circuit training DVD in just a short amount of time.

AMOHAME2 Posts: 1,557
11/26/10 2:28 P

I find I get a better workout with Jillian, but I turn to Jackie when I just can't handle Jillian's screaming.

AHURD80 Posts: 2,665
11/25/10 3:19 P

Jillian's my girl!

MICHELEBOISE Posts: 1,325
11/24/10 4:16 P

I will have to check out Jackie Warner!! I think I need to have a home workout arsenal!!

MSPRIS3 Posts: 521
11/24/10 4:07 P

I started with 30DS and BFBM, then just recently purchased Jackie Warners Xtreeme Timesaver Training.

I tried JW's Monday for the first time, did it again today, even though I'm still sore from Monday's workout. I think I like this one better, it's a bit longer, but I'm sore everywhere, I was never really sore with Jillian's DVD's.

But, both are good, will continue with JW's and do 30DS on those days I'm short on time

A dog is one of the remaining reasons why some people can be persuaded to go for a walk. ~O.A. Battista

If your dog is fat, you are not getting enough exercise. ~Author Unknown
TISTEN23 SparkPoints: (26,284)
Fitness Minutes: (25,260)
Posts: 1,237
10/4/10 12:10 P

I like them both, but Jillian (in my opinion) is a better trainer. Jackie is great, but she doesnt do circut as well...

~*~*Kristen*~*~
FIFFINA SparkPoints: (0)
Fitness Minutes: (21,730)
Posts: 311
10/4/10 11:08 A

I agree with KISS04BAM in every single word! I also started as Jillianīs fan and I fan-atically followed any new DVD she made. I will always like her NMTZ, and BFBM, although a little less than the first mentioned. I was never that much a fan of 30DS, it is just boring for me and too short, but the other ones are great. That said I recently found Jackie and she is now my number one, I am really sorry she hasnīt more DVDīs. Power Circuit is my favourite, I also like One on one Training, but Power Circuit - first time it was pure hell, then I got used to it and I like it more and more, great moves and the abs part - I love it. But I also do agree that these two girlsī workouts are similar in many aspects, and they make a great rotation, I like exercicing with Jillian one day and with Jackie another.

SPARKVAMPY2012 Posts: 2,510
10/4/10 10:47 A

I agree with KASSAY25.
I will always be a loyal Jillian fan. I have had great results with No More Trouble Zones. But I did start out with 30 Day Shred before hand.
I recently started doing Jackie's Power Circuit Training and I actually look forward to doing that workout.
Jillians 30 Day Shred is good for someone just starting out or trying to get back into doing workouts.
Currently I still do Jillians workouts 30DS & NMTZ but not as often as I do Jackies.
After I did Jackies the first time I was sore for 2 days.
All the above workouts are great! And any or all would be great for someone looking to lose weight if you stick with it consistently.
My favorites so far are Jillians NMTZ and Jackies Power Circuit Training. They are both similar but different in their own way.
All these workouts are On Demand (Exercise Tv)for Free so you can try them out before you purchase them.

Edited by: SPARKVAMPY2012 at: 10/4/2010 (10:49)
-Name: Devon
-Pennsylvania
-Goal Weight: 120-110
KASSAY25 Posts: 3,218
10/4/10 10:33 A

I prefer Jackie Warner dvd's. They are more lengthy and really concentrate more on each part of your body. Not only that but she really teaches you how to get the most out of your moves. Also, i see more results! I just love how she breaks up your abs into 3-4 different sections. I remember the first time i did her total circuit workout, the next day my abs were sore in places they had never been before. LOVE HER!!

718GEMINI Posts: 471
10/4/10 10:11 A

I agree, Jackie's workout is definitely more intense stregth training. 30 Day Shred is a great, short workout.

LEMONS25 Posts: 146
10/3/10 10:38 P

i have the shred and jackie warner power circuit. both are good. jackie's for me is a bit more intense (i do the 40 min workout). i tend to use the shred when i am short on time. i alternate between these two videos and turbo jam.

"Your body is the baggage you must carry through life. The more excess the baggage, the shorter the trip."
- Arnold H. Glasgow
CASSYCHAOS Posts: 180
10/3/10 8:52 P

I've recently bought Jillian's 30 Day Shred, and Jackie's Personal Training DVD.

Has anyone used these before? Who do you prefer?

Peace, Love, and Respect
Page: 1 of (1)  




Other Fitness and Exercise Topics:

Topics: Last Post:
Opinions on the Arm Bikes 4/7/2014 12:48:20 PM
I lost it! 3/27/2014 4:53:54 AM
Suspicions confirmed 4/29/2014 2:21:02 PM
I think I'm broken.... 4/15/2014 3:53:11 PM
Getting Fitted for Shoes 7/29/2014 9:04:07 AM