Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Message Boards
FORUM:   Diet and Nutrition

Inches or weight?

Click here to read our frequently asked Diet and Nutrition questions.

Search the
Message Boards:
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top

SparkPoints: (13,603)
Fitness Minutes: (18,534)
Posts: 734
4/2/13 5:43 P

Watching inches makes me happier. I've been three different sizes at the same weight, so I know it's more about body composition for me than how much I weigh.

SparkPoints: (65,036)
Fitness Minutes: (35,097)
Posts: 2,166
4/2/13 5:26 P

Inches... Make sure you are not bloated when you take the measurements. If you can use a skinfold calipers, far better (won't matter if you are bloated or not).

Scale can motivate, but more often than not, it frustrates, especially over the short term. So I dropped the scale totally. Now I go by inches lost and body fat % as determined by skinfold caliper measurements.

Posts: 739
4/2/13 1:20 P

loss of inches=small cuter clothes

SparkPoints: (3,439)
Fitness Minutes: (1,708)
Posts: 214
4/2/13 1:16 P

I do both. Inches lets me fit into smaller clothes. Weight is the only thing my doctor cares about so I need to care about it too.

SparkPoints: (210,962)
Fitness Minutes: (87,276)
Posts: 11,556
4/2/13 8:36 A

I usually measure weight rather than inches but I put on a pair of shorts from last year and they are way too big. woohoo!

SparkPoints: (152,835)
Fitness Minutes: (152,709)
Posts: 10,003
4/2/13 8:31 A

Both because you may be losing one and not the other and it's nice to see a change someone to maintain motivation. However, I know weight isn't always a good indicator of size because muscle may be more compact but it may make you look heavier on a scale than you truly are.

SparkPoints: (73,649)
Fitness Minutes: (51,612)
Posts: 3,488
4/2/13 7:28 A

I like losing inches more than weight. To me, inches mean a smaller clothing size and that my body is getting more compact. Pounds just reflect the Earth's gravitational pull.

SparkPoints: (81,825)
Fitness Minutes: (35,522)
Posts: 36,184
4/2/13 6:18 A


SparkPoints: (16,107)
Fitness Minutes: (14,455)
Posts: 415
4/1/13 10:55 P

for me it`s weight

SparkPoints: (6,880)
Fitness Minutes: (9,038)
Posts: 142
4/1/13 10:45 P

I track both. Losing inches is a change that people can see and that you can see in your clothes fitting looser/better. Losing weight is something that only you can see when you step on the scale.

Posts: 26,543
4/1/13 7:43 P

It is important to track both; for both show postive change and can be motivating that you are moving in the right direction.

From what you are sharing---right now you are losing body fat and gaining muscle mass. Therefore the scale is reporting the same number. Since muscle takes up less space in the body (than does fat), you are noticing smaller body measurements.

SP Registered Dietitian Nutritionist Becky

SparkPoints: (522)
Fitness Minutes: (1,071)
Posts: 10
4/1/13 7:36 P

Is it better to lose inches or better to lose weight? Right now I'm having the worst time trying to drop the lbs. but it seems like I'm able to lose inches.

Page: 1 of (1)  


Diet Resources: always feel full | feel full after eating | never feel full