Author: Sorting Last Post on Top Message:
GLOSAK Posts: 4
11/28/12 1:12 P

After I'd lost about 20 pounds some people commented. But I expect people noticed before then. People have to be sure they're not going to offend you before they'll say anything. The real issue is: do you notice yourself.

CATMAGNET SparkPoints: (38,973)
Fitness Minutes: (51,134)
Posts: 1,183
11/28/12 12:39 P

I think I lost about 20 pounds before anyone really noticed, but I honestly can't remember.

Jane

Camp Good Grief 5k 2012 - 31:50
Gobble Wobble 5k 2012 - 30:00
Turkey Trot 4 Mile Race 2012 - 38:38
Ugly Sweater 5k Fun Run 2012 - 27:19
Move-It Memphis 10K 2013 - 55:36
Germantown Half Marathon - 2:08:53
FedEx St. Jude Classic Fairway 5k - 4/13/2013
Pittsburgh Half-Marathon - 5/5/2013
SCHEALTHNUTT SparkPoints: (48,770)
Fitness Minutes: (24,210)
Posts: 1,913
11/28/12 12:17 P

I dont think any one has noticed yet!! emoticon

SKINNYMISSKASEY SparkPoints: (114,114)
Fitness Minutes: (176,425)
Posts: 3,941
11/28/12 11:44 A

30lbs

GRIZ1GIRL SparkPoints: (139,889)
Fitness Minutes: (180,469)
Posts: 2,241
11/28/12 11:43 A

Took about 40 lbs before anyone noticed....that's what happens when I was REALLY FAT...I had to lose a lot before it made a difference!

It Is What It Is.... :)
LOLATURTLE Posts: 372
11/28/12 11:20 A

A friend (who did know that I was losing weight and that I had started running) was telling me she could tell I'd lost and my shape was changing after 15 pounds or so.

About 30 pounds down, a very sweet coworker who I like very much crept up behind me and said "you're shrinking away to nothing!" I wasn't expecting it so I think I was just like "...me?" (there was no one else in the office, it was like 7:30pm, hahaha) but I wasn't offended, just surprised.

My work pants are super baggy so I'm guessing people will either start to notice that, or will notice when I get new pants that fit, all "hey, you're smaller!" but they may or may not comment, depends on the person.

CREICHEL Posts: 106
11/28/12 11:06 A

About 30 pounds

CREICHEL Posts: 106
11/28/12 11:06 A

About 30 pounds

ANDREAG89 SparkPoints: (27,445)
Fitness Minutes: (21,210)
Posts: 552
11/28/12 10:33 A

Before "others" outside of my family noticed, half of the weight I intend to lose was when a few have noticed - that is 27 pounds of the 54 lb goal.

I think the more we have to lose the less noticeable it is until a good amount of it is gone.

AndreaG89
-----------
"There are only two options: Make progress or make excuses."



MANDYLEW24 SparkPoints: (33,025)
Fitness Minutes: (17,650)
Posts: 756
11/28/12 9:44 A

Initially it was 20 lbs before anyone mentioned anything. I've been at the same weight for about a year and recently lost 6 lbs. and a lot of people noticed. I'm not sure how I feel about that. haha

JOBINKY Posts: 4
11/28/12 9:33 A

I work with very supportive people. Although I didn't notice any change until about 20lbs were gone, my coworkers started mentioning my weight loss after 10. They sure make it worth the effort. I am now at 180 and started at 240. Hard work and still a work in progress, but getting there.

MRSALLYP SparkPoints: (20,854)
Fitness Minutes: (59,080)
Posts: 147
11/28/12 8:56 A

my first 12lbs were very noticeable as I was gaining muscle at the same time and clothes were also getting to be too big on me - it was amazing how quickly it took effect (I think it was around 8--10 weeks in!)

SOFLODEB Posts: 7
11/28/12 8:54 A

I plan to lose around 100 lbs. Hubby noticed after about 15, as well as my close co-workers. I am not down 28 lbs, more than 25% of what I hope to lose, and no one else has noticed, or if they have, they haven't mentioned it yet.

Deb in South Florida
ASHLEYGILLE SparkPoints: (12,195)
Fitness Minutes: (2,227)
Posts: 1,722
11/28/12 8:33 A

When I was at my highest (161 pounds), people really started commenting after I lost 30 pounds. This time, my SW being 130, people started noticing not too long ago, when I got to about 115 pounds. Now I'm just about at goal (I'm short, so my goal weight is 110, which is what my doc recommends for me). Maintenance is going to be the really tough part for me as it's so easy to let the weight creep back on. Thank goodness for SP! I think beiing a part of this community, whether I'm doing well or struggling majorly, I'm much more apt to get back on track and stick to my goals. Thanks to all!

Striving to maintain!
JENNILACEY SparkPoints: (80,279)
Fitness Minutes: (85,382)
Posts: 2,489
11/28/12 7:14 A

My husband and my mom noticed after my first 10 lbs. I didn't!


Take your focus off the Marshmallow.

www.leangains.com/2010/01/marshmallo
w-test.html


"Toning" is marketing muscles to women who are afraid if they pick up a barbell, they'll leave the gym looking like She-Hulk. It doesn't happen, what does happen is you get results. Lifting Barbie weights does nothing but waste time.
TRYINGHARD54 Posts: 4,734
11/28/12 5:51 A

havent got to that point yet.. so no one noticed..lol. but im working on it

I CAN DO THIS
JDMAKEIT2HOT Posts: 8,458
11/28/12 5:51 A

The people I didn't chat with about my weight noticed after 68 pounds! emoticon

JD

*sparking since june 2007


FISHERESS68 SparkPoints: (5,831)
Fitness Minutes: (1,043)
Posts: 130
11/28/12 2:51 A

I THINK IT WAS 10LBS, MY FACE THINNED OUT RIGHT AWAY

I WANT TO SUCCEED, I NEED TO SUCCEED, I WILL SUCCEED
AWIBS57 Posts: 2
11/28/12 2:00 A

Around the 20-25 lb mark everyone I know started talking about it. At that point it was clearly not just a fluctuation. People started congratulating me and asking my advice. That's also about when I got in range of a normal, healthy BMI.

I lost 30 lbs total last year, then gained about 10 of it back, and have re-lost about 7 of those. I vacillate in the 25-30 lbs down from what I was two years ago range. Now that everyone knows it's okay to talk to me about it, they seem more willing to comment on little differences to try to be encouraging.

ANYANP2 SparkPoints: (2,357)
Fitness Minutes: (762)
Posts: 44
11/27/12 11:57 P

about 5kgs

Its not what you do.... Its how you do it...
NEWBIEBAIT SparkPoints: (13,877)
Fitness Minutes: (15,671)
Posts: 157
11/27/12 10:32 P

No one says anything when I lose weight, only when I gain it. When I gained the first 20lbs from my pregnancy every one talked behind my back that I was getting fat again and I looked so awful and blah blah. I kept the pregnancy a secret as long as I could and just let them keep talking. They are all overweight as well so I'm sure when I lose weight it kind of burns them.

"Well I guess if a person never quit when the going got tough, they wouldn't have anything to regret for the rest of their life." -Lance Armstrong in Dodgeball
(I still love you, Lance!!!)


"Sucking at something is the first step to being kinda good at it." -Adventure Time
LADYFROMTHEWOOD Posts: 3,138
11/27/12 10:22 P

I think most ppl notice long before they'll comment. Some feel it's rude or would be uncomfortable talking about something so personal. Others won't comment b/c they worry about awkwardness if you gain the weight back! Some won't comment b/c they are a little jealous. Others just don't know how to give a compliment about weight loss. It seems to them like they would be saying "you were so fat before now!" KWIM?

I think this is why we have to learn to be our own cheerleaders in the beginning. It's a great tool to be able to cheer yourself on when no one else seems to notice. I think it may even be necessary if we're going to keep going for the long haul.

Let me say... I think you're doing GREAT! emoticon

The real contest is always between what you've done and what you're capable of doing. You measure yourself against yourself and nobody else.

Pots are formed from clay, but the empty space within it is the essence of the pot.

Like energy and true love, the imprint of beauty through the retina on the soul is permanent.
STEPHEN_NANNY SparkPoints: (10,496)
Fitness Minutes: (16,232)
Posts: 385
11/27/12 7:38 P

When I lost the first 15 lbs, my friends and family were telling me I looked half my weight LOL...that was about 70 lbs ago. It was very encouraging. I feel really really bad for people who lose much more than that but don't have people say anything or don't notice, because I would find that difficult...I will reluctantly admit to some vanity and finding the comments of others to be a motivator for me.

If you bring forth that which is within you, that which is within you will save you. If you do not bring forth that which is within you, that which you do not bring forth will destroy you.
BLUENOSE63 SparkPoints: (107,996)
Fitness Minutes: (82,255)
Posts: 2,954
11/27/12 7:07 P

About 15 but if you want the truth, it was the inches coming off that people noticed not the pouindage so much

LCRUMLEY81 SparkPoints: (77,502)
Fitness Minutes: (13,575)
Posts: 862
11/27/12 7:06 P

no one has noticed yet

AZULVIOLETA6 SparkPoints: (66,733)
Fitness Minutes: (74,443)
Posts: 3,293
11/27/12 6:35 P

People seem to notice/re-notice about every ten pounds with me.

What's really fun is to run into people that you haven't seen in a year or more and for them to tell you that you look terrific! I've heard this from people I barely know (like a lady who used to do my hair, a cashier at a yarn shop, an old dance companion) so it must be true. :)

In any case, it feels *great.*

Dances: salsa (standard/LA), casino, rueda de casino, cumbia Colombiana, cumba Mexicana, bachata, mambo, cha-cha-chá, merengue, reggaetón.

Dances to Learn in the future: flamenco, tango Argentino, samba, belly dancing, bhangra, danzón, Cuban rumba, ballroom rumba
SDLEE514 SparkPoints: (18,291)
Fitness Minutes: (22,648)
Posts: 317
11/27/12 3:36 P

Given my petite size I shouldn't loose more than 10-15 pounds, and I have lost 10 pounds. My sister noticed over thanksgiving, but my own boyfriend and other friends/family don't see a difference and/or haven't said anything. I noticed it in myself after about 8 pounds.

WENWASHING67 Posts: 356
11/27/12 2:31 P

I lost 30 lbs after my divorce. When I started going out in "public" again, my old friends noticed that I had lost the weight.

MICHELLEGEORGE1 Posts: 103
11/27/12 2:26 P

For me it was around 30lbs - I had lost and gained the same 20lbs so many times over the last 10 years that I think everyone in my life just expected me to put it back on again. Once I got past that and it was evident that I had finally figured out this healthy lifestyle change, everyone seemed to notice at once! I've lost a total of 61lbs now and I get comments on the loss almost every day. I think the best compliment that people can pay me when they haven't seen me in a long time is that they say they didn't recognize me. The best thing about those compliments is that they are highly motivational... it keeps me on track and helps me plough forward!

Remember... nothing tastes as good as thin feels! :)
EBELLA9 SparkPoints: (1,074)
Fitness Minutes: (599)
Posts: 4
11/27/12 2:23 P

At around 15 lbs, my boyfriend started noticing. then at 20lbs people I don't see as often were noticing.

JENNN77 SparkPoints: (86,926)
Fitness Minutes: (42,964)
Posts: 653
11/27/12 1:47 P

It was over 20lbs before anybody said anything. And the first person to say something was my mostly blind grandmother! She can only see shapes, but I was still wearing big clothes (though they were baggy). It was months before anybody at work said something. My brother & his wife (I only see a few times a year) have never said anything and a friend I saw once a week didn't notice until we didn't see each other for a month. A lot of people aren't very observant or just don't mention it. Also, if they see you all the time and you are gradually losing weight, they may not really notice until you start wearing slimmer styled clothing.

EMMELINEE3 SparkPoints: (4,863)
Fitness Minutes: (2,437)
Posts: 118
11/27/12 1:24 P

Ms. Kathleen I saw on your post, "If you change your mind you can change your body, and ultimately change your life" ( I agree with that, well stated.)

F.R.O.G. Faithfully Rely On God!!!
NOMIE322 SparkPoints: (21,413)
Fitness Minutes: (33,381)
Posts: 144
11/27/12 11:46 A

For me it was about 30lbs. No one noticed (or said anything) before and then all at once everyone started to notice and comment. It was very strange at first.

THINSTEAD Posts: 33
11/27/12 11:35 A

I read somewhere that your close friends and family notice first, and it may take acquaintances and coworkers longer. Like 30 lbs. It definitely took close to 30 for me before people said anything. I've lost 55 total now and I feel better than I have in 20 years : )

If you change your mind, you can change your body, and ultimately change your life~
ELIZABETH2464 Posts: 22
11/27/12 11:17 A

Around the 15 lb mark - it's one of the most effective motivators for me!

Life isn't a dress rehearsal. Live your show today!
JICKEE Posts: 411
11/27/12 10:56 A

30 to 40 lbs

SIRENSONGS SparkPoints: (57,040)
Fitness Minutes: (28,206)
Posts: 2,002
11/27/12 10:54 A

I'd say maybe at around 20 lbs lost. Of course, some people still haven't noticed, and I've lost more than 70 lbs now. Go figure!

LEB0401 Posts: 301
11/27/12 10:52 A

For me it was 10lbs.

I'm thinking it'll be harder for people to notice your weight loss during colder months since we're all bundled up under layers. You should wear a form fitting sweaterdress to a holiday gathering and the complitments will start to pour in!

Laura
27
Fredericksburg, VA
SHELAGHB Posts: 13
11/27/12 10:14 A

I think 15lbs was about when people started to notice. With that said, I've received more compliments in the past month when my body fat percentage change yet the scale didn't move much.

Body fat % is a much better indicator of visual and physical success. They scale doesn't always tell the whole story. For example, rapid weight loss often is a combination of fat and muscle loss. :( Without proper balance of exercise and nutrition you could actually be setting yourself back. I personally think the investment in a once per month Bod Pod is a better measure.

ADIOSALL Posts: 5,197
11/27/12 10:10 A

I didn't give anyone time to notice. I was shouting it from the rooftops!

RASIRE Posts: 284
11/27/12 10:05 A

I was just over 15 lbs down when people began to comment/notice. emoticon

;-)
BABIRD1 Posts: 258
11/27/12 10:02 A

Actually, none. My flab started firming up and my muscles got stronger, so the scale had stayed about the same at the time I got a couple of comments about looking good. You have no idea how much people take notice of "muffin top" in particular.

ELISAJANE57 Posts: 742
11/27/12 10:02 A

I was 30 pounds overweight when I started and people noticed around 15 pounds lost.

Is it wrong to fight time, to turn it back or push it forward? Time was never mine.
JMOUSE99 SparkPoints: (129,204)
Fitness Minutes: (82,242)
Posts: 5,126
11/27/12 9:59 A

It took more than 20 lbs down before anyone noticed. I think it's because the weight loss is so gradual rather than unhealthily fast.

Lenore (Vancouver, Canada)

Bronze Wellness Warrior - BLC27 & BLC28
Winds of Change Lodge - Camp WannabeFit 2015
Amber Amazon Warrior - BLC21 to BLC26

Shared pain is lessened. Shared joy is increased. Thus we refute entropy.
- Spider Robinson

What fits your busy schedule better: exercising 1 hour a day or being dead 24 hours a day?
- Glasbergen

People who don't like cats were probably mice in an earlier life.
CMCOLE Posts: 2,667
11/27/12 9:29 A

not sure.

five to ten percent of total - I believe

JOYFULME01 Posts: 610
11/27/12 9:28 A

My daughters-in-law noticed after 5 pounds or so. I'm down 40 pounds and my husband of 30 years still hasn't commented.

ALICIALYNNE Posts: 1,654
11/27/12 9:25 A

My now-husband noticed within about 5 pounds, as well as my mother and sister (I think because I was more diligent with my muscle work; even though I didn't lose much at that time, I did look a little different). For others, it took about 15 lbs.

I do absolutely think it is more about percentage of weight versus the actual number of pounds. 15 pounds for me was 7.6% lost. 15 pounds for someone weighting 250 is only 6%. 7.6% would probably be more noticeable.

St. Leo's 5k: 3/17/12 51:07
FCLEMF 5K: 4/28/12 50:45 (CORRECTING TYPO- HAD IT AS 40 INSTEAD OF 50!)
Race for the Cure 5k: 5/5/12 61:51
St. Leo's 10k: 3/16/13 1:34:44 PR for mile pace!
St. Leo's 10k: 3/21/15 1:42:57

Goal: Run 1 mile straight! 4/24/12
Goal: Run 1 mile in 15 minutes! 8/22/12

Consistently drink 8 cups of water per day.

120 minutes of exercise per week.
GINNABOOTS Posts: 6,504
11/27/12 9:07 A

I would say about 15 pounds.

GLITTERFAIRY77 Posts: 8,023
11/27/12 8:54 A

Because I have so much to lose, the last time I lost a lot of weight, it took about 40lbs for people to start to notice.

MamiSheli53 is my MOM!!!

Abi~Rochester, NY

Aim for progress...NOT perfection.

Starting weight July 2012: 310
(dates of accomplishment for the following to come)
GW1: 280 passed 2/8/13-278!
GW2: 250
GW3: 220
GW4: 200
GW5: 175

I can do ALLLLLL things through Christ who strengthens me.


"It's a long, hard climb-but I'm gonna get there."

"If you stay focused on the past, you will never be able to see what lies ahead."
LISAN0415 SparkPoints: (8,749)
Fitness Minutes: (1,353)
Posts: 1,600
11/27/12 8:41 A

Hi there!

I was wondering for those on the weight loss journey or those at goal weight, How much weight did you lose before someone noticed? Was it more a perecentage of your total weight or just a certain number of pounds, or a size?

I have lost about 17 lbs and no one has notied yet, I am hoping by the end of December if I stay on track and lose 5-7 more lbs, they will see a difference. I know I have seen a difference.

Lisa

Page: 4 of (4)   « First Page ‹ Previous Page 2 3 4




Other SparkPeople Cafe Topics:

Topics: Last Post:
Eating healthy on a budget 6/21/2014 5:25:35 PM
Dressing sexier now that you're thinner? 3/10/2014 8:44:48 PM
That ONE habit that irks you. 4/25/2014 11:40:34 AM
Coffee, good or bad ? 2/25/2014 12:06:35 PM
recipes 6/12/2014 11:46:29 PM