Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   Fitness and Exercise
TOPIC:  

HRM, Fitbit, or BodyMedia?



Click here to read our frequently asked Fitness and Exercise questions.

 
 
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
      Share
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top


CZARINA_TV
SparkPoints: (71,192)
Fitness Minutes: (118,284)
Posts: 261
7/2/13 10:19 A

I own an HRM and a FitBit Zip. The FitBit monitors my general level of activity. One day I was working at an office that had a big kitchen with cookies downstairs and while I felt like I wasn't very active, I kept going downstairs for snacks and water and I actually got in 10k steps thanks to my sweet tooth and glasses of water. The step count is pretty accurate, but I don't trust the calorie information it gives me. It just keeps me on track in general.

I use my HRM when I'm running or doing another high heart rate activity like Zumba. Everyone puts in a different amount of effort into the same exercise, so and HRM will give you an exact number and show changes over time. You can also use your HRM to exercise within aerobic/anaerobic zones based on your basal heart rates, if that's your thing, but I just like having data that proves how hard I'm working out. I also just find that information interesting -- even when I'm running at the same speed on a treadmill, I can go back and see when my heart rate spiked and have proof that I'm pushing myself. I use a bluetooth HRM that can talk to my phone and I sync that with Endomondo to get graphs. (I wish I could sync it here...) I like that better than having a watch that records the data, since I have a Mac and could never get the data off my Polar HRM.



MEGAPEEJ
Posts: 732
7/1/13 2:27 P

It will depend on what you want it for. I have a Polar HRM because I want to accurately monitor how many calories I burn during cardio exercise. It helps push me to do maybe a couple more minutes on the elliptical because I would rather log 400 calories than 375!

FitBit is good if you want a motivator to get you to walk more during the day. It doesn't measure heartrate so it essentially guesses how much you're burning, all it really knows is whether you're moving or standing still. Good if you stand still too much and need a reminder to move. But in my opinion it's basically an expensive pedometer.



LAURENXX19
Posts: 531
7/1/13 2:12 P

I have been looking into buying a HRM. I was going to buy a Polar model on eBay for $42 when I considered just buying a FitBit or BodyMedia. Does anyone have any insight to these? Or preferences for which model. I liked both the Fitbit One and Flex.



 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  



Share


 
Diet Resources: p90x lean | p90x dvds | p90x price
x Lose 10 Pounds by October 29! Get a FREE Personalized Plan