Author: Sorting Last Post on Top Message:
MJEFFERSON23 SparkPoints: (32,691)
Fitness Minutes: (16,395)
Posts: 1,280
2/5/14 9:18 A

weigh in

MIZKAREN Posts: 48,401
2/5/14 8:56 A


2/5/14 7:41 A

Weigh in every day and tape once a month.

PAULIE91952 Posts: 10,576
2/5/14 7:09 A

Weigh in

BLUENOSE63 SparkPoints: (108,021)
Fitness Minutes: (82,255)
Posts: 2,954
2/5/14 6:59 A

Tape once a week and scale every 3 months.

GEVANS7 SparkPoints: (243,948)
Fitness Minutes: (155,542)
Posts: 2,119
2/4/14 5:19 P

Scale at least once a week and tape once a month

LEONAMINIKA SparkPoints: (8,212)
Fitness Minutes: (2,846)
Posts: 196
2/4/14 5:12 P

usually scale

ANDILH Posts: 1,543
2/4/14 4:29 P

I prefer measuring with a tape. My weight numbers haven't changed that much, but since starting doing Pilates I've gone down 3 pants sizes, 2 shirt sizes, and 3 bra band sizes. Numbers on the scale can vary so much based on the scale, the time of day, etc. that it's much better for my motivation and mental health if I focus more on getting healthy and rehabbing my back (why I started the Pilates) which aids in weight loss, than weight loss specifically.

XHUNTERX Posts: 974
2/4/14 1:52 P

I prefer the scale

PLUGINALONG SparkPoints: (30,258)
Fitness Minutes: (23,761)
Posts: 817
2/4/14 12:19 P

I weigh in as I don't show sufficient inches lost for a long time after I lose.

SPARKLEYSHINE SparkPoints: (29,922)
Fitness Minutes: (4,899)
Posts: 732
2/4/14 12:17 P

Both. They each motivate me for different reasons.

CARTER4414 SparkPoints: (23,329)
Fitness Minutes: (10,460)
Posts: 485
2/4/14 12:06 P

I find it very difficult to get consistent measurements with the tape so I don't trust any progress I see.

VWMOMMY SparkPoints: (9,888)
Fitness Minutes: (5,930)
Posts: 296
2/4/14 12:03 P

I do both. Like someone else mentioned, there are times when the scale seems "stuck" and during those times the measuring tape reminds me that I am doing a lot of things right. I think that if you are doing any significant strength training that the tape measure is probably more important.

2/4/14 11:50 A

Depends on the day. Sometimes I wake up feeling so heavy that I rather use the tape to remind myself of my progress. Other days I wake up feeling so light that I have to step on to the scale and reaffirm my motivated feeling.

2/4/14 11:40 A

Weigh in

WINDANCER99 Posts: 6,801
2/4/14 9:28 A

weigh in

MEXGAL1 SparkPoints: (555,837)
Fitness Minutes: (379,437)
Posts: 16,145
2/4/14 9:19 A


BUD_44 SparkPoints: (40,111)
Fitness Minutes: (46,103)
Posts: 2,040
2/4/14 8:02 A


TRYINGHARD54 Posts: 5,292
2/4/14 7:41 A

weigh in

YESICANYESIWILL SparkPoints: (26,970)
Fitness Minutes: (11,605)
Posts: 2,993
2/4/14 7:09 A

weigh in

TRYINGTOLOSE64 Posts: 91,347
2/4/14 6:56 A

weigh in

NISSANGIRL Posts: 23,747
2/4/14 6:50 A

weigh in

KKKAREN Posts: 12,753
2/4/14 6:23 A

I prefer weighing in, I haven't used a tape in over a year. I need to though because I've noticed my clothes are getting too big, I'm sure I lost some inches.

JEFFGIRL Posts: 10,627
2/4/14 12:33 A


ALLYALLYT Posts: 9,467
2/3/14 11:38 P

weigh in

FENWAYGIRL18 Posts: 5,868
2/3/14 11:20 P


MEXGAL1 SparkPoints: (555,837)
Fitness Minutes: (379,437)
Posts: 16,145
2/1/14 9:36 A

weigh in

ASHLEYAMBER0710 Posts: 244
2/1/14 9:36 A

I would love to do both but I find I am not very proficient in taping. So mostly I just weigh in.

EMPRESSAMQ Posts: 5,077
2/1/14 9:14 A

I use both the scale and my adorable digital tape measure to generate data in my fitness and weight management quest.

Both are useful in their own way, but the scale (for me) is the most reliable measurement of my progress.

Body measurements (and relying on how clothes feel, which I also do) are more subjective and too easy to "game" (sometimes pulling the tape slightly tighter or measuring in a teeny fraction of a different location can skew the result). A good scale that gives an accurate reading gives a solid number to go by, even if it is influenced by a lot of other factors (water weight, weight of food in the system, exercise, time of day, stress, etc.).

So over time, I feel the scale is my best source of data for weight.

Measuring can indicate how well I'm doing fitness wise.

HOLLYM48 Posts: 16,185
2/1/14 9:13 A

I prefer to weigh.

SHERYLDS Posts: 17,137
2/1/14 8:57 A

emoticon with MIFITNOW
a weekly weigh in is immediate feedback...the tape helps you track your exercise progress. Relying just on the tape would make me feel like I wasn't getting anywhere.

MIFITNOW Posts: 2,658
2/1/14 6:38 A

I weigh once a week and measure once a month.

THROOPER62 Posts: 30,595
2/1/14 6:11 A

weigh in

TRYINGTOLOSE64 Posts: 91,347
2/1/14 6:01 A

weigh in

GDANE3 SparkPoints: (215,347)
Fitness Minutes: (166,501)
Posts: 15,376
2/1/14 5:06 A


ROXYCARIN SparkPoints: (95,965)
Fitness Minutes: (82,553)
Posts: 3,996
2/1/14 4:03 A

Weigh in, but use both methods

JANIEWWJD SparkPoints: (502,625)
Fitness Minutes: (324,047)
Posts: 13,705
1/31/14 11:54 P

I do both!!!

HEALTHYGRAMMY49 Posts: 19,046
1/31/14 7:12 P

Definitely weigh-in, but I can also tell by how my clothes fit.

GOALIEGRANDMA3 SparkPoints: (117,833)
Fitness Minutes: (73,802)
Posts: 8,064
1/31/14 6:47 P

I weigh.....I get feedback on results with how my clothes fit

SHKIRK Posts: 1,168
1/31/14 4:56 P

I prefer to wt in I do not trust I am measuring right yet. I do it every now and then around every 20 pounds lost. emoticon

CAMEOSUN SparkPoints: (86,609)
Fitness Minutes: (5,698)
Posts: 10,425
1/31/14 1:16 P

Do both on occasion.

1/31/14 1:08 P

I'd take a tape measure over a scale any day. Infact just the other day I measured and weighed and guess what, my measurements went down a bit and my scale went up a bit!

I also go by how my clothes fit, how I look (I take pictures) and how I feel.

Edited by: JUSTEATREALFOOD at: 1/31/2014 (13:10)
RIVETPA Posts: 1,177
1/31/14 12:16 P

I don't own a tape, so I just go with a weekly weigh-in

BOB5148 SparkPoints: (429,414)
Fitness Minutes: (183,025)
Posts: 14,174
1/31/14 10:52 A

Weigh in

AMANDA660 Posts: 881
1/31/14 10:28 A

Tape! That is best for me.

EMELADE SparkPoints: (1,173)
Fitness Minutes: (431)
Posts: 4
1/31/14 10:14 A

I usually look at the scale, but in reality I know the # on the scale isn't that big of a difference. I go by how I feel, look in the mirror, and how my pants fit.

LOLEMA SparkPoints: (105,894)
Fitness Minutes: (128,714)
Posts: 5,169
1/31/14 10:11 A

Usually tape and clothing and then once in awhile peek on the scale.

RIET69 SparkPoints: (47,087)
Fitness Minutes: (11,285)
Posts: 3,116
1/31/14 10:11 A

Neither, hate both!!

LEC358 SparkPoints: (11,135)
Fitness Minutes: (6,555)
Posts: 2,744
1/31/14 10:07 A

I'm for the measuring tape all the way. The number on the scale, IMO, tells you absolutely nothing about how you look or your body composition which are what people most want to change when they try to become healthier.

TANITHSEH1011 Posts: 217
1/31/14 10:01 A

Persoanlly I prefer to tape over looking at the scale. I think we have been programed to believe that lower number on the scale equal good health when that is just not always true. This is not to say I'm in support of people cartrying a excess of weight because that isn't healthy either however there is a medium.

What do you all think?

Page: 1 of (1)   1

Other SparkPeople Cafe Topics:

Topics: Last Post:
did I "barge in" line at the super market? 7/24/2016 11:31:04 PM
Tomorrow is "me" day! 12/19/2015 4:08:38 PM
A smelly post - I'm talking BO 3/23/2016 2:09:27 AM
Weight loss buddy/penpall 9/30/2015 5:44:47 AM
I feel so hungry 12/21/2015 7:46:30 PM