Well... it's certainly an option to do things that way.
*I* believe that aspartame, which is the sweetener used in nearly every diet soda, is far worse for you than real sugar (even HFCS). If you're going to make another healthy step at some point, to no soda at all, switching to diet now only to get used to it and have to go through another deprivation later on simply doesn't make good sense, to me.
I drink sucralose-sweetened drinks (which is the only sweetener our endocrinologist permits us, including "natural" sugar), such as PowerAde Zero, Mio, and occasionally Kool-Aid (or equivalent) made with sucralose. I've also found a good juice which I can mix with plain seltzer water, and it seems like soda to me: Ocean Spray Diet (not "light"). I drink a LOT of water, too. The combination of sweet with fizziness may help you break your cravings for soda.
Fitness Minutes: (73,463)
3,203 10/2/13 3:01 P
My opinion depends on what the sweetener is (Spenda or Stevia=OK, NutriSweet/Aspartame=BAD) and whether or not your ultimate goal is to get off of it entirely.
If you switch to diet sodas with aspartame, watch out for headaches. NutriSweet is a migraine trigger and it can cause brain swelling in some people.
Even without sugar, sodas are leeching calcium out of your bones and messing with your sense of satiety. I think that any kind of pop should be an "occasional treat" food and not a daily indulgence.
Fitness Minutes: (605)
10 10/2/13 12:18 P
Thanks guys! I was feeling guilty about it now I feel better.
A diet soda or two per day isn't going to hurt you. It may even be really helpful for your weight loss efforts (so long as you don't replace the calories you were getting in the regular sodas with other foods) and I know we can all agree that even a small reduction in weight can be very beneficial.
I agree - I quit diet soda and think its gross but I would heartily support drinking it over regular soda. 5 sodas = 700 calories/day x 7 days = 4900 calories. That is 1.4 pounds per week lost from your diet if you cut it!
Fitness Minutes: (105,516)
13,256 10/2/13 9:22 A
it's a good stepping stone to having one pop (regular or diet) only occasionally and drinking almost entirely water.
I think you're going to get a variety of answers on this one! I will say that I think sometimes people forget that they, themselves, didn't make the switch from other beverages to just water, overnight. At any rate, here's a Spark Article on the topic; www.sparkpeople.com/resource/nutrition_art icles.asp?id=605
IMO, a couple diet sodas are better than 5 regular sodas. Perhaps after you've gotten used to not having all the sugar, you can then switch out the diet soda for water. Nothing says you can't flavor your water, either. I like to squeeze a little lemon or lime into mine sometimes.
Fitness Minutes: (605)
10 10/2/13 8:32 A
I know that diet soda is bad for you and all but is it okay if someone used to drink at least 5 regular sodas a day switch to a couple diet ones a day?
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.