Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

 
Message Boards
FORUM:   Fitness and Exercise
TOPIC:  

Cardio or strength



Click here to read our frequently asked Fitness and Exercise questions.

 
 
Search the
Message Boards:
Search
      Share
Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Author: Message: Sort First Post on Top


BILL60
Posts: 224,361
4/5/13 7:35 P

Both.



GKASHMIRA
Posts: 11
4/5/13 6:33 P

I appreciate your response but as a trainer I am sure you recognize that there is no way lifting heavier weights is ALWAYS better for EVERYONE in every single medical condition. It is simply not true. Again using the same example of pregnancy here is a direct quote from babycenter:

"* Use lighter weights, more reps. To avoid overloading joints already loosened by increased levels of the hormone relaxin during pregnancy, use lighter weights and do more repetitions instead. If you usually do leg presses with 30 pounds for 8 to 12 repetitions, try 15 pounds for 15 to 20 reps. Or if you typically do a chest press with 15 pounds for 8 to 12 reps, try 8 pounds for 15 to 20 reps."

Of course there will be women who lifted way heavier weights pre-pregnancy that can continue lifting heavier weights while pregnant but BEGINNERS probably shouldn't...

Again, for pregnant women the rate of perceived exertion (RPE) is also supposed to only be between a 4-6 (see Sparkpeople's babyfit site article here for a reference: http://babyfit.sparkpeople.com/articles.as
p?id=51&page=1 ). This means you should be able to talk (though not on a cell phone! emoticon )

And these are far from the only websites or medical opinions that tells pregnant women to not to over do it when it comes to exercise.

Just for the record, I do not personally work out this way (light weights) but this is a big community with lots of different people are different stages of fitness and with varying medical concerns and we should respect one another. I just wanted to speak up for anyone who may be reading these posts and feeling bad about the way they exercise -- even though it is right for them.

I hope that this doesn't offend anyone. I mean well!

P.s. The body producing a "copious amount of sweat" is the result of increased body temperature which is the result of calories being burned for fuel for your muscles.

Edited by: GKASHMIRA at: 4/5/2013 (18:38)


SERGEANTMAJOR
Posts: 6,397
4/5/13 12:08 A


I will respectfully disagree with the light weights and high repetitions model for those with medical conditions as the only way they can obtain benefits. medical research with seniors up to age 83 has demonstrated that working with challenging weights is possible and beneficial. The rule is to work within your capabilities using weights which challenge at lower repetitions to improve strength.

Being an automaton for an hour on an elliptical my produce a copious mount of sweat but sweat does not indicate the quality of a workout, it only indicates your body is cooling itself.

Am I being judgmental? Probably but as an experienced trainer and retired chiropractic sports physician who keeps current with the research I give carefully considered opinions



MPLANE37
SparkPoints: (64,429)
Fitness Minutes: (34,077)
Posts: 2,166
4/4/13 9:12 P

I do think cardio is more fun than strength training, because one can totally unwind while doing cardio exercise whereas in challenging strength training, one has to do the opposite, i.e. one has to focus on the lift.

However, in terms of health benefits, I think it would be incorrect to force a comparison. Both are needed, and both help one another when done the right way.

Edited by: MPLANE37 at: 4/4/2013 (21:15)


GKASHMIRA
Posts: 11
4/4/13 9:07 P

Cardio! I love a great, heart-pumping, sweat pouring spin class ;)
I strength train too of course but the only way I'm not bored to tears is listening to music.

Also, I just want to add that it is NOT TRUE that "if you can talk/read/etc you aren't working out hard enough"! Variety is what keeps things interesting both physically and mentally. Sometimes I'm in the mood to get on the elliptical for an hour and read a magazine while I listen to music -- I still come off drenched in sweat and I am quite fit. I CAN talk through these workouts (although I think it's rude to talk on a cell phone in a gym ;) I'm not saying this should be anyone's only way of exercising but every serious training program includes days of moderate intensity.

And some medical conditions have people limited to lifting lighter weights so those people have to do super high reps to get any benefit at all. For example pregnant women aren't supposed to lift a whole lot of weight because of the way the lower back curve actually increases. They obviously aren't building a whole lot of new muscle, but this might be what it takes to not lose the muscles they built pre-pregnancy.

So let's not judge people too harshly.



JUBILANT_SLEEP
SparkPoints: (6,507)
Fitness Minutes: (4,106)
Posts: 239
4/4/13 8:17 P

Well, I love dancing around in my cardio turbo jam videos but the strength ones are awesome because I don't sweat nearly as hard. Sweating is annoying for me because I usually work out in my glasses and they fog up!



TACDGB
Posts: 6,012
4/4/13 7:51 P

If I had to choose I would do weight lifting every time......but cardio is good for your heart and lungs and I do that too..........and will when my ankle heals.



PROUD__MOMMA
SparkPoints: (2,358)
Fitness Minutes: (465)
Posts: 92
4/4/13 5:22 P

Strength for sureeeee.. I need to find more cardio excercises as I find myself getting very bored



ALORTA
SparkPoints: (7,310)
Fitness Minutes: (3,449)
Posts: 310
4/4/13 5:13 P

Strength, unless I'm doing a class.
I get too bored trying to do treadmill, etc for more than a couple minutes (though yes, it feels silly getting on and off within 5 when there are people going at it for 20+ ), so I mostly use it (or the bike, etc) to get my heart rate up and then start on weight machines... with another couple min boost if my HR falls too far



BRONXBABE
SparkPoints: (89,044)
Fitness Minutes: (104,083)
Posts: 2,966
4/4/13 5:08 P

Strength training.



FITWITHIN
SparkPoints: (260,944)
Fitness Minutes: (183,864)
Posts: 19,945
4/4/13 4:30 P

I like them both.



RITACOMPU
SparkPoints: (58,181)
Fitness Minutes: (51,093)
Posts: 2,610
4/4/13 4:05 P

cardio



BUNNYVUNE
Posts: 110
4/4/13 1:30 P

Neither. I prefer flexibility training. It lengthens my muscles and increases my range of motion, so I get the most out of any other workout I do.



STEPH057
Posts: 244
4/4/13 1:13 P

I honestly really like both. With ST, it's always so satisfying when you can lift more weight. And I love my spin class!



JILLWOLVERINE
SparkPoints: (2,183)
Fitness Minutes: (3,503)
Posts: 53
4/4/13 11:42 A

I love strength training, I love the concentration it takes and it's very relaxing and stress reducing for me.

I have a love/hate relationship with cardio. I love a good workout of any kind but I find it hard to get excited about cardio unless it's a fairly new routine that I haven't learned to hate yet. :P



SARIANEC
Posts: 2,994
4/4/13 11:35 A

Strength - easily. I love feeling strong and pushing myself.



MI-ELLKAYBEE
SparkPoints: (144,905)
Fitness Minutes: (127,235)
Posts: 3,919
4/4/13 5:29 A

both -but mostly strength (weights)



SERGEANTMAJOR
Posts: 6,397
4/3/13 8:35 P


Resistance bands are an excellent choice for a strength training programme. If you go to the Spark team Resistance band and bodyweight training you will find information on resistance bnads and how to use them.



SUZE1960
SparkPoints: (44,748)
Fitness Minutes: (53,823)
Posts: 185
4/3/13 7:07 P

both


Online Now
STARFISH1961
SparkPoints: (42,848)
Fitness Minutes: (18,340)
Posts: 2,263
4/3/13 5:59 P

Hey ; I'm confused I've been trying to do cardio a few times a week, usually walking, can get my heartrate up pretty good with that.I want to start using resistance bands, would those be considered strength training ? If not, than what would be, for a beginner ? I only have 2 & 5 lb weights emoticon emoticon

Keep tracking emoticon 1961



GETRESULTSMDMEE
Posts: 1,339
4/3/13 2:41 P

Both work for me but strength really gets my results fast



ERICADURR
Posts: 241
4/3/13 2:37 P

This is definitely true (btw, I LOVEDDDD Crossfit back when I was living in Little Rock)! I always shake my head when I see someone lifting 1-5 lb weights over and over again, tons of times.

Edited by: ERICADURR at: 4/3/2013 (14:38)


BARBANNA
SparkPoints: (96,615)
Fitness Minutes: (74,684)
Posts: 3,189
4/3/13 2:33 P

I love my cardio but I do both every chance I get. My cardio comes first always!



YANKEEANGEL988
SparkPoints: (136)
Fitness Minutes: (80)
Posts: 3
4/3/13 2:22 P

I love cardio! :)



YOU_CALIBAN
SparkPoints: (7,482)
Fitness Minutes: (11,441)
Posts: 488
4/3/13 2:16 P

yeah, erica, same here.

and that is true, crossfit, I just see way fewer who actually lift doing that compared to the tv watchers and magazine readers on the cardio machines



CROSSFITKATE
SparkPoints: (632)
Fitness Minutes: (296)
Posts: 10
4/3/13 2:04 P

You say the same thing for someone who does endless strength training reps with too light of a weight because they "don't want to bulk up" too.



ERICADURR
Posts: 241
4/3/13 1:50 P

Or on their phone the entire time! My motto is that if you can talk, read, or browse your phone, then YOU'RE NOT WORKING HARD ENOUGH! :)



YOU_CALIBAN
SparkPoints: (7,482)
Fitness Minutes: (11,441)
Posts: 488
4/3/13 10:38 A

amen, sergeant. something about reading a magazine on the stationary bike!





KRAFTYKRAFT
SparkPoints: (29,974)
Fitness Minutes: (30,043)
Posts: 1,964
4/3/13 7:58 A

I actually prefer cardio - I find the strength training kind of boring, but I make myself do it because I know it is important



ROKIAS
SparkPoints: (21,243)
Fitness Minutes: (31,979)
Posts: 559
4/3/13 7:03 A

Strength, no question. I get enough cardio included when I'm doing strength, I loath doing pure cardio.



SUZE1960
SparkPoints: (44,748)
Fitness Minutes: (53,823)
Posts: 185
4/2/13 9:11 P

cardio



SERGEANTMAJOR
Posts: 6,397
4/2/13 8:37 P

Since strength training is more productive and has more benefits, including cardio ones, when done properly it is a no brainer for me which to choose. At my age strength training is more critical however recreationaly I cycle, paddle kayaks and backpack.

In my experience as a trainer I have found that many do not do their cardio at the level of demand that a comprehensive strength workout does so they find cardio more appealing.



BILL60
Posts: 224,361
4/2/13 6:38 P

Cardio



RITACOMPU
SparkPoints: (58,181)
Fitness Minutes: (51,093)
Posts: 2,610
4/2/13 5:50 P

cardio



CANDEE412
Posts: 321
4/2/13 5:38 P

cardio today



NOBLEEQUESTRIAN
SparkPoints: (5,092)
Fitness Minutes: (10,066)
Posts: 233
4/2/13 4:39 P

I prefer cardio. I don't do much strength training to be honest. A lot of the activities I take part in include a lot of strength training. For example I'm a dancer so when I dance not only am I performing an aerobic activity but I'm also building muscle (you will notice dancers have a lot of lean muscle). I also ride horses, which is basically a lot of continuous squatting (a proper posting trot is basically pushing your body up with your legs over and over and over again). When I run I work out my core and when I swim I work out my core, arms, and legs.



ICEANGEL0531
Posts: 1,858
4/2/13 4:20 P

Both



FIELDWORKING
SparkPoints: (21,919)
Fitness Minutes: (41,980)
Posts: 601
4/2/13 4:00 P

I prefer cardio to strength training. I do both though.



IRISHFANUH87
Posts: 1,038
4/2/13 12:38 P

I definitely enjoy cardio more....I actually look forward to my dancing or walking workouts. Strength training isn't bad but I wouldn't say I enjoy actually doing it. I do, however, prefer the results I have gotten from adding in strength training!



SOOBIES
SparkPoints: (993)
Fitness Minutes: (1,077)
Posts: 51
4/2/13 11:11 A

Definitely strength. I do love me some cardio as well though. :)

Edited by: SOOBIES at: 4/2/2013 (11:17)


JENSTRESS
Posts: 939
4/2/13 10:03 A

like someone said below, COMBINE the two! I like that!



DIDS70
Posts: 5,070
4/2/13 9:58 A

strength over cardio anyday. Running on a treadmill or elliptical is too boring. I don't like running either. I am not coordinated enough to do dancing.



SIMONEKP
Posts: 2,458
4/2/13 9:47 A

cardio



LEC358
SparkPoints: (8,824)
Fitness Minutes: (6,540)
Posts: 1,968
4/2/13 8:40 A

except when I run long enough to get runners high (awesome btw), strength training is more fun because it makes me feel powerful :D



MLAN613
SparkPoints: (146,138)
Fitness Minutes: (148,983)
Posts: 9,660
4/2/13 8:23 A

Cardio but I participate in group fitness classes to get strength training.



ERICADURR
Posts: 241
4/2/13 8:20 A

Strength, because if done correctly, it also functions as cardio. Someone can be skinny fat only doing cardio--strength training is what transforms your body.



JUSTEATREALFOOD
Posts: 995
4/2/13 8:11 A

Strength for sure!



SWEDIEPIE
Posts: 338
4/2/13 6:53 A

Strength for the charge I get out of it, and I also love the energy I have for the day after a good cardio workout. So both, for different reasons.



BUBBLEJ1
SparkPoints: (21,988)
Fitness Minutes: (20,943)
Posts: 2,801
4/2/13 6:27 A

Strength, every time :)



SCAREWALDORF
SparkPoints: (59,656)
Fitness Minutes: (52,834)
Posts: 2,083
4/2/13 5:09 A

In a balanced exercise program,we do both of course, but I find I much prefer cardio training to strength. Which do you prefer?

emoticon emoticon



 
Page: 1 of (1)  
Search  



Share


 
Diet Resources: pro fitness treadmill | treadmill test | weslo treadmill