Zero Waste? What do you think?
So, yesterday I hauled all my empty bottles, cans, and newspapers off to the local recycling center. It took me three round trips on my bike and about two hours, so I was feeling quite virtuous and proud of myself. Until I got home and ran across this email in my inbox:
Celebrate Zero Waste Day.
According to these people, my valiant efforts may be part of the problem, not part of the solution....
According to the Zero Waste people, the whole idea of recycling is mainly a gimmick perpetrated by manufacturers of soda, beer, juice, and bottled water to get themselves off the hook for providing socially and environmentally responsible packaging and put the burden for dealing with the problem of waste on us consumers. Instead of cooperating with this plan, they say, we should demand that these manufactures go back to putting their products in returnable/reusable bottles, and boycott products that come in plastic and non-reusable bottles.
Personally, I think this argument makes some good points. Recycling is a huge improvement over dumping all this junk into landfills, and we should all be responsible for cleaning up after ourselves. But recycling doesn’t do much to tackle the problems of excess waste and excessive use of non-biodegradable materials at the source of the problem: the manufacturing process. And there are other, proven ways of handling this problem that could accomplish this goal better, like the old reusable bottles with a refundable deposit that all soda and beer used to come in.
But there are drawbacks, too. Prices for these products would probably go up, and it is more work for consumers to schlepp glass bottles around than plastic bottles. And there’s always the question of how effective or appropriate it is for government to legislate how people should handle “lifestyle” problems like this. Sometimes, getting told what to do just makes you feel like doing the opposite, out of spite. Maybe it’s better to put resources into educating people about how their consumption practices affect the environment, and leave it to them to force manufacturers to change with their personal buying decisions.
Anyway, at the moment, I’m mostly feeling frustrated at how hard it is to “be responsible” in the kind of world we live in these days. I firmly believe that a big part of living a healthy lifestyle is being true to your own values, and my values do include doing what I can to maximize the good and minimize the harm I do to other people and creatures, and to the environment, through my own choices and habits as a consumer.
But sometimes, it feels like the only way to do that is to become almost obsessive about scrutinizing the moral and ecological implications of every personal choice you make–mainly because big manufacturers, advertisers, retailers and the government don’t seem to be thinking about these things much at all. And then you have to put a large amount of your own time into dealing with waste products and other problems that wouldn’t exist if things were done a little differently on the other end of the producer-consumer chain. That doesn’t seem right to me.
Or maybe I'm just feeling sorry for myself today?
How do you feel about and handle these issues? Are you going to celebrate Zero Waste Day?
Celebrate Zero Waste Day.
According to these people, my valiant efforts may be part of the problem, not part of the solution....
According to the Zero Waste people, the whole idea of recycling is mainly a gimmick perpetrated by manufacturers of soda, beer, juice, and bottled water to get themselves off the hook for providing socially and environmentally responsible packaging and put the burden for dealing with the problem of waste on us consumers. Instead of cooperating with this plan, they say, we should demand that these manufactures go back to putting their products in returnable/reusable bottles, and boycott products that come in plastic and non-reusable bottles.
Personally, I think this argument makes some good points. Recycling is a huge improvement over dumping all this junk into landfills, and we should all be responsible for cleaning up after ourselves. But recycling doesn’t do much to tackle the problems of excess waste and excessive use of non-biodegradable materials at the source of the problem: the manufacturing process. And there are other, proven ways of handling this problem that could accomplish this goal better, like the old reusable bottles with a refundable deposit that all soda and beer used to come in.
But there are drawbacks, too. Prices for these products would probably go up, and it is more work for consumers to schlepp glass bottles around than plastic bottles. And there’s always the question of how effective or appropriate it is for government to legislate how people should handle “lifestyle” problems like this. Sometimes, getting told what to do just makes you feel like doing the opposite, out of spite. Maybe it’s better to put resources into educating people about how their consumption practices affect the environment, and leave it to them to force manufacturers to change with their personal buying decisions.
Anyway, at the moment, I’m mostly feeling frustrated at how hard it is to “be responsible” in the kind of world we live in these days. I firmly believe that a big part of living a healthy lifestyle is being true to your own values, and my values do include doing what I can to maximize the good and minimize the harm I do to other people and creatures, and to the environment, through my own choices and habits as a consumer.
But sometimes, it feels like the only way to do that is to become almost obsessive about scrutinizing the moral and ecological implications of every personal choice you make–mainly because big manufacturers, advertisers, retailers and the government don’t seem to be thinking about these things much at all. And then you have to put a large amount of your own time into dealing with waste products and other problems that wouldn’t exist if things were done a little differently on the other end of the producer-consumer chain. That doesn’t seem right to me.
Or maybe I'm just feeling sorry for myself today?
How do you feel about and handle these issues? Are you going to celebrate Zero Waste Day?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > We Ate It: Amy's Multi-Grain Hot Cereal Bowl









.jpg)












Comments
No, I'm not going to get the manufacturers to change overnight, but if everyone decided to do nothing because they couldn't do everything exactly right, nothing would get done. Every little thing helps. I do like the idea of trying to support companies that work to reduce packaging when there are products already available. - 9/15/2009 1:00:56 PM
It is easy to blame corporations for all this trash but we need to see our part in over-consumption process. Not many people want to have a meaningful dialogue in the process because nobody wants to pay for these programs or work with the corporations. People don't want to pay taxes, don't want to be charged for the necessary services. They want corporations to pay for everything and still get the product at a deep discount instead of fair pay.
- 9/12/2009 7:10:58 AM
When people talk about food and packaging being cheap and easy, they forget to take into account the price they pay down the road. Health care costs are going up for everyone. People are sicker, more overweight, and lazier than ever before. There are people living near toxic landfills or factories that dump waste illegally. Even if you can afford your own health care, there are taxes to help out others who can't, so cheap and easy food and packaging, isn't necessarily cheap and easy. And most people could use the exercise it takes to schlepp those bottles around, but they won't.
I find another use for everything that I can. I use the back of paper, I compost, I filter water, I sell or donate old clothes and furniture. Most of the stuff I recycle is other people's stuff that they were throwing away. - 7/17/2009 2:56:58 PM
People tend to forget the importance of reduction and even reuse, because recycling is somewhat easier. - 5/27/2009 12:28:07 PM
Drinking filtered water instead of bottled water, avoiding soda entirely, & minimizing the purchase of drinks in throwaway OR recyclable cups are all things I do. But something I think about a LOT is all the plastic we waste with bath products, shampoos, lotions, etc. I would happily adapt to a more "primitive" system where we could go to a store with our cleaned-up glass containers & have fresh creams & cleansers dispensed into them. For practical reasons there would be less variety, but it would be much more sustainable.
Your ruminations show clearly that to deal with environmental problems, especially global climate change, we need BOTH changes in individual lifestyle AND the macro/structural (government-mandated) policies that enable our lifestyle changes. Neither is enough alone. - 4/1/2009 4:18:50 PM
PS. I didn't realize recycling wasn't that effective. - 3/16/2009 2:39:51 AM
Regardless of any government conspiracies, I think what you did was a good thing- but a BRILLIANT thing- that would be for all of us little nobodies to find out EXACTLY what those 'big boys on the block' are up to! LOL!! (haha, I laugh in the face of danger...) - 2/1/2009 3:59:33 PM
I disagree with Pada1... because this does not have anything to do with global warming. It has to do with the use of land and the damage done to wildlife by so many of our wast products. We need wildlife to maintain the balance and in the end to nourish us. If sea birds are getting liver damage from minute bits of plastic which we really do not need and have managed for years without, then we should be ashamed and concerned.
Given that manufacturers are so slow to respond, it is up to us to recycle. For example I use those juice cartons cut in half as pots to grow plants in; also as freezer containers. I get irritated that the makers use both plastic and waxed paper to make them so they are more expensive to recycle. Why not go back to the cut off corner rather than the plastic spout?
Clothes if not suitable for the charity shop or jumble sale, and old towels get used as cleaning cloths and I am interested that so many of the younger generation are now wanting to learn how to sew.
Styrofoam which comes with appliances is very useful in the bottom of large container pots as drainage and the large flat sheets I use to protect plants from frost. But I am lucky in that I have a garden and it is a problem in towns. But I think everyone can do something to reduce the amount in landfill even if it is only something small.
. - 12/23/2008 7:46:59 AM
Peace, Darlene - 11/27/2008 7:16:27 AM
We are given recycling bags (yellow bags) that we put cans, plastics, etc in. This works very well in my opinion.
Another thing we have is a bin for yard waste and food waste. It is large enough that we can use it for a year before emptying it. We are a family of 6, use one trash can that is collected once a month. - 11/16/2008 4:18:26 PM
I am waiting and praying that our government will wake up and take messures to protect our country and this planet. In the meantime I do work in the public and I can say that that an aweful lot of people do not really care!! - 11/16/2008 1:57:15 PM
I do prefer the plastic containers over the glass because of breakage, but I do recycle or reuse all of them.
Something else that isn't mentioned here is paper. I have put myself on the do not mail list and stopped all catalogs coming to me. I recycle all the junk mail that still comes and if the back side is blank, I use it in my computer to print things I want to print out or write notes on the back. I live alone and don't fill a 10 gal trash can every two weeks. I recycle everything I can. A lot of things there is no place to recycle here. - 11/16/2008 9:45:02 AM
Every small step we can take is a help, and starting with educating children will lead to improvements for their future. And in turn, the children will teach their parents how to reduce, reuse and recycle. - 11/15/2008 9:09:54 AM
I don't purchase beverages, I drink water and make tea or coffee.
As far as packaging, plastic seems to be unavoidable, but lately I have purchased small appliances packed in molded cardboard that goes right in my paper recycle bin. I think this is great. - 11/15/2008 8:50:38 AM
Last summer, my daughter went to a summer camp where she had to pack a lunch every day and they strongly encouraged a no waste lunch box. They wouldn't even allow the kids to bring a paper sack lunch. It made me think hard about how I pack her lunches during the school year. I try to put things in reusable containers now. - 11/15/2008 8:27:16 AM
For the longest time, I didn't bother returning the cans or bottles, and then I realized... somebody was making a profit off of me every time I put a can or bottle into the recycle bin at home... so I now collect the items, and when I have a few garbage bags full, I either bring them back to the store for my refund, or I donate them when there are bottle drives for fundraising. - 11/15/2008 2:39:04 AM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›