Would You Take Medical Advice From A Celebrity?
We are a society that is fascinated with the lives of celebrities. We like to know what they eat for dinner, where they shop for toothpaste and the details of their medical history. Many celebrities have been very open about their struggles with various diseases, in the hopes that they can inspire and educate others through their experiences. But when does it cross the line from sharing experiences, to giving medical advice that they aren't qualified to be dispensing?
Michael J. Fox has inspired millions through his struggle with Parkinson's Disease. He has raised money to research a cure and made this disease much more high-profile than it would have been otherwise. But you don't see him writing books about how to treat the condition, or giving others who have Parkinson's advice about how they should be handling the disease.
There are other celebrities who seem to cross the line from sharing experiences and bringing attention, to giving advice about treatment. Suzanne Somers is a good example. Her latest book, titled Knockout, discusses alternative cancer treatment therapies and disputes proven research in the area of cancer treatment and cures. Jenny McCarthy has been very vocal about the link between autism and vaccines, even though research has shown vaccines to be safe.
People look to celebrities like these for advice on how to treat their medical conditions. Are these celebrities just speaking out about things the medical community doesn't want you to know? Or are they crossing the line into territory they aren't qualified to discuss?
Should celebrities bear any additional responsibility to be careful about what they say because of who they are? Although many people would say they won't take advice from someone who's not a qualified expert, others put trust in celebrities that may or may not be justified. And honestly, it's much easier for a famous person to spread misinformation than it is for you or I to do it.
What do you think?
Michael J. Fox has inspired millions through his struggle with Parkinson's Disease. He has raised money to research a cure and made this disease much more high-profile than it would have been otherwise. But you don't see him writing books about how to treat the condition, or giving others who have Parkinson's advice about how they should be handling the disease.
There are other celebrities who seem to cross the line from sharing experiences and bringing attention, to giving advice about treatment. Suzanne Somers is a good example. Her latest book, titled Knockout, discusses alternative cancer treatment therapies and disputes proven research in the area of cancer treatment and cures. Jenny McCarthy has been very vocal about the link between autism and vaccines, even though research has shown vaccines to be safe.
People look to celebrities like these for advice on how to treat their medical conditions. Are these celebrities just speaking out about things the medical community doesn't want you to know? Or are they crossing the line into territory they aren't qualified to discuss?
Should celebrities bear any additional responsibility to be careful about what they say because of who they are? Although many people would say they won't take advice from someone who's not a qualified expert, others put trust in celebrities that may or may not be justified. And honestly, it's much easier for a famous person to spread misinformation than it is for you or I to do it.
What do you think?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |











.jpg)










Comments
- 5/9/2012 1:52:38 PM
You have to use your common sense and decide whether or not to listen to "high profile" advice. Check with your doctor in regards to questions you may have coming from celebrities, magazines and even blogs and let him/her advise you.
- 2/4/2011 9:05:44 AM
And about Jenny McCarthy: anyone who believes vaccines are safe are simply drastically uninformed, a blind follower - a sheep - who is not paying a lick of attention, or a blind follower refuses to look at the evidence because they are a traditional doc with large ego, or other similar reason for ego investment. I challenge you to look up in favorite search engine two words: Amish autism. Please, get informed people. This is the age of the internet. - 5/21/2010 1:57:09 AM
So I think if what the celebrity says sounds valid, then start researching to gather corroborating AND contradictory advice, and then talk to your doctor to get their expert advice. - 1/21/2010 10:56:39 AM
I also give credit to Michael J Fox too for making more people aware of what it is like to live with Parkinson's disease. Is he an expert ? no, but he's lending his voice in hopes of making more and more people aware. that's important.
I've read some of Suzanne Somers books and I do feel she is irresponsible. While she may have a doctor as a co-author for her books, she isn't qualified to be a spokesperson for woman's health especially when discussing hormone replacement. that's a very sensitive subject. There is no one right answer. So, for her to say do X, Y or Z instead of listening to your own doctor is irresponsible. As for the thigh master, it was mostly harmless.
While a celebrity endorsement might get my notice. ultimately, I'll wait for a professional medical opinion on the subject before forming any opinions of my own.
- 1/20/2010 9:28:48 AM
- 1/17/2010 9:25:34 PM
Dr. Sanjay Gupta. He went to Haiti as a medical correspondent, but when he arrived and saw the tragic situation, he became a doctor - which is his first commitment. His first patient? A 15 day old baby girl that needed his skills as a neurosurgeon. Until he was satisfied she was doing the best she could do with the severely limited conditions, he did not pick up the microphone.
We should have all of our celebrities with his talent. - 1/14/2010 9:22:29 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›